GAMMA-RAY FLARES FROM Mrk421 IN 2008 OBSERVED WITH THE ARGO-YBJ DETECTOR

G. Aielli, C. Bacci, B. Bartoli, P. Bernardini, X. J. Bi, C. Bleve, P. Branchini, A. Budano, S. Bussino, A. K. Calabrese Melcarne, P. Camarri, Z. Cao, A. Cappa, R. Cardarelli, S. Catalanotti, Claudio Cattaneo, Paola Celio, S. Z. Chen, Yupeng Chen, Ning Cheng, P. Creti, S. W. Cui, B. Z. Dai, G. D’Alí Staiti, Danzengluobu Danzengluobu, M. Dattoli, I. De Mitri, B. D′Ettorre Piazzoli, M. De Vincenzi, T. Di Girolamo, X. H. Ding, G. Di Sciascio, C. Feng, Zhaoyang Feng, Zhenyong Feng, F. Galeazzi, P. Galeotti, R. Gargana, Q. B. Gou, Yi-Qing Guo, H. H. He, Haibing Hu, Hongbo Hu, Q. Huang, M. Iacovacci, R. Iuppa, I. James, H. Y. Jia, Labaciren Labaciren, H. J. Li, J. Y. Li, X. X. Li, B. Liberti, G. Liguori, C. Liu, M. Y. Liu, J. Liu, H. Lu, Xinhua Ma, G. Mancarella, S. M. Mari, G. Marsella, D. Martello, S. Mastroianni, X. R. Meng, P. Montini, C. C. Ning, A. Pagliaro, M. Panareo, Lorenzo Perrone, P. Pistilli, X. B. Qu, E. Rossi, F. Ruggieri, L. Saggese, P. Salvini, R. Santonico, P. R. Shen, X. D. Sheng, F. Shi, C. Stanescu, A. Surdo, Y. H. Tan, P. Vallania, S. Vernetto, C. Vigorito, Bo Wang, H. Wang, C. Y. Wu, H. R. Wu, Benda Xu, L. Xue, Yingwen Yan, Q. Y. Yang, X. C. Yang, A. F. Yuan, M. Zha, Honglin Zhang, Jilong ZhangThe Astrophysical Journal Letters 2010 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents observations of the blazar Markarian 421 during its highly active flaring period in 2008 using the ARGO-YBJ ground-based gamma-ray detector. The study provides crucial VHE (Very High Energy) gamma-ray data for the June flares, complementing observations from other telescopes and revealing a particularly powerful flare with a spectrum harder than predicted.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Blazars, a type of active galactic nucleus with a relativistic jet pointed towards Earth, are known for their intense and rapidly varying emissions across the electromagnetic spectrum. Markarian 421 (Mrk421), being one of the closest and brightest blazars, is a prime target for studying the physics of these extreme phenomena. While multiwavelength campaigns have provided detailed insights into blazar flares, observations in the Very High Energy (VHE, >100 GeV) gamma-ray range can be hampered by environmental factors like moonlight, which interfere with ground-based Cherenkov telescopes. This paper addresses the need for continuous VHE monitoring during such critical flaring events, specifically focusing on the June 2008 flares of Mrk421, where moonlight limited other observations. By filling this observational gap, the study aims to provide a more complete picture of the energy spectrum and variability of the blazar during these powerful outbursts.

Methods

The ARGO-YBJ experiment, located at high altitude in Tibet, China, utilizes a large area array of Resistive Plate Chambers (RPCs) to detect extensive air showers initiated by high-energy cosmic rays and gamma rays. For this study, the detector operated in "shower mode," triggering on correlated signals from multiple RPCs. The analysis involved reconstructing the arrival direction and energy of the primary particles.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Background Estimation: The "time swapping" method was employed to estimate the cosmic-ray background. This involves replacing the actual arrival times of detected events with randomly selected times from a buffer, creating a background sky map. An "equi-zenith angle" method was also used as a cross-check for background evaluation.
  • Event Selection: Events with a minimum number of fired pads (Npad ≥ 40) and within a zenith angle of 40° were selected. No specific gamma-hadron discrimination was applied, relying on the statistical significance of excesses over the background.
  • Data Integration: Due to the limited sensitivity of ARGO-YBJ for detecting short-duration, high-flux events, measurements for the June flares were integrated over 3-day periods to achieve sufficient statistical significance.
  • Spectral Analysis: The differential gamma-ray spectrum was fitted with a power law, corrected for intergalactic absorption by the Extragalactic Background Light (EBL), using parameters from Raue & Mazin (2008).

