Abstract
After a general discussion on the choice of gauge, we compare the quark propagator in the background of one instanton in regular and singular gauge with a gauge invariant propagator obtained by inserting a path-ordered gluon exponential. Using a gauge motivated by this analysis, we were able to obtain a finite result for the quark condensate without introducing an infrared cutoff nor invoking some instanton model.
Introduction
In Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), the vacuum is not a simple void but a complex medium filled with topological fluctuations known as instantons. These localized gluonic field "bubbles" play a critical role in chiral symmetry breaking—the process by which quarks acquire their dynamical mass. However, theoretical treatments of instantons frequently encounter the "Infrared Problem": the mathematical density of instantons increases rapidly as their size ($\rho$) grows. In standard calculations, this leads to divergent results for physical quantities like the quark condensate unless an arbitrary infrared cutoff is manually introduced.
This paper addresses this fundamental instability by examining the role of gauge choice in the definition of the quark propagator. By constructing a gauge-invariant propagator, the author demonstrates that the infrared divergence is largely a mathematical artifact of specific gauge choices rather than an inherent physical catastrophe.
The Role of Gauge in Instanton Physics
A central theme of this research is the comparison between different mathematical "gauges," which the author likens to coordinate systems in General Relativity. Just as a poorly chosen coordinate system can introduce fictitious forces, a "crooked" gauge can introduce mathematical artifacts that obscure physical reality.
The study focuses on two primary gauges:
- Regular Gauge: Characterized by being smooth at the center of the instanton but exhibiting slow decay at infinity.
- Singular Gauge: Characterized by a singularity at the center but a rapid decay at infinity.
While regular gauge is often preferred for probing the interior of an instanton (small-distance physics), singular gauge is typically favored for large-distance processes. To bridge this gap, the author constructs a Gauge Invariant (GI) Propagator by inserting a path-ordered gluon exponential (a Wilson line) between quark fields. This construction is shown to be equivalent to working in the axial gauge, providing a "natural" middle ground that preserves the physical integrity of the calculation across different scales.
Methodology: Beyond the Single Instanton
To move from theoretical definitions to physical predictions, the author employs several sophisticated techniques:
- Large $N_c$ Limit: By assuming a large number of colors, the complex equations of QCD become more tractable. This approximation is a standard tool in theoretical physics, typically maintaining an accuracy within approximately 10%.
- Self-Energy Resummation: Rather than treating instantons in isolation, the author sums the contributions of an arbitrary number of instantons. This allows for the definition of a "dynamical quark mass" $M(p)$, which varies depending on the momentum of the quark.
- Path-Ordered Exponentials: The use of straight-line Wilson lines ensures that the resulting propagator is gauge-invariant, allowing for a more robust comparison between different gauge-dependent results.
Results: A Finite Quark Condensate
The most significant finding of this work is that the infrared divergence can be resolved through a physically motivated choice of gauge. By utilizing the insights gained from the GI analysis—specifically applying the regular gauge to the integration over large instanton sizes—the author achieves a finite result for the quark condensate $\langle \bar{\psi}\psi \rangle$.
Key numerical results include:
- QCD Scale Prediction: Using the established experimental value for the condensate (240 MeV), the model predicts a QCD scale of $\Lambda_{PV} \approx 190$ MeV. This value aligns well with existing experimental data.
- Dominant Scales: The analysis reveals that the condensate is primarily influenced by quark wave functions with high momenta ($p_c \approx 860$ MeV) and relatively large instanton sizes ($\rho_c \approx 160$ MeV).
Crucially, these results are obtained without the need for the "instanton liquid model" or the manual imposition of infrared cutoffs, suggesting that the finiteness of the condensate is a natural feature of the theory when handled with gauge-invariant methods.
Limitations and Future Directions
While the paper provides a novel solution to the infrared problem, several areas remain open for refinement. The author notes that the final results are sensitive to the tree-level coupling constant $g_0$, a value that currently must be estimated from external models like the Bag Model.
Additionally, the definition of the gauge-invariant propagator is inherently path-dependent. While this study utilizes a straight-line path for the gluon exponential, different path choices could potentially lead to different results. Finally, while the Large $N_c$ limit and one-instanton approximations are standard, they represent areas where future precision improvements could be made.
Conclusion
By re-evaluating the quark propagator through the lens of gauge invariance, this work offers a more fundamental approach to instanton physics. It demonstrates that the long-standing infrared problem may be a consequence of gauge-dependent approximations rather than a failure of the underlying theory, providing a clearer path toward understanding the non-perturbative vacuum of QCD.
Summary updated