Gauge theories and dessins d’enfants: beyond the torus

Sownak Bose, James Gundry, Yang‐Hui HeJournal of High Energy Physics 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores the deep connections between supersymmetric gauge theories and the mathematical concept of "dessins d'enfants" (child's drawings). The authors extend the known relationship between these theories and dessins from the familiar torus (genus 1) to higher-genus Riemann surfaces, providing a systematic way to classify and construct these complex structures. This work offers a valuable bridge between theoretical physics and number theory, with potential applications in understanding fundamental physics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the challenge of understanding the structure of four-dimensional supersymmetric gauge theories, particularly those with toric moduli spaces. These theories have been found to be intimately related to "brane tilings" and "dimer models," which can be abstractly represented by mathematical objects called "dessins d'enfants." While this connection has been well-studied for the simplest case of a torus (genus 1), extending this understanding to more complex Riemann surfaces (higher genera) has been a significant open problem. The authors aim to provide a systematic framework for classifying and constructing these dessins and their corresponding gauge theories for arbitrary genera, moving "beyond the torus."

Methods

The core of the paper lies in the concept of a "Belyi pair," which consists of a Riemann surface and a specific type of map (a holomorphic covering) to the complex projective line. The authors leverage Belyi's theorem, which states that such pairs can be defined over rational numbers, linking them to number theory. They systematically explore Belyi pairs for different genera, starting with genus 0 (the sphere) and moving to higher genera. Key techniques include:

  • Riemann-Hurwitz formula: Used to relate the genus of a surface, the degree of a map, and the number and types of ramification points.
  • Explicit computation of Belyi pairs: This involves finding specific algebraic curves and rational functions that satisfy the conditions of a Belyi pair.
  • Use of invariants: For higher genera, the authors employ generalized versions of the elliptic j-invariant, such as Igusa and Shioda invariants, to classify and characterize the underlying curves.
  • Combinatorial manipulations: Techniques for combining existing Belyi maps to generate new ones are explored.
  • Number field parameterizations: The authors investigate defining Belyi pairs over number fields beyond the complex numbers, opening up new avenues for parameterization.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical constructions and calculations rather than empirical data analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dessins d'enfants as a unifying language: The paper reinforces the idea that dessins d'enfants provide a powerful and elegant way to encode the complex structures of supersymmetric gauge theories across different genera.
  • Generalization beyond the torus: The work demonstrates that the rich interplay between physics, geometry, combinatorics, and number theory observed for toroidal brane tilings extends to higher-genus surfaces, opening up new frontiers for research.
  • The power of invariants: The use of Igusa and Shioda invariants for genus 2 and 3, respectively, highlights their crucial role in classifying and understanding these complex mathematical objects, analogous to the j-invariant for elliptic curves.
  • Computational tractability: While explicit computations can be challenging, the paper showcases how systematic approaches and the use of computational tools can lead to the discovery and classification of new Belyi pairs.
  • Number fields as a new parameterization space: Exploring Belyi pairs over number fields beyond the complex numbers reveals a richer landscape of possible structures and parameterizations.

Key Results

The paper provides:

  • A discussion and partial classification of Belyi pairs for genera other than one.
  • Explicit computation of Belyi pairs for genus 0, 2, and 3.
  • Demonstration of how Igusa and Shioda invariants can be used to characterize genus 2 and 3 hyperelliptic curves, respectively.
  • A systematic algorithm for generating Belyi pairs for arbitrary genera, particularly for cases with three ramification points.
  • A catalogue of genus 0, 1, and 2 Belyi maps, graded by degree, which can serve as a valuable resource for researchers.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that:

  • The explicit computation of Belyi pairs can be computationally prohibitive, especially for higher degrees and genera.
  • Not all ramification structures found necessarily translate to physically relevant gauge theories, as some have indices equal to 1.
  • The construction of Belyi pairs can be difficult, particularly when forcing specific ramification structures at the point 'one'.

Future work suggested by the paper includes:

  • Further exploration of the relationship between Belyi pairs and gauge theories for higher genera.
  • Developing more efficient algorithms for computing Belyi pairs.
  • Investigating the use of number field parameterizations to reformulate any Belyi pair.
  • Applying these findings to a broader range of physics problems, such as understanding scattering amplitudes and exploring new gauge theories.

Summary updated

Abstract

Dessin d’enfants on elliptic curves are a powerful way of encoding doubly-periodic brane tilings, and thus, of four-dimensional supersymmetric gauge theories whose vacuum moduli space is toric, providing an interesting interplay between physics, geometry, combinatorics and number theory. We discuss and provide a partial classification of the situation in genera other than one by computing explicit Belyi pairs associated to the gauge theories. Important also is the role of the Igusa and Shioda invariants that generalise the elliptic j-invariant.
BibTeX
@article{bose2015gauge,
  author = {Sownak Bose and James Gundry and Yang‐Hui He},
  title = {{Gauge theories and dessins d’enfants: beyond the torus}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1007/jhep01(2015)135},
}
Figure