Gaze in Film and Television from the Perspective of Post-colonialism: Taking the Film "Anatomy of a Fall" as an Example

M. Hu, Lifeng LuoJournal of Education Humanities and Social Sciences 2025 · DOI

Abstract

Against the backdrop of the global rise of feminism, films directed by women are increasingly attracting critical attention. However, academic discussions regarding gender imbalance and social scrutiny within gender relations remain insufficient. This study focuses on the 2023 film Anatomy of a Fall, utilizing Post-colonialism and "Gaze" theory to explore how ethnicity, gender, and identity intersect to shape the expression of power dynamics. Through a sociocultural lens and literature analysis, the paper interprets the phenomena of the gaze and the "anti-gaze," revealing the complexity of gendered scrutiny in a post-colonial context. The study finds that the film challenges traditional gender models through strategic film language and spatial reversals. Furthermore, this research addresses a gap in the Chinese academic community regarding this film, providing a new perspective on the gender dimensions of modern cinema.

Introduction: The Dilemma of the Gendered Gaze

While feminist cinema has gained significant traction, the intersectional complexities of gender, ethnicity, and identity are often overlooked in mainstream analysis. Specifically, the "gaze"—the mechanism through which power structures view and categorize individuals—remains a potent force in social and cinematic narratives. Justine Triet’s Anatomy of a Fall serves as a critical case study for examining these dynamics. The film does not merely present a legal mystery; it depicts a struggle for narrative autonomy against a patriarchal and "colonial" social gaze.

Theoretical Framework

To deconstruct the film’s power dynamics, this study integrates several key theoretical frameworks:

  • Post-colonialism and Hybridity (Homi Bhabha): Analyzing the protagonist, Sandra, as a "colonized" subject due to her status as a German woman in the French legal system.
  • Gaze Theory: Exploring the dialectic between the self and the "Other," and the emergence of the "anti-gaze"—the reclamation of the right to master one's own story.
  • Gendered Space (Derek Gregory): Examining how physical environments, such as the home and the courtroom, reflect and reinforce power imbalances.
  • Field Theory (Pierre Bourdieu): Viewing marriage as a competitive "field" where partners vie for capital, including status, discourse power, and emotional resources.

Spatial Reversal: The Domestic Field as a Site of Conflict

A central insight of this analysis is the reversal of traditional gendered spaces. Historically, patriarchal norms relegate women to the "private/internal" sphere of the home while men occupy the "public/external" sphere of professional success. Anatomy of a Fall flips this script: Sandra is the successful, public-facing writer, while her husband, Samuel, is confined to the private sphere of home renovations and childcare.

This reversal is identified as the core source of the couple's fatal friction. Samuel’s struggle to reconcile his domestic reality with societal expectations of masculinity leads to a breakdown in the marriage field. The film suggests that the patriarchal gaze "otherizes" both characters: Sandra is judged for being "too strong" and "unfeminine," while Samuel is marginalized for his perceived emotional fragility.

Language as a Tool of the Anti-Gaze

Sandra’s identity as a German living in France creates a "hybrid" state. Her refusal to speak French—the language of the court and the dominant culture—and her insistence on using English is framed as a strategic power move. By forcing the court to rely on translators, she disrupts the directness of their gaze. This linguistic barrier allows her to maintain her status as a subject rather than a passive object of judgment. This "anti-gaze" strategy enables her to navigate the trial by maintaining her own rational and linguistic territory.

Quantitative Analysis of Discourse Power

In addition to qualitative analysis, the study employs a psycholinguistic approach to measure the protagonist's autonomy. The authors analyzed approximately 58 minutes of trial dialogue, focusing on subject-verb structures.

The findings reveal that Sandra uses the first person ("I") as the subject in 44% of her statements, whereas she refers to her husband (the third person) only 35% of the time. This quantitative data provides empirical evidence of Sandra reclaiming "discourse power." By consistently positioning herself as the subject of her sentences, she asserts her agency and resists the court's attempt to define her through the lens of her husband's death.

Conclusion

Anatomy of a Fall serves as a benchmark for understanding modern gender relations. The study concludes that the film’s use of "anti-gaze" strategies—specifically the mastery of language and the subversion of spatial norms—offers a viable path for female self-affirmation. By revealing the dynamic changes in the roles and social structures of individuals within the marriage field, the film provides new ideas for the harmonious development of gender relations. While this single-film case study has limitations, it opens a necessary dialogue on the intersection of post-colonial identity and gendered scrutiny in contemporary cinema.

Summary updated

Abstract

Against the backdrop of the current rise of feminism around the world, films directed by women are increasingly attracting attention. However, discussions on gender imbalance and social scrutiny in gender relations are still insufficient. This study focuses on Anatomy of a Fall and uses Post-colonialism and "Gaze" theory to explore how ethnicity, gender, and identity in the film affect the expression of gender relations. Through socio-cultural perspective and literature analysis, the phenomenon of gaze and anti-gaze in films is interpreted, revealing the complexity of gender gaze and its special significance in post-colonialism. The study found that Anatomy of a Fall not only presents the diversity of gender gaze but also shows its intersection with ethnicity, gender, and identity in the context of post-colonialism. The director challenges the traditional gender gaze model through film language, which has a profound impact on gender relations. This study reveals the complexity of gender gaze in the context of post-colonialism, provides new ideas for the harmonious development of gender, and emphasizes the importance of Bourdieu's field theory in understanding the confrontation of gendered space, revealing the dynamic changes in the position, role and social structure of gender individuals in the marriage field. In addition, this study fills the gap in the research on this film in the Chinese academic community, opens up a new perspective for the study of the gender dimension of gender relations in films directed by women, and has important academic and practical significance.
BibTeX
@article{hu2025gaze,
  author = {M. Hu and Lifeng Luo},
  title = {{Gaze in Film and Television from the Perspective of Post-colonialism: Taking the Film "Anatomy of a Fall" as an Example}},
  journal = {Journal of Education Humanities and Social Sciences},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.54097/1q6smf13},
}
Figure