Gardnerella subgroup dominant microbiomes are associated with divergent cervicovaginal immune responses in a longitudinal cohort of Kenyan women

Elinor Shvartsman, Cátia T. Perciani, Meika Richmond, Justen Russell, Riley H. Tough, Sarah J. Vancuren, Janet E. Hill, Kavi-icr, Walter Jaoko, Lyle R. McKinnon, Paul Sandstrom, Kelly S. MacDonaldFrontiers in Immunology 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Most cervicovaginal microbiome-immunology studies to date have relied on 16S rDNA microbial profiling which does not resolve the molecular subgroups of Gardnerella, believed to be central to the pathogenesis of bacterial vaginosis (BV) and subsequent risk of HIV acquisition. Here we used the cpn60 universal target which in addition to other microbial taxa, resolves four Gardnerella subgroups, for cervicovaginal microbial profiling in a longitudinal cohort of Kenyan women to examine associations with cellular and soluble markers of inflammation and HIV susceptibility. Participants (N = 41) were sampled, contributing 362 samples for microbiome analysis. All non-Lactobacillus dominant microbial communities were associated with high pro-inflammatory cytokine levels. Divergent associations were observed among different Gardnerella subgroup dominated communities with respect to the chemokine IP-10. Specifically, Gardnerella subgroup A dominant and polymicrobial communities were associated with reduced concentrations of IP-10 in adjusted linear mixed models (p<0.0001), compared to microbial communities dominated by Lactobacillus (non-iners) species. However, these associations did not translate to significant differences in the proportion or absolute number of CCR5, HLA-DR and CD38 expressed on cervical CD4+ T- cells. These findings suggest that some associations between Gardnerella subgroup dominant microbiomes and mucosal immunity differ and are relevant for the study of BV-pathogenesis and understanding the mechanisms of BV-associated HIV risk.

Introduction

Bacterial vaginosis (BV) represents a significant shift in the vaginal microbiome from a state dominated by Lactobacillus species to a diverse array of anaerobic bacteria. This condition is a well-documented risk factor for HIV acquisition in women, yet the precise biological mechanisms linking microbial shifts to increased susceptibility remain poorly understood.

A significant limitation in previous research has been the use of 16S rRNA gene sequencing, which often lacks the taxonomic resolution to distinguish between closely related species or subgroups within the genus Gardnerella. Gardnerella is comprised of at least four distinct molecular subgroups (A, B, C, and D), each possessing unique virulence factors and potentially different roles in BV pathogenesis. This study addresses this gap by utilizing high-resolution sequencing to investigate how specific Gardnerella subgroups correlate with cervicovaginal inflammation and the presence of HIV target cells.

Methodology

The researchers conducted a longitudinal study involving 41 Kenyan women over a 48-week period, collecting a total of 362 samples. To overcome the limitations of standard sequencing, the study employed cpn60 Universal Target Sequencing. The cpn60 gene provides greater sequence variation than 16S, allowing for the resolution of Gardnerella into its four subgroups.

Immune responses were assessed through two primary lenses:

  1. Soluble Markers: 14 cytokines and chemokines were measured using electrochemiluminescence assays to profile the inflammatory environment.
  2. Cellular Markers: Flow cytometry was used to quantify cervical T-cells and their expression of HIV-relevant markers, including the CCR5 co-receptor and activation markers HLA-DR and CD38.

Data analysis utilized Linear Mixed Models (LMM) to account for the longitudinal nature of the study, adjusting for potential confounders such as age, antibiotic use, and contraception.

Microbiome Profiling and Diversity

The use of cpn60 allowed for a detailed classification of Community State Types (CSTs). The study identified communities dominated by various Lactobacillus species (e.g., L. crispatus, L. iners) and those dominated by specific Gardnerella subgroups (GVA, GVB, GVC) or mixed polymicrobial states.

Microbial community profiling using cpn60 sequencing shows the relative abundance of species and Shannon diversity across different Community State Types (CSTs).

