Gel-Induced Selective Crystallization of Polymorphs

Ying Diao, Kristen E. Whaley, Matthew E. Helgeson, Mahlet A. Woldeyes, Patrick S. Doyle, Allan S. Myerson, T. Alan Hatton, Bernhardt L. TroutJournal of the American Chemical Society 2011 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces polymer microgels as a novel material for precisely controlling the crystallization of different polymorphs (crystal forms) of molecules. By tuning the microgel's internal structure, the researchers demonstrated significant improvements in polymorph selectivity, offering a new avenue for controlling crystal formation in various applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Polymorphism, the ability of a compound to exist in multiple crystal forms, is a critical challenge in many fields, especially pharmaceuticals, as different polymorphs can have vastly different physical properties (e.g., solubility, stability, bioavailability). While nanoporous materials have been explored to control this phenomenon, the underlying mechanisms, particularly the kinetic aspects and the influence of the substrate's local structure, remain poorly understood. Existing methods often struggle with reproducibility and achieving high selectivity, especially for molecules that readily form multiple polymorphs simultaneously (concomitant crystallization). This paper aims to address this gap by investigating how a tunable, nanoconfined environment, provided by polymer microgels, can systematically influence polymorph crystallization and elucidate the key factors driving selectivity.

Methods

The researchers synthesized polymer microgels from poly(ethylene glycol) diacrylate (PEGDA) with varying molecular weights, which allowed them to control the internal mesh size of the gel. These microgels, when swollen in solution, create a nanoconfined environment. The crystallization experiments were conducted using two model compounds: carbamazepine (CBZ), known for packing polymorphism, and ROY, known for conformational polymorphism.

Key techniques employed include:

  • Microgel Synthesis: Stop-flow lithography was used to create monodispersed cubelike PEGDA microgels.
  • Microstructure Characterization: Swelling measurements and the Flory-Rehner theory were used to estimate the average mesh size of the swollen polymer network.
  • Crystallization Experiments: Supersaturation was generated by cooling ethanol solutions containing the model compounds and microgels.
  • Nucleation Induction Time Measurement: A Thermo Fisher Scientific RS10 Clarity Station was used to monitor the time it took for crystallization to begin, using IR transmission signals. This data was fitted with stretched exponential models to determine average induction times.
  • Polymorph Identification and Quantification: X-ray diffraction (XRD) was the primary tool for identifying the crystal forms present. For CBZ, the mass fraction of different polymorphs was quantified. For ROY, the frequency of occurrence of each polymorph was measured.
  • Partition Coefficient Measurements: The distribution of solute molecules between the gel and the bulk solution was measured to understand preferential partitioning.
  • Crystal Preferred Orientation Studies: Flat PEGDA films were used to investigate interfacial interactions and their influence on crystal orientation, analyzed by XRD.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data generated from crystallization experiments with model compounds (CBZ and ROY) in various conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Microgels as Tunable Crystallization Reactors: Polymer microgels, with their controllable internal structure (mesh size), act as effective nanoreactors that can significantly influence crystallization outcomes.
  • Kinetic Control is Key: The observed polymorph selectivity is strongly correlated with changes in nucleation kinetics (induction time). Microgels can dramatically accelerate nucleation, often favoring specific polymorphs.
  • Dual Role of Microgels: Microgels exert control through two primary mechanisms:
  • Nanoconfinement: The physical restriction of space within the gel network influences molecular mobility and nucleation.
  • Nucleation Templating: Specific interactions between the polymer chains and the solute molecules guide the initial arrangement of molecules, lowering the nucleation barrier for certain polymorphs.
  • Mesh Size Matters: The size of the microgel's internal pores (mesh size) is a critical parameter. There appears to be an "optimum" mesh size that maximizes selectivity for a particular polymorph, suggesting a delicate balance between confinement and interaction.
  • Interfacial Interactions Drive Selectivity: For CBZ, specific interactions between the vinyl group of the molecule and the PEG subchain of the microgel were identified as crucial for templating form II nucleation. For ROY, different interactions with PEG and acrylate components of the microgel influenced the selectivity towards different polymorphs.
  • Accessing New Parameter Space: Microgels enable crystallization in conditions or with selectivities that are difficult or impossible to achieve with conventional bulk methods.

Key Results

  • CBZ Crystallization:
    • In bulk solution, CBZ typically crystallized as a mixture of forms I and II, with occasional form III.
  • With PEGDA microgels, particularly those with larger mesh sizes (M > 400 g/mol), pure form II was exclusively obtained.
  • Microgels significantly reduced the nucleation induction time for CBZ, with a strong correlation between accelerated nucleation and form II selectivity.
  • ROY Crystallization:
    • In bulk, ROY predominantly crystallized as form Y, with occasional R and ON forms.
  • Microgels significantly improved the frequency of occurrence of the metastable form R, achieving up to a 20-fold increase compared to bulk.
  • An optimum mesh size (around M = 575 g/mol) was found to maximize the selectivity for form R.
  • Microgels also accelerated the nucleation of all ROY polymorphs, with different mesh sizes favoring different forms.
  • Partitioning: CBZ and ROY showed preferential partitioning into the microgels, with concentrations in the gel being 3-4 times higher for CBZ and 6-11 times higher for ROY than in the bulk solution. This partitioning increased with larger microgel mesh sizes.
  • Templating Effect: XRD analysis of ROY crystals grown on flat PEGDA films revealed preferred crystal orientations, providing direct evidence for the nucleation-templating effect of the polymer surface.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Reproducibility of Bulk Crystallization: The authors acknowledge that CBZ crystallization can be sensitive to experimental conditions (e.g., impurities, water content, stirring speed), which can lead to inconsistencies in previous reports. They meticulously controlled these factors in their study.
  • Understanding Complex Systems: While the study provides mechanistic insights, fully rational design of polymorph control would require a deeper molecular understanding of the nucleation process and reaction coordinates, which is an ongoing area of research for the group.
  • Generalizability: The study focused on two model compounds. Further research is needed to assess the applicability of polymer microgels to a wider range of molecules and crystallization systems.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that selective crystallization of desired polymorphs could be achieved by designing specific polymer chemistries and microstructures. They also highlight the need for detailed molecular understanding of nucleation processes, which is a focus of their ongoing work.

Summary updated

Abstract

Although nanoporous materials have been explored for controlling crystallization of polymorphs in recent years, polymorphism in confined environments is still poorly understood, particularly from a kinetic perspective, and the role of the local structure of the substrate has largely been neglected. Herein, we report the use of a novel material, polymer microgels with tunable microstructure, for controlling polymorph crystallization from solution and for investigating systematically the effects of nanoconfinement and interfacial interactions on polymorphic outcomes. We show that the polymer microgels can improve polymorph selectivity significantly. The polymorphic outcomes correlate strongly with the gel-induced nucleation kinetics and are very sensitive to both the polymer microstructure and the chemical composition. Further mechanistic investigations suggest that the nucleation-templating effect and the spatial confinement imposed by the polymer network may be central to achieving polymorph selectivity. We demonstrate polymer microgels as promising materials for controlling crystal polymorphism. Moreover, our results help advance the fundamental understanding of polymorph crystallization at complex interfaces, particularly in confined environments.
BibTeX
@article{diao2011gel,
  author = {Ying Diao and Kristen E. Whaley and Matthew E. Helgeson and Mahlet A. Woldeyes and Patrick S. Doyle and Allan S. Myerson and T. Alan Hatton and Bernhardt L. Trout},
  title = {{Gel-Induced Selective Crystallization of Polymorphs}},
  journal = {Journal of the American Chemical Society},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1021/ja210006t},
}
Figure