Gender differences and left-behind experiences in the relationship between gaming disorder, rumination and sleep quality among a sample of Chinese university students during the late stage of the COVID-19 pandemic

Li Li, Ligang Liu, Zhimin Niu, Huahua Zhong, Songli Mei, Mark D. GriffithsFrontiers in Psychiatry 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study utilizes network analysis to reveal a reciprocal "vicious cycle" between gaming disorder (GD), rumination, and poor sleep quality among Chinese university students. Surprisingly, while demographic factors like gender and "left-behind" childhood experiences affect the severity of these issues, they do not alter the underlying structure of how these symptoms interact with one another.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While the link between excessive gaming, repetitive negative thinking (rumination), and sleep debt is well-documented, researchers often treat them as isolated variables or simple linear cause-and-effect chains. This paper addresses two major gaps:

  1. The Systemic Interaction: How do specific symptoms of GD (like loss of control) interact directly with specific types of rumination or sleep disturbances?
  2. The Role of Background: Does the "wiring" of this psychological network change based on gender or "left-behind" experiences (a common situation in China where children remain in rural areas while parents migrate to cities for work)?

Understanding these interactions during the late stage of the COVID-19 pandemic provides a unique window into student mental health during a period of significant social transition.

Methods

The researchers moved beyond traditional regression models, employing Network Analysis (specifically the EBICglasso model). In this approach, psychological symptoms are viewed as "nodes" in a web, and the statistical associations between them are "edges."

Key instruments included:

  • Gaming Disorder Test (GDT): A four-item scale based on WHO criteria.
  • Short Version of Rumination Response Scale (RRS): Measuring brooding and reflection.
  • Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI): Assessing seven domains of sleep.

To compare groups (male vs. female; left-behind vs. non-left-behind), they used the Network Comparison Test (NCT) to see if the global strength or the specific structure of the networks differed significantly.

Datasets

The study analyzed a cross-sectional online survey of 1,872 Chinese university students (930 males, 942 females) recruited from eight universities across four provinces (Heilongjiang, Jiangxi, Liaoning, and Shannxi) between September and December 2021.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Vicious Cycle" Architecture: The network revealed that GD, rumination, and sleep quality are mutually reinforcing. For example, "daytime dysfunction" (from poor sleep) and "thinking about feelings alone" (rumination) acted as bridge symptoms that connected the different clusters of problems.
  • Core Symptoms of GD: The strongest connection in the entire network was between "continuation/escalation of gaming" (gd3) and "gaming problems" (gd4). The authors suggest these are the "heart" of gaming disorder in this population.
  • Structural Invariance: This is perhaps the most striking finding. While males reported higher levels of gaming and those with left-behind experiences reported poorer sleep, the Network Comparison Test showed no significant differences in network structure. This suggests that the psychological mechanism of how these problems feed into each other is universal across these demographic groups.
  • The Rumination Trigger: The node "Think ‘Why do I always react this way?’" (r3) was the most central rumination symptom, suggesting that self-critical questioning is a major driver of the broader psychological distress network.

Key Results

  • Prevalence: 3.5% of the sample met the criteria for Gaming Disorder, and 14% reported significant sleep disturbances.
  • Gender Differences: Males spent significantly more time gaming and had higher GD scores ($p < 0.001, d > 0.4$).
  • Left-Behind Impact: Students with left-behind experiences had significantly higher sleep disturbance scores ($p < 0.001$).
  • Network Stability: The network was statistically robust, with a Correlation Stability (CS) coefficient of 0.75, well above the recommended 0.25 threshold.
  • Non-Significant NCT: The network structure (M = 0.085, $p = 0.71$) and global strength ($p = 0.19$) showed no significant differences between genders, supporting the idea of a common underlying mechanism.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cross-Sectional Design: Because the data was collected at a single point in time, the "reciprocal" nature is inferred; longitudinal studies are needed to definitively prove the direction of causality.
  • Self-Report Bias: The study relies on subjective surveys rather than objective measures like sleep tracking (actigraphy) or clinical interviews for GD.
  • Context Specificity: The data reflects the "late stage" of the pandemic in China, where life had largely returned to normal. The results might differ in regions still under lockdown or in a post-pandemic world.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that interventions should target "bridge symptoms"—specifically reducing negative rumination—to simultaneously improve sleep and decrease the risk of gaming disorder.

Summary updated

Abstract

The results suggest reciprocal relationships between GD, rumination, and sleep quality. Gender and left-behind experiences did not influence the reciprocal relationship between GD, rumination, and sleep quality during the late stage of COVID-19 pandemic. Using network analysis, the findings provide novel insights that rumination and sleep quality may have interacted with GD among Chinese students during the late stage of COVID-19 pandemic. Reducing or eliminating negative rumination may decrease GD and improve sleep quality. Moreover, good sleep quality contributes to positive rumination which may decrease the risk of GD among Chinese university students.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2023gender,
  author = {Li Li and Ligang Liu and Zhimin Niu and Huahua Zhong and Songli Mei and Mark D. Griffiths},
  title = {{Gender differences and left-behind experiences in the relationship between gaming disorder, rumination and sleep quality among a sample of Chinese university students during the late stage of the COVID-19 pandemic}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychiatry},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyt.2023.1108016},
}
Figure