Datasets

  • ARGO-YBJ Detector Data: Continuous monitoring data from the ARGO-YBJ experiment from January to June 2008, specifically focusing on the period of Mrk421's flaring activity.
  • RXTE/ASM X-ray Data: Soft X-ray (2-10 keV) light curves from the Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer (RXTE) All-Sky Monitor (ASM) were used to correlate with the VHE gamma-ray observations.
  • Previous VHE Data: Data from the Whipple Cherenkov telescope (Krennrich et al. 2002) for a previous Mrk421 flare of comparable intensity were used for spectral comparison.
  • Theoretical Models: The spectral energy distribution (SED) model by Donnarumma et al. (2009) was used as a reference for expected fluxes and spectral shapes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Complementary VHE Coverage: The ARGO-YBJ data successfully filled a critical gap in VHE observations during the June 2008 Mrk421 flares, a period where moonlight significantly hampered Cherenkov telescope observations.
  • Strong Correlation with X-rays: A clear correlation was observed between the VHE gamma-ray excess rate from Mrk421 and the X-ray flux measured by RXTE/ASM, reinforcing the understanding of common emission mechanisms.
  • Exceptional Flare Intensity: The second flare in early June 2008 was found to be exceptionally powerful, with ARGO-YBJ detecting a gamma-ray flux approximately 6 times that of the Crab Nebula above 1 TeV.
  • Harder Spectrum in the Second Flare: The reconstructed differential spectrum for the June 11-13 flare was found to be harder (steeper spectral index) than predicted by theoretical models, suggesting a potentially different emission process or electron acceleration mechanism at play during this intense outburst.
  • Long-Term Spectral Hardening Correlation: The observed spectral index and flux relationship for Mrk421 in 2008 aligns with a long-term correlation observed in previous studies of the source, suggesting this property is a persistent characteristic of its emission.

Key Results

  • Average VHE Flux: From day 41 to 180 of 2008, the average VHE flux above 1 TeV was (3.6 ± 0.6) × 10⁻¹¹ photons cm⁻² s⁻¹, which is about twice the Crab Nebula flux.
  • June 11-13 Flare Significance: A statistical significance of 3.8 standard deviations was achieved for the excess of events from Mrk421 during June 11-13.
  • June 11-13 Flare Flux: The integral flux above 1 TeV during this flare was approximately 6 times the Crab Nebula flux.
  • Differential Spectrum: The deabsorbed differential spectrum for the June 11-13 flare was fitted by a power law with an index α = -2.1 ± 0.3, extending up to several TeV.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Statistical Limitations: The authors acknowledge that due to the relatively low statistics for short-duration events, measurements were integrated over 3-day periods. This limits the ability to resolve very rapid variability on timescales shorter than a few days.
  • Systematic Uncertainties: While efforts were made to estimate systematic uncertainties (e.g., from background evaluation), they can still affect the precise flux and spectral index values.
  • Model Discrepancies: The observed flux for both June flares was found to be higher than predicted by the Donnarumma et al. (2009) model, and the spectrum of the second flare was harder than predicted. This suggests that current models may need refinement to fully capture the observed phenomenology.
  • Future Work: The paper indicates that a comprehensive analysis of all ARGO-YBJ data collected during 2008 will be reported in a dedicated paper. This broader analysis will likely provide a more detailed understanding of Mrk421's behavior throughout the year and allow for a more robust comparison with theoretical models. Further investigation into the compatibility of the observed phenomenology with current VHE photon emission models in AGNs is also suggested.