Divergent Immune Signatures and the IP-10 Paradox

A key finding of the study was that while all non-Lactobacillus dominant communities—typical of BV—were associated with elevated pro-inflammatory cytokines (such as IL-1β and TNF-α), Gardnerella subgroup A (GVA) exhibited a unique immune signature. Specifically, GVA-dominant and polymicrobial (MIXED) communities were associated with significantly reduced concentrations of the chemokine IP-10 (CXCL10) compared to non-iners Lactobacillus states.

Principal Component Analysis (PCA) helped clarify these relationships. PC1 represented a broad pro-inflammatory cluster (including IL-10, IL-1β, TNF-α, and IL-8), which was elevated in all Gardnerella-dominant states. However, PC2, which was heavily loaded with IP-10, showed a distinct negative association with GVA.

Principal Component Analysis of cytokine profiles shows that while most Gardnerella-dominant states increase general inflammation (PC1), Subgroup A (GVA) is uniquely associated with lower IP-10 levels (PC2).

This "IP-10 Paradox" suggests that Gardnerella Subgroup A might actively suppress this specific chemoattractant. Since IP-10 is responsible for recruiting immune cells, its suppression could be a strategy to evade the host immune system, potentially facilitating the development of resilient biofilms.

Cellular Inflammation and HIV Risk

Despite the clear differences in soluble cytokine levels, the study did not find significant associations between microbial community types and the proportion or activation state of cervical CD4+ T-cells (CCR5+, HLA-DR+, or CD38+). This disconnect suggests that the recruitment of HIV target cells may involve more complex dynamics or occur over different timescales than the immediate cytokine response.

Additionally, the study reinforced the intermediate status of Lactobacillus iners-dominant communities, which showed higher inflammatory markers than other Lactobacillus species but lower levels than those dominated by Gardnerella.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This research highlights that Gardnerella subgroups are not a monolith and exert divergent effects on the vaginal immune environment. The unique suppression of IP-10 by Subgroup A points toward strain-specific mechanisms of immune manipulation.

Limitations of the study include the use of relative abundance data rather than absolute bacterial loads and a relatively small number of samples for certain subgroups like GVB and GVC. Future research should focus on the molecular mechanisms of IP-10 suppression and determine if these strain-specific immune profiles directly impact the efficacy of HIV prevention strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Most cervicovaginal microbiome-immunology studies to date have relied on 16S rDNA microbial profiling which does not resolve the molecular subgroups of <i>Gardnerella</i>, believed to be central to the pathogenesis of bacterial vaginosis (BV) and subsequent risk of HIV acquisition. Here we used the <i>cpn</i>60 universal target which in addition to other microbial taxa, resolves four <i>Gardnerella</i> subgroups, for cervicovaginal microbial profiling in a longitudinal cohort of Kenyan women to examine associations with cellular and soluble markers of inflammation and HIV susceptibility. Participants (N = 41) were sampled, contributing 362 samples for microbiome analysis. All non-<i>Lactobacillus</i> dominant microbial communities were associated with high pro-inflammatory cytokine levels. Divergent associations were observed among different <i>Gardnerella</i> subgroup dominated communities with respect to the chemokine IP-10. Specifically, <i>Gardnerella</i> subgroup A dominant and polymicrobial communities were associated with reduced concentrations of IP-10 in adjusted linear mixed models (p<0.0001), compared to microbial communities dominated by <i>Lactobacillus</i> (non-iners) species. However, these associations did not translate to significant differences in the proportion or absolute number of CCR5, HLA-DR and CD38 expressed on cervical CD4<sup>+</sup> T- cells. These findings suggest that some associations between <i>Gardnerella</i> subgroup dominant microbiomes and mucosal immunity differ and are relevant for the study of BV-pathogenesis and understanding the mechanisms of BV-associated HIV risk.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shvartsman2023gardnerella,
  author = {Elinor Shvartsman and Cátia T. Perciani and Meika Richmond and Justen Russell and Riley H. Tough and Sarah J. Vancuren and Janet E. Hill and KAVI-ICR and Walter Jaoko and Lyle R. McKinnon and Paul Sandstrom and Kelly S. MacDonald},
  title = {{Gardnerella subgroup dominant microbiomes are associated with divergent cervicovaginal immune responses in a longitudinal cohort of Kenyan women}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Immunology},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fimmu.2022.974195},
}
Figure