Gas Sensing Properties of Mg-Incorporated Metal-Organic Frameworks

Jae-Hyoung Lee, Thanh-Binh Nguyen, Duy-Khoi Nguyen, Jae-Hun Kim, Jin-Young Kim, Bach Thang Phan, Sang Sub Kim2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces two novel Mg-incorporated metal-organic frameworks (Mg-MOFs) for gas sensing applications. The synthesized materials exhibit excellent crystallinity, thermal stability, and high surface area, demonstrating promising performance for detecting toxic gases like NO2. The study highlights the crucial role of pore size and volume in influencing the kinetic properties of MOF-based gas sensors.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The development of highly sensitive and selective gas sensors is crucial for environmental monitoring and safety. Metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) have emerged as promising materials for gas sensing due to their tunable structures, high porosity, and large surface areas. However, there's a need for more research into the specific sensing capabilities of MOFs, particularly those designed without relying on traditional metal oxide co-materials. This paper addresses this gap by synthesizing and evaluating two new Mg-incorporated MOFs (Mg-MOFs-I and -II) as standalone sensing materials for toxic gases, aiming to understand how structural features like pore size influence their sensing performance.

Methods

The researchers synthesized two novel Mg-MOFs, Mg-MOFs-I and Mg-MOFs-II, using a solvothermal reaction between specific linkers (H4TDA and H4ODA, respectively) and a Mg2+ cation. The synthesized MOFs were characterized using:

  • Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM): To analyze the morphology of the materials.
  • X-ray Diffraction (XRD): To confirm the crystallinity and structural integrity of the synthesized MOFs.
  • Thermogravimetric Analysis (TGA): To assess their thermal stability.
  • Nitrogen Adsorption-Desorption Isotherms: To determine their porosity and surface area.

For gas sensing, patterned interdigital electrodes (PIEs) on SiO2-grown Si substrates were fabricated. The MOF powders were then dispersed in 2-propanol, dropped onto the PIEs, dried, and wired to create the sensor devices. Gas sensing tests were conducted in a horizontal-quartz heating chamber, exposing the sensors to various gases (NO2, O2, H2S, H2, C6H6) at different concentrations and temperatures. Sensor response was defined as the ratio of resistances in air and target gas (R = Ra/Rg for NO2, R = Rg/Ra for reducing gases), with response and recovery times measured as the time to reach 90% of the maximum response or initial resistance, respectively.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on the synthesis and characterization of novel materials and their performance in gas sensing experiments conducted by the authors.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Mg-MOFs as standalone sensors: The study successfully demonstrates the potential of Mg-MOFs as active sensing materials without the need for additional metal oxide layers, simplifying sensor fabrication.
  • Pore size is key for kinetics: While both MOFs showed good sensing capabilities, Mg-MOFs-II, with its larger pore size and volume, exhibited significantly shorter response and recovery times. This suggests that pore dimensions play a more critical role in the kinetic aspects of gas sensing than the sieving effect itself.
  • Optimal sensing temperature: An optimal operating temperature of 200 °C was identified for achieving the best sensing performance for NO2.
  • P-type sensing behavior: Both Mg-MOFs displayed p-type sensing behavior, consistent with the adsorption of oxidizing gases like NO2, which leads to a decrease in resistance.
  • NO2 selectivity: The sensors showed a stronger response to NO2 compared to other tested gases, attributed to the more reactive nature of NO2 molecules.
  • Surface area matters for response: The higher surface area of Mg-MOFs-II (2900 m².g⁻¹) compared to Mg-MOFs-I (2520 m².g⁻¹) likely contributes to its stronger response due to increased adsorption sites.

Key Results

  • Material Properties: Both Mg-MOFs exhibited good crystallinity, high thermal stability (up to ~300 °C), needle-shape morphology, and high surface areas (Mg-MOFs-I: 2520 m².g⁻¹, Mg-MOFs-II: 2900 m².g⁻¹). The pore apertures were calculated to be 26.4 Å for Mg-MOFs-I and 22.5 Å for Mg-MOFs-II.
  • Optimal Temperature: 200 °C was found to be the optimal operating temperature for NO2 sensing.
  • Gas Selectivity: The sensors showed a significantly stronger response to NO2 than to O2, H2S, H2, and C6H6 at 200 °C.
  • Kinetic Performance: Mg-MOFs-II generally demonstrated shorter response and recovery times compared to Mg-MOFs-I, especially for gases like NO2 and H2. For example, for 1 ppm NO2 at 200 °C, Mg-MOFs-I had a response time of 124 s and recovery time of 221 s, while Mg-MOFs-II had a response time of 184 s and recovery time of 170 s. (Note: While Mg-MOFs-II had a longer response time for 1ppm NO2, it showed better kinetics for other gases and concentrations, and the paper emphasizes the overall trend of better kinetics for Mg-MOFs-II).
  • Concentration Dependence: Sensor response increased with increasing NO2 concentration.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Selectivity: While NO2 selectivity was observed, the paper notes that the difference in pore size between the two MOFs was not large enough to significantly affect gas response or selectivity, suggesting that the selectivity is weak. Further studies are needed to clarify the role of Mg nodes and linker structures in achieving higher selectivity.
  • Mechanism Clarification: The authors acknowledge that while a sensing mechanism involving potential barrier variations is proposed, further studies are necessary to fully elucidate the role of Mg nodes and linker structures in the sensing process.
  • Long-term stability: While thermal stability was assessed, long-term operational stability under various environmental conditions was not explicitly discussed.
  • Comparison to other MOFs: While the paper mentions existing literature, a direct quantitative comparison of the synthesized Mg-MOFs' performance against other state-of-the-art MOF-based gas sensors for specific gases would strengthen the findings.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{lee2019gas,
  author = {Jae-Hyoung Lee and Thanh-Binh Nguyen and Duy-Khoi Nguyen and Jae-Hun Kim and Jin-Young Kim and Bach Thang Phan and Sang Sub Kim},
  title = {{Gas Sensing Properties of Mg-Incorporated Metal-Organic Frameworks}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/s19153323},
}

Loading related content...

Figure