Gender Difference in Gender Bias: Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation Reduces Male’s Gender Stereotypes

Siqi Wang, Jinjin Wang, Wenmin Guo, Hang Ye, Xinbo Lu, Jun Luo, Haoli ZhengFrontiers in Human Neuroscience 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study used transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) to investigate the causal role of the medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC) in gender stereotypes. They found that anodal tDCS applied to the mPFC significantly reduced implicit gender bias in males, but not in females, suggesting a sex-specific neural basis for gender stereotyping.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Gender stereotypes are pervasive and influence social attitudes and behaviors. While previous research has implicated the medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC) in social cognition and stereotype formation, the precise causal role of the mPFC in gender stereotypes has remained unclear. Existing studies using lesion data and neuroimaging have provided correlational evidence, but a direct causal link has been difficult to establish. This paper aims to bridge this gap by using tDCS to directly modulate mPFC activity and observe its effect on implicit gender bias.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of neurostimulation and behavioral tasks:

  • Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation (tDCS): This non-invasive brain stimulation technique was used to modulate the excitability of the mPFC. Participants received either anodal tDCS (intended to increase cortical excitability), cathodal tDCS (intended to decrease excitability), or sham stimulation (as a control). The stimulation was applied over the Fpz position for 20 minutes.
  • Gender Implicit Association Test (IAT): This is a standard measure of implicit social biases. Participants rapidly categorized male/female names and "strong"/"weak" attribute words. The core idea is that faster reaction times when associating male names with strong attributes (and female names with weak attributes) indicate a stronger implicit bias. The D-IAT score quantifies this bias.
  • Ambivalent Sexism Inventory (ASI): This questionnaire was used to measure explicit attitudes towards women, assessing both hostile and benevolent sexism.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized participant data collected during the experiment.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • mPFC's Causal Role in Male Implicit Bias: The most striking finding is that directly stimulating the mPFC with anodal tDCS causally reduced implicit gender stereotypes in males. This provides strong evidence for the mPFC's involvement in regulating these biases.
  • Sex-Specific Neural Mechanisms: The effect of tDCS was significantly different between males and females. While anodal stimulation reduced bias in males, it had no significant effect on females. This suggests that the neural underpinnings of implicit gender stereotyping may differ between sexes.
  • Implicit vs. Explicit Bias: tDCS modulated implicit bias (IAT scores) but had no effect on explicit prejudice (ASI scores). This highlights the distinction between automatic, unconscious biases and consciously controlled attitudes, and suggests that the mPFC might be more critical for regulating the former.
  • Reaction Time Dynamics: The reduction in male D-IAT scores was primarily driven by a decrease in the difference in reaction times between congruent and incongruent blocks in the IAT. This indicates that tDCS altered how quickly participants processed stereotype-consistent vs. stereotype-inconsistent information.

Key Results

  • D-IAT Scores:
    • Male participants showed significantly higher D-IAT scores (indicating stronger implicit bias) than female participants across all stimulation conditions.
  • Anodal tDCS significantly reduced male participants' D-IAT scores compared to sham stimulation (p = 0.003).
  • Cathodal tDCS did not significantly alter male D-IAT scores compared to sham or anodal stimulation.
  • tDCS had no significant effect on female participants' D-IAT scores.
  • Reaction Times (RTs):
    • Males generally had longer RTs in incongruent blocks compared to congruent blocks, and this difference was significantly reduced by anodal tDCS (p = 0.023).
  • Females did not show significant modulation of RT differences by tDCS.
  • Explicit Prejudice (ASI):
    • tDCS had no significant effect on overall ASI scores for either males or females.
  • There were some gender differences in ASI subscales, with males showing higher benevolent sexism (BI, BP) and females showing higher hostile sexism (HS) and benevolent sexism (BG).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Neural Circuitry: While the study demonstrates the mPFC's causal role, it doesn't fully elucidate the specific neural circuitry involved. Future research could combine tDCS with neuroimaging techniques (like fMRI) to map these circuits.
  • tDCS Montage: The study used a bipolar tDCS montage. It's unclear if only the mPFC is influencing stereotypes or if the return electrode and their interaction play a role.
  • Between-Subject Design: The study used a between-subject design to avoid learning effects. Future studies could explore within-subject designs to further investigate these effects.
  • Cultural Nuances: The authors acknowledge that gender stereotypes are culture-sensitive, and cultural background might influence neural activity and bias. Future work could explore these cross-cultural differences more deeply.
  • Cathodal Stimulation: The lack of effect from cathodal tDCS might be due to the mPFC being less sensitive to this type of stimulation or a ceiling effect in baseline prejudice.

In conclusion, this study provides compelling evidence for the mPFC's causal role in implicit gender stereotyping, particularly in males, and highlights potential sex differences in the neural mechanisms underlying these biases.

Summary updated

Abstract

Stereotypes exist in the interactions between different social groups, and gender stereotypes are particularly prevalent. Previous studies have suggested that the medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC) is involved in the social cognition that plays an important role in gender stereotypes, but the specific causal effect of the mPFC remains controversial. In this study, we aimed to use transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) to identify a direct link between the mPFC and gender bias. Implicit stereotypes were measured by the gender implicit association test (IAT), and explicit prejudice was measured by the Ambivalent Sexism Inventory (ASI). We found that male and female participants had different behavioral and neural correlates of gender stereotypes. Anodal tDCS significantly reduced male participants' gender D-IAT scores compared with cathodal and sham stimulation, while the stimulation had an insignificant effect in female participants. The reduction in male participants' gender bias mainly resulted from a decrease in the difference in reaction time (RT) between congruent and incongruent blocks. Regarding the explicit bias measurement, male and female participants had distinct attitudes, but tDCS had no effect on ASI. Our results revealed that the mPFC played a causal role in controlling implicit gender stereotypes, which is consistent with previous observations and complements past lesion, neuroimaging, and transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) studies and suggests that males and females have different neural bases for gender stereotypes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2019gender,
  author = {Siqi Wang and Jinjin Wang and Wenmin Guo and Hang Ye and Xinbo Lu and Jun Luo and Haoli Zheng},
  title = {{Gender Difference in Gender Bias: Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation Reduces Male’s Gender Stereotypes}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Human Neuroscience},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3389/fnhum.2019.00403},
}
Figure