GDynamic stiffness and transmissibility of commercially available wheelchair cushions using a laboratory test method

Yasmin Garcia-Mendez, Jonathan Pearlman, Rory A. Cooper, Michael L. BoningerThe Journal of Rehabilitation Research and Development 2012 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated how different wheelchair cushions affect vibration transmission to users. They found that while lab tests using a material testing system (MTS) can characterize cushion stiffness, these results didn't accurately predict real-world vibration transmission during manual wheelchair use. Air-based cushions generally offered better vibration dampening than foam or gel options.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Wheelchair (WC) users are at a higher risk of back and neck pain, and whole-body vibration (WBV) is a suspected contributing factor. While it's known that WC cushions play a role in vibration transmission, there's a lack of conclusive evidence on how different cushion types perform in real-world scenarios. Existing lab methods for testing cushion transmissibility often combine the cushion and the user into a single system, making it hard to isolate the cushion's properties. This study aims to bridge this gap by comparing two methods: a controlled lab test using a material testing system (MTS) and a more realistic test involving human subjects propelling a WC over a simulated road course. The goal is to see if lab-based characterization can reliably predict real-world performance and to identify which cushion types are best at reducing vibration.

Methods

The researchers employed two primary methods to evaluate wheelchair cushion transmissibility:

  1. Material Testing System (MTS) Characterization:
    • Seven commercially available WC cushions were tested.
  2. A material testing system (MTS) was used to measure the dynamic stiffness of each cushion. This involved applying random vibration to the cushion under various preload conditions (300-800 N).
  3. The dynamic stiffness was modeled using a K + Cω relationship, allowing for the estimation of static stiffness (K) and viscous damping (C) parameters.
  4. Mathematical models of the human body's apparent mass (one-degree-of-freedom [ODOF] and two-degree-of-freedom [TDOF] models) were also used in conjunction with the cushion stiffness data to predict transmissibility.
  5. Wheelchair Road Course (WRC) Testing:
    • Fourteen nondisabled subjects propelled a manual WC equipped with each of the seven cushions over a simulated road course.
  6. This course included various obstacles designed to mimic daily activities (e.g., curb descents, bumps, industrial carpet).
  7. Accelerometers were placed at the WC-cushion interface (below the cushion on the WC frame) and the cushion-human interface (above the cushion) to measure input and output accelerations.
  8. Seated transmissibility was calculated as the ratio of output to input acceleration.
  9. Vibration Dose Value (VDV) transmissibility was also calculated as a measure of vibration exposure.

The study then compared the results from the MTS characterization (including the mathematical models) with the WRC test results.

Datasets

Not explicitly discussed as datasets in the traditional machine learning sense. The study utilized:

  • Seven commercially available wheelchair cushions: These served as the subjects of the experiments.
  • Data from 14 nondisabled human subjects: Used for the WRC testing to simulate real-world user experience.
  • Existing mathematical models of human apparent mass: Specifically, ODOF and TDOF models from Wei and Griffin were used.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Lab vs. Real-World Disconnect: The most significant finding is that laboratory characterization of cushion stiffness using an MTS, even when combined with human body models, did not correlate well with actual vibration transmissibility measured during manual WC propulsion on a road course. This highlights the complexity of simulating real-world conditions in a controlled lab setting.
  • Air Cushions Excel: Air-based cushions (or those with air components) consistently demonstrated lower transmissibility in the WRC test compared to foam- or gel-based cushions. This suggests they are more effective at dampening vibrations experienced during dynamic use.
  • Mathematical Models Fall Short: The ODOF and TDOF models, while useful for some applications, overestimated transmissibility at lower frequencies and underestimated it at frequencies between 8-12 Hz in the WRC test. This indicates that current models may not fully capture the dynamic behavior of the cushion-human system during actual WC use.
  • Frequency Content Matters: The power spectral density (PSD) of the vibration encountered on the WRC was not flat, unlike the input used in the MTS tests. This variable frequency content likely contributed to the discrepancies between the two testing methods.

Key Results

  • MTS vs. WRC Correlation: The study found a poor correlation between transmissibility measured by the MTS and that measured during the WRC test.
  • Cushion Type Performance: Air-based cushions (e.g., ROHO HIGH PROFILE, Meridian Wave) generally showed lower transmissibility in the WRC test compared to foam (Comfort Mate Foam) and gel (Jay J2 Deep Contour) cushions.
  • VDV Differences: VDV transmissibility results from the WRC showed significant differences between cushions, with air cushions again performing better.
  • Model Prediction Accuracy: Both ODOF and TDOF models significantly overestimated maximum seat transmissibility compared to WRC measurements.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Nondisabled Subjects: The study used nondisabled subjects to represent WC users. The authors acknowledge that disabled individuals may have different biomechanics and body characteristics that could affect seat transmissibility.
  • Single WC Type: Only one type of manual WC was used, and it was not custom-fitted to participants, which could influence results.
  • MTS vs. WRC Discrepancy: The poor correlation between MTS and WRC results indicates a need for improved mathematical models that better predict dynamic response during WC propulsion.
  • Future Directions:
    • Develop more accurate mathematical models of the human-cushion system for WC propulsion.
  • Explore the use of different indenters for MTS testing (e.g., ISO 16840-2 compliant) to better represent human anatomy.
  • Investigate cushion performance in absorbing impacts from obstacles like curb descents.
  • Conduct future research with disabled subjects to account for individual biomechanics.
  • Collect long-term, in-community vibration exposure data to complement lab and controlled road course studies.
  • Develop dynamic road simulators for more realistic testing without requiring disabled subjects.

Summary updated

Abstract

Evidence suggests that wheelchair (WC) users are exposed to unhealthy levels of vibration during WC use. Health risks associated with vibration exposure include vertebral disc degeneration and back pain, which may consequently decrease the function and independence of WC users. Some evidence suggests that the cushions used in WCs may amplify vibrations, although conclusive evidence has not been presented in the literature. This study evaluated and compared the transmissibility of commercially available WC cushions with two laboratory test methods: (1) direct measurement of transmissibility while human subjects propelled a WC over a road course with different cushions and (2) characterization of cushions with a material testing system (MTS) combined with mathematical models of the apparent mass of the human body. Results showed that although dynamic characterization of WC cushions is possible with an MTS, the results did not correlate well with the transmissibility obtained in the WC road course. Significant differences were found for transmissibility among the cushions tested, with the air-based cushions having lower transmissibility than the foam- or gel-based cushions.
BibTeX
@article{garciamendez2012gdynamic,
  author = {Yasmin Garcia-Mendez and Jonathan Pearlman and Rory A. Cooper and Michael L. Boninger},
  title = {{GDynamic stiffness and transmissibility of commercially available wheelchair cushions using a laboratory test method}},
  journal = {The Journal of Rehabilitation Research and Development},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1682/jrrd.2011.02.0023},
}
Figure