Gene-centric intra- and inter-clade recombination in a context of Esche-richia coli subpopulations

Yu Kang, Xing Shi, Lina Yuan, Yanan Chu, Fei Chen, Zilong He, Zhancheng Gao, Xinmiao Jia, Qiang Lin, Qin Ma, Jian Wang, Rongrong Fu, Jiayan Wu, Jingfa Xiao, Songnian Hu, Jun YubioRxiv 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that Escherichia coli populations are structured into two major clades with distinct ecological niches, driven by extensive within-clade recombination that fosters adaptation and limited inter-clade recombination that acts as a barrier to speciation. This work provides a fine-scale map of recombination dynamics, offering crucial insights into bacterial evolution and the early stages of species divergence.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The role of recombination in bacterial evolution is a long-standing debate. While some theories suggest that recombination is rare and leads to genome-wide selective sweeps, others propose that bacteria behave more like quasi-sexual populations. A key challenge has been accurately inferring recombination events, especially in closely related strains, which is crucial for understanding how populations diverge and speciate. This paper aims to address this by providing a detailed, genome-wide analysis of recombination within E. coli, a model organism with diverse ecological roles, to understand its impact on population structure and early speciation.

Methods

The researchers employed a comparative genomics approach, leveraging a dataset of 104 complete E. coli genomes. They used a combination of SMRT (Single-Molecule Real-Time) and Illumina sequencing technologies for their in-house sequenced strains. To infer recombination events, they compared the synteny of identical fragments across genome pairs, identifying fragments that had moved locations as authentic recombinant events. This allowed them to generate a fine-scale map of recombination across the entire genome. They also utilized phylogenetic analysis (maximum-likelihood phylogeny) to define clades and assess genetic distance, and genome-scale models (GSMs) to predict metabolic profiles.

Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of 104 complete Escherichia coli genomes. Of these, 45 were newly sequenced in-house using SMRT and Illumina technologies from diverse animal hosts. The remaining genomes were obtained from public databases, including human-host strains and environmental strains.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Two Major E. coli Clades: The study clearly delineates E. coli into two major clades, termed "Vigorous" (Vig) and "Sluggish" (Slu), based on ecological and physiological characteristics, with distinct preferences for hosts, climates, and metabolic strategies.
  • Intra-clade Recombination Fuels Adaptation: Extensive recombination within each clade allows for rapid adaptation by breaking gene linkages and optimizing gene combinations for specific ecological niches. This makes strains within a clade behave like a "quasi-sexual" group.
  • Inter-clade Recombination as a Speciation Barrier: In contrast, recombination between the Vig and Slu clades is significantly reduced (approximately 10-fold less) and is strongly correlated with phylogenetic distance. This limited exchange acts as a genetic barrier, promoting the divergence and eventual speciation of these clades.
  • Core Genome Stability: While recombination is extensive, it primarily affects dispensable genes and does not disrupt the core genome framework or essential metabolic portfolios, suggesting strong selective pressures maintain these critical functions.
  • Gene Mobility Varies: Gene mobility is not uniform; core genes are generally stable, while dispensable genes, particularly those enriched in specific clades (clade-associated genes or CAGs), show higher mobility, contributing to clade-specific adaptations.

Key Results

  • Recombination Rate Disparity: Intra-clade recombination rates were found to be significantly higher than inter-clade rates. For instance, the total length of recombinant fragments within clades could reach up to 2Mb, while inter-clade fragments rarely exceeded 250kb.
  • Phylogenetic Correlation: Recombination intensity and fragment size were logarithmically correlated with phylogenetic distance, with closer relatives showing higher recombination rates.
  • Clade-Specific Genes: The study identified specific genes enriched in each clade (clade-associated genes, CAGs), with half of these being metabolic genes, highlighting the genetic basis for their distinct physiological and ecological traits.
  • Metabolic Differences: Genome-scale models predicted significant differences in nutrient uptake and metabolic products between the Vig and Slu clades, with Vig strains favoring taurine and xylose, and Slu strains preferring dulcose, maltose, and cellobiose.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that inferring recombination events can be challenging, especially with draft assemblies, and that very close strains might have underestimated recombination frequencies due to overlapping fragments. Future work could focus on elucidating the molecular mechanisms that create these phylogeny-restricted recombination barriers between clades. Further investigation into how these recombination dynamics influence the evolution of virulence and antibiotic resistance within these clades would also be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT Recombination is one of the most important mechanisms of prokaryotic species evolution but its exact roles are still in debate. Here we try to infer genome-wide recombination events within a species uti-lizing a dataset of 104 complete genomes of Escherichia coli from diverse origins, among which 45 from world-wide animal-hosts are in-house sequenced using SMRT (single-molecular real time) technology.Two major clades are identified based on evidences of ecological and physiological characteristics, as well as distinct genomic features implying scarce inter-clade genetic exchange. By comparing the synteny of identical fragments genome-widely searched for each genome pair, we achieve a fine-scale map of re-combination within the population. The recombination is rather extensive within clade, which is able to break linkages between genes but does not interrupt core genome framework and primary metabolic port-folios possibly due to natural selection for physiological compatibility and ecological fitness. Meanwhile,the recombination between clades declines drastically as the phylogenetic distance increases, generally 10-fold reduced than those of the intra-clade, which establishes genetic barrier between clades. These empirical data of recombination suggest its critical role in the early stage of speciation, where recombina-tion rate differs according to phylogentic distance. The extensive intra-clade recombination coheres sister strains into a quasi-sexual group and optimizes genes or alleles to streamline physiological activities,whereas shapely declined inter-clade recombination split the population into clades adaptive to divergent ecological niches. Significance Statement Roles of recombination in species evolution have been debated for decades due to difficulties in inferring recombination events during the early stage of speciation, especially when recombination is always complicated by frequent gene transfer events of bacterial genomes. Based on 104 high-quality complete E. coli genomes, we infer gene-centric dynamics of recombination in the formation of two E. coli clades or subpopulations, and recombination is found to be rather intensive in a within-clade fashion, which forces them to be quasi-sexual. The recombination events can be mapped among individual genomes in the context of genes and their variations; decreased between-clade and increased intra-claderecombination engender a genetic barrier that further encourages clade-specific secondary metabolic portfolios for better environmental adaptation. Recombination is thus a major force that accelerates bacterial evolution to fit ecological diversity.
BibTeX
@misc{kang2017gene,
  author = {Yu Kang and Xing Shi and Lina Yuan and Yanan Chu and Fei Chen and Zilong He and Zhancheng Gao and Xinmiao Jia and Qiang Lin and Qin Ma and Jian Wang and Rongrong Fu and Jiayan Wu and Jingfa Xiao and Songnian Hu and Jun Yu},
  title = {{Gene-centric intra- and inter-clade recombination in a context of <i>Esche-richia coli</i> subpopulations}},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1101/122713},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure