In 2017, a study published in Nature identified TP53 as the most-cited gene in scientific literature, a testament to its critical role as a tumor suppressor. However, measuring the "public life" of a gene—what the general population actually cares about—is a far more complex task than counting citations in PubMed. Two correspondence pieces published in Nature (Vol. 553, January 2018) explore this intersection of genomics and public interest, revealing how the creative naming conventions of biologists often collide with the realities of internet search data.
The Alignment of Science and Public Interest
At the highest levels of research, scientific importance and public curiosity often align. Both Kuan-lin Huang and the team of Mark B. Gerstein and Fabio C. P. Navarro found that TP53 holds the crown as both the most-searched and most-cited gene. This suggests that the most fundamental biological research eventually permeates the public consciousness, likely driven by the universal relevance of cancer research.
Beyond TP53, public interest is frequently driven by clinical utility and diagnostic availability. Genes associated with popular genetic testing kits, such as APOE (Alzheimer’s disease), SERPINA1 (antitrypsin deficiency), and CFTR (cystic fibrosis), show consistently high search volumes. Similarly, the recent surge in queries for PD-L1 tracks closely with the clinical success and media coverage of cancer immunotherapies.
The "Angelina Jolie Effect"
One of the most striking findings in the analysis of public interest is the role of celebrity news. Huang’s analysis of Google Trends data from 2004 to 2017 highlights the "Angelina Jolie Effect." Search queries for BRCA1 (a gene linked to breast and ovarian cancer) saw massive, unprecedented spikes in 2013 and 2015. These spikes coincided exactly with the actor’s public announcements regarding her preventive surgeries. This phenomenon demonstrates that public engagement with genetics is often event-driven rather than a steady accumulation of knowledge.
The Superman Problem: Lexical Ambiguity
While celebrity news provides a clear signal of public interest, other data points are far noisier. The primary challenge in tracking the public life of genes is lexical ambiguity—the fact that many genes are named after common words, phrases, or pop-culture icons.
This is particularly prevalent in the nomenclature of model organisms like Drosophila (fruit flies) and Arabidopsis (thale cress), where researchers have historically used more "creative" names. For example, the SUPERMAN gene in Arabidopsis appears to have a high search volume. However, this is almost certainly a "culturally hijacked" metric; the data is confounded by users searching for the DC Comics character rather than plant genetics.
Similarly, genes with names that are common English phrases or idioms—such as drop dead, cheap date, or Brokenheart—suffer from high false-positive rates. Gerstein and Navarro noted that this distortion is most pronounced in genes that are no longer the primary focus of current scientific literature but continue to attract "hits" due to their common-word names. Longer gene names that are full phrases are significantly more likely to produce distorted search data than short, alphanumeric codes.
Improving Scientific Communication
The confounding nature of gene nomenclature highlights a significant hurdle for data scientists and science communicators alike. Current methods for tracking public interest are often stymied by these linguistic overlaps. To gain a clearer picture of what the public truly understands about genetics, future research will require more sophisticated natural language processing (NLP) to disambiguate biological entities from common language.
Furthermore, the fact that the public is actively searching for these terms presents an opportunity. As Huang notes, the scientific community must improve timely and accurate communication to ensure that when a user searches for a gene—whether driven by a celebrity announcement or a medical diagnosis—they find high-quality, evidence-based information rather than linguistic noise or misinformation. Bridging the gap between the laboratory and the search engine remains a vital task for the genomic era.
Summary updated