Gender, Age and Season as Modifiers of the Effects of Diurnal Temperature Range on Emergency Room Admissions for Cause-Specific Cardiovascular Disease among the Elderly in Beijing

Shan Zheng, Minzhen Wang, Bei Li, Shigong Wang, Shilin He, Ling Yin, Kezheng Shang, Tanshi LiInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that even small daily temperature fluctuations (Diurnal Temperature Range or DTR) can significantly increase emergency room (ER) visits for cardiovascular issues in the elderly in Beijing. Crucially, the impact of DTR isn't uniform; it disproportionately affects older individuals, females, and has different effects depending on the season, highlighting the need for targeted public health interventions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While the general impact of ambient temperature on health is well-established, the specific role of diurnal temperature range (DTR) – the difference between daily maximum and minimum temperatures – on cardiovascular disease (CVD) morbidity, especially among vulnerable populations, is less understood. DTR is a key indicator of climate variability and may offer more insight into health impacts than average temperature alone. The elderly are particularly susceptible to temperature changes due to physiological limitations. This paper aims to fill the gap in understanding how DTR affects cause-specific CVD ER admissions in the elderly and to identify specific subgroups (by age, gender, and season) that are most vulnerable.

Methods

The researchers employed a time-series analysis using a Poisson generalized additive model (GAM). This statistical approach is well-suited for analyzing count data (like ER admissions) and can model non-linear relationships between variables.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Controlling for confounders: The models rigorously adjusted for long-term trends, seasonal patterns, day of the week, public holidays, mean temperature, relative humidity, wind speed, atmospheric pressure, and air pollutants (PM10, NO2, SO2). This is crucial for isolating the specific effect of DTR.
  • Lagged effects: The study considered both single-day and cumulative-day lags for DTR, acknowledging that the impact of temperature changes might not be immediate.
  • Stratified analysis: The core of the study involved analyzing the DTR-CVD admission relationship separately for different age groups (65-74 vs. ≥75 years) and genders (male vs. female).
  • Seasonal interaction: The researchers specifically investigated how the effect of DTR might differ between the warm season (May-October) and the cold season (November-April) by including interaction terms.
  • Statistical significance testing: Differences in effect estimates between subgroups were assessed using a specific formula to determine statistical significance.

Datasets

  • Emergency Room (ER) Admissions Data: Daily ER admissions for cause-specific cardiovascular diseases (all cardiovascular disease, hypertensive disease, ischemic heart disease, and cerebrovascular disease) for individuals aged 65 years and older in Beijing from January 1, 2009, to December 31, 2011. Data was collected from three large-scale comprehensive hospitals in the Haidian District.
  • Meteorological Data: Daily data including minimum, maximum, and mean temperature, relative humidity, mean wind speed, and atmospheric pressure from a fixed-site station in the Daxing District of Beijing for the same study period. DTR was calculated from this data.
  • Air Pollution Data: Daily data on urban sulfur dioxide (SO2), nitrogen dioxide (NO2), and particulate matter less than 10 µm in aerodynamic diameter (PM10) from the Beijing Public Net for Environmental Protection website.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • DTR is a significant independent risk factor: Even after accounting for average temperature and air pollution, DTR consistently showed a significant association with ER admissions for CVD. This suggests DTR captures a unique aspect of climate variability that impacts health.
  • The elderly are particularly vulnerable: Individuals aged 75 and older were found to be more susceptible to the adverse effects of DTR compared to the younger elderly group (65-74). This highlights the importance of considering age-related physiological changes.
  • Gender matters: Females showed a stronger association between DTR and ER admissions for all cardiovascular and ischemic heart disease compared to males. This points to potential biological or behavioral differences influencing susceptibility.
  • Seasonality plays a role: While DTR had adverse effects in both seasons, the impact was generally stronger in the warm season for both genders. However, for females, the effect was found to be higher in the cold season than in the warm season, suggesting a complex interaction.
  • Cause-specific effects are important: The study didn't just look at general CVD but broke it down into specific types, revealing nuances in how DTR affects different cardiovascular conditions.

Key Results

  • A short-term increase of 1°C in Diurnal Temperature Range (DTR) was significantly associated with increased ER admissions for cause-specific cardiovascular diseases among the elderly in Beijing.
  • Gender differences:
    • Females showed higher DTR effects for all cardiovascular disease (1.46% increase per 1°C DTR at lag 01) and ischemic heart disease (1.71% increase per 1°C DTR at lag 02) compared to males.
  • For cerebrovascular disease, the effect of DTR was higher in males with cumulative-day lags.
  • Age differences:
    • Individuals aged 75 and over were more vulnerable. For example, for females aged ≥75, a 1°C increase in DTR was associated with a 2.23% increase in all cardiovascular disease ER admissions, compared to 0.74% for females aged 65-74.
  • Seasonal differences:
    • In the warm season, significant positive relationships were observed for females with all cardiovascular and cerebrovascular disease, and for males with cerebrovascular disease.
  • In the cold season, significant effects were observed only in females for all cardiovascular disease and cerebrovascular disease.
  • The effect estimates for females aged ≥75 were larger in the cold season than in the warm season for cerebrovascular disease.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Geographic scope: ER admission data was collected from only three hospitals in Beijing, potentially leading to selection bias.
  • Exposure measurement: Using a single meteorological station's data as a proxy for personal exposure to DTR might lead to exposure misclassification.
  • Socioeconomic factors: The study could not analyze the modifying effects of socioeconomic and educational levels due to data limitations.
  • First-time vs. repeat admissions: The distinction between first-time ER admissions and those with a history of admissions was not considered.
  • Indoor vs. outdoor temperature: The influence of air conditioning and indoor-outdoor temperature differences, which could mitigate DTR effects, was not analyzed due to data unavailability.

Future research directions suggested include:

  • Investigating the underlying physiological mechanisms by which DTR induces pathophysiological responses and cardiovascular diseases.
  • Conducting similar studies in other regions to assess the generalizability of findings.
  • Exploring the role of socioeconomic factors and indoor environmental conditions (like air conditioning use) in modifying DTR's health effects.

Summary updated

Abstract

A short-term increase of DTR was significantly associated with ER admissions for cause-specific cardiovascular disease among the elderly in Beijing. Gender, age and season may modify the acute health effect of DTR. Some prevention programs that target the high risk subgroups in the elderly for impending large temperature changes may reduce the impact of DTR on people's health.
BibTeX
@article{zheng2016gender,
  author = {Shan Zheng and Minzhen Wang and Bei Li and Shigong Wang and Shilin He and Ling Yin and Kezheng Shang and Tanshi Li},
  title = {{Gender, Age and Season as Modifiers of the Effects of Diurnal Temperature Range on Emergency Room Admissions for Cause-Specific Cardiovascular Disease among the Elderly in Beijing}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph13050447},
}
Figure