Gasoline Desulfurization by Catalytic Alkylation over Methanesulfonic Acid

Xiaolin Wu, Yunpeng Bai, Ying Tian, Xuan Meng, Li ShiBulletin 2013 · DOI

Abstract

Methanesulfonic acid (MSA) was investigated as a catalyst for removing trace organic sulfur (thiophene) from Fluid Catalytic Cracking (FCC) gasoline via alkylation with olefins. Under atmospheric pressure at 343 K, a thiophene conversion of 98.7% was achieved within 60 minutes using a 10% mass ratio of MSA to oil. The catalyst demonstrated significant stability, maintaining a 92.9% conversion rate after three cycles without reactivation. MSA offers an environmentally benign route for desulfurization due to its biodegradability, low toxicity, and ease of separation via decantation.

Introduction

Sulfur compounds in gasoline are a primary environmental concern, contributing to air pollution and the degradation of automotive catalytic converters. While Hydrodesulfurization (HDS) is the industry standard, it requires high temperatures and pressures, consumes significant hydrogen, and often reduces the fuel's octane number by saturating olefins.

Olefinic Alkylation of Thiophenic Sulfur (OATS) has emerged as a promising alternative. By reacting thiophene with olefins to form heavier alkylated products, sulfur can be removed through simple distillation. However, traditional catalysts like hydrofluoric acid or aluminum chloride are hazardous and corrosive. This study explores Methanesulfonic Acid (MSA) as a "green," biodegradable, and highly efficient liquid catalyst for this process.

Experimental Methods

The study utilized a model oil mixture consisting of n-octane, 1% thiophene (sulfur source), and 5% 1-hexene (olefin source). Reactions were performed in an Erlenmeyer flask within a temperature-controlled water bath. Thiophene conversion was monitored using Gas Chromatography (GC-FID), while reaction products were identified via GC-MS. The structural integrity of the recycled catalyst was verified using FT-IR spectroscopy.

Results and Discussion

Optimization of Reaction Conditions

The efficiency of thiophene conversion is heavily dependent on the catalyst-to-oil ratio and reaction temperature. Experimental data indicated that increasing the mass ratio of MSA to oil significantly accelerates the reaction rate.

Thiophene conversion over time at various MSA/oil mass ratios.

As shown in the figure above, a 10% MSA/oil ratio provides near-complete conversion within 60 to 90 minutes. While a 15% ratio offers slightly faster kinetics, the 10% ratio was identified as the optimal balance between efficiency and catalyst economy. Temperature also played a critical role; while higher temperatures (up to 363 K) improved initial rates, 343 K (70°C) was sufficient to reach 98.7% conversion within an hour.

Reaction Mechanism

The alkylation process follows a carbocation mechanism. MSA, a strong Brønsted acid, protonates the 1-hexene to form a reactive carbocation intermediate. This intermediate then undergoes an electrophilic attack on the thiophene ring, resulting in alkylated thiophenes. These heavier molecules have significantly higher boiling points than the original thiophene, facilitating their subsequent removal from the gasoline fraction.

Catalyst Stability and Recyclability

A key advantage of MSA is its ease of recovery. Due to its high polarity and low solubility in hydrocarbons, the catalyst phase can be separated from the oil phase by simple decantation.

Thiophene conversion across multiple catalyst recycle cycles.

The recyclability tests showed that the catalyst remains highly active for the first three runs, with conversion only dropping slightly from 98.7% to 92.9%. However, a sharp decline in performance was observed in the fourth and fifth cycles. This deactivation is primarily attributed to the accumulation of trace amounts of water (above 0.25 wt%) and heavy reaction byproducts that dilute the acid and block active sites.

Conclusion

Methanesulfonic acid is a highly effective and environmentally friendly catalyst for the alkylation desulfurization of gasoline. It achieves near-total sulfur removal under mild conditions and can be easily recycled. Future work should focus on developing dehydration methods to extend the catalyst's lifespan and testing the process on complex, real-world FCC gasoline streams.

Summary updated

Abstract

Methanesulfonic acid (MSA) was used as catalyst to remove trace organic sulfur (thiophene) from Fluid Catalytic Cracking gasoline (FCC) via alkylation with olefins. The reactions were conducted in Erlenmeyer flask equipped with a water-bath under atmospheric pressure. The influence of the temperature, the reaction time, and the mass ration of MSA were investigated. After a 60 min reaction time at 343 K, the thiophene conversion of 98.7% was obtained with a mass ration of MSA to oil of 10%. The catalyst was reused without a reactivation treatment, and the thiophene conversion reached 92.9% at the third time. The method represents an environmentally benign route to desulfur, because MSA could easily be separated from the reaction mixture via decantation and it could be reused.
BibTeX
@article{wu2013gasoline,
  author = {Xiaolin Wu and Yunpeng Bai and Ying Tian and Xuan Meng and Li Shi},
  title = {{Gasoline Desulfurization by Catalytic Alkylation over Methanesulfonic Acid}},
  journal = {Bulletin},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.5012/bkcs.2013.34.10.3055},
}
Figure