Summary updated

Abstract

In 2008 the blazar Markarian 421 entered a very active phase and was one of the brightest sources in the sky at TeV energies, showing frequent flaring episodes. Using the data of ARGO-YBJ, a full coverage air shower detector located at Yangbajing (4300 m a.s.l., Tibet, China), we monitored the source at gamma ray energies E > 0.3 TeV during the whole year. The observed flux was variable, with the strongest flares in March and June, in correlation with X-ray enhanced activity. While during specific episodes the TeV flux could be several times larger than the Crab Nebula one, the average emission from day 41 to 180 was almost twice the Crab level, with an integral flux of (3.6 +-0.6) 10^-11 photons cm^-2 s^-1 for energies E > 1 TeV, and decreased afterwards. This paper concentrates on the flares occurred in the first half of June. This period has been deeply studied from optical to 100 MeV gamma rays, and partially up to TeV energies, since the moonlight hampered the Cherenkov telescope observations during the most intense part of the emission. Our data complete these observations, with the detection of a signal with a statistical significance of 3.8 standard deviations on June 11-13, corresponding to a gamma ray flux about 6 times larger than the Crab one above 1 TeV. The reconstructed differential spectrum, corrected for the intergalactic absorption, can be represented by a power law with an index alpha = -2.1 extending up to several TeV. The spectrum slope is fully consistent with previous observations reporting a correlation between the flux and the spectral index, suggesting that this property is maintained in different epochs and characterizes the source emission processes.
BibTeX
@article{aielli2010gamma,
  author = {G. Aielli and C. Bacci and B. Bartoli and P. Bernardini and X. J. Bi and C. Bleve and P. Branchini and A. Budano and S. Bussino and A. K. Calabrese Melcarne and P. Camarri and Z. Cao and A. Cappa and R. Cardarelli and S. Catalanotti and Claudio Cattaneo and Paola Celio and S. Z. Chen and Yupeng Chen and Ning Cheng and P. Creti and S. W. Cui and B. Z. Dai and G. D’Alí Staiti and Danzengluobu Danzengluobu and M. Dattoli and I. De Mitri and B. D′Ettorre Piazzoli and M. De Vincenzi and T. Di Girolamo and X. H. Ding and G. Di Sciascio and C. Feng and Zhaoyang Feng and Zhenyong Feng and F. Galeazzi and P. Galeotti and R. Gargana and Q. B. Gou and Yi-Qing Guo and H. H. He and Haibing Hu and Hongbo Hu and Q. Huang and M. Iacovacci and R. Iuppa and I. James and H. Y. Jia and Labaciren Labaciren and H. J. Li and J. Y. Li and X. X. Li and B. Liberti and G. Liguori and C. Liu and C. Q. Liu and M. Y. Liu and J. Liu and H. Lu and Xinhua Ma and G. Mancarella and S. M. Mari and G. Marsella and D. Martello and S. Mastroianni and X. R. Meng and P. Montini and C. C. Ning and A. Pagliaro and M. Panareo and Lorenzo Perrone and P. Pistilli and X. B. Qu and E. Rossi and F. Ruggieri and L. Saggese and P. Salvini and R. Santonico and P. R. Shen and X. D. Sheng and F. Shi and C. Stanescu and A. Surdo and Y. H. Tan and P. Vallania and S. Vernetto and C. Vigorito and Bo Wang and H. Wang and C. Y. Wu and H. R. Wu and Benda Xu and L. Xue and Yingwen Yan and Q. Y. Yang and X. C. Yang and A. F. Yuan and M. Zha and Honglin Zhang and Jilong Zhang},
  title = {{GAMMA-RAY FLARES FROM Mrk421 IN 2008 OBSERVED WITH THE ARGO-YBJ DETECTOR}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal Letters},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1088/2041-8205/714/2/l208},
}
Figure