Gamma Band Oscillations Reflect Sensory and Affective Dimensions of Pain

Yuanyuan Lyu, Francesca Zidda, Stefan T. Radev, Hongcai Liu, Xiaoli Guo, Shanbao Tong, Herta Flor, Jamila AndohFrontiers in Neurology 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that emotional context significantly influences the subjective experience of pain, specifically its unpleasantness, but not its intensity. Using EEG, researchers identified two distinct gamma band oscillations (GBOs) that correlate with different aspects of pain processing: an early GBO linked to overall pain perception and a later GBO associated with the emotional modulation of pain.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Pain is not just a physical sensation; it's deeply intertwined with our emotions. While we know that emotions can alter how we perceive pain, the precise neural mechanisms behind this modulation remain unclear. Specifically, researchers wanted to understand how different emotional states, induced by visual cues, affect the sensory (intensity) and affective (unpleasantness) dimensions of pain, and how these changes are reflected in brain activity, particularly in gamma band oscillations (GBOs). Previous studies often combined emotional stimuli and pain simultaneously, making it difficult to disentangle attentional or cognitive confounds. This paper aims to address this by using a "prime-target" paradigm to isolate the emotional influence.

Methods

The researchers employed a sophisticated experimental design involving electroencephalography (EEG) and a priming paradigm. Healthy participants were presented with pictures of varying emotional valence (negative, neutral, or positive) as primes. Following a brief delay, they received a painful electrical stimulus to their forearm. After each stimulus, participants rated both the intensity and unpleasantness of the pain using visual analog scales (VAS).

EEG data was meticulously preprocessed, including filtering, artifact rejection, and independent component analysis to remove unwanted signals. The core of the analysis involved time-frequency decomposition of the EEG signals to identify gamma band oscillations (GBOs). Specifically, they looked for event-related spectral perturbations (ERSPs) to pinpoint GBOs occurring after the painful stimulus. They identified two distinct GBOs: an "early GBO" and a "late GBO," characterized by different time windows, frequency ranges, and scalp distributions. Statistical analyses, including repeated measures ANOVAs and Spearman's rank correlation, were used to examine the relationships between prime valence, pain ratings, and GBO amplitudes.

Datasets

The study utilized the International Affective Picture System (IAPS) as the dataset for emotional priming. These pictures are normatively rated for valence and arousal, allowing researchers to select stimuli with specific emotional characteristics. The specific picture numbers used are listed in the paper. No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Emotional Valence Selectively Modulates Pain Unpleasantness: The most striking finding is that negative emotional primes significantly increased pain unpleasantness, while positive primes decreased it. Crucially, pain intensity remained largely unaffected by the emotional context. This suggests that the emotional component of pain is more susceptible to modulation than its sensory component.
  • Two Distinct Gamma Band Oscillations (GBOs) for Pain: The study identified two consecutive GBOs after painful stimulation, each with unique characteristics. This suggests that gamma band activity is not monolithic in pain processing but rather comprises distinct temporal and spatial components.
  • Early GBO Reflects Overall Pain Perception: The early GBO, occurring shortly after the stimulus and with a contralateral distribution, was positively correlated with both pain intensity and unpleasantness ratings. Importantly, it was not influenced by the emotional valence of the prime, suggesting it reflects a more general, sensory-driven aspect of pain processing.
  • Late GBO Reflects Affective Modulation: The later GBO, appearing with a centroparietal distribution and at a higher frequency, was significantly modulated by emotional valence, being larger for negative primes. Its amplitude was also positively correlated with the emotional modulation of pain unpleasantness, pointing towards its role in the affective, top-down processing of pain.
  • Phase-Locked vs. Induced Oscillations: The paper also touches upon the distinction between phase-locked and induced GBOs, suggesting that while the early GBO might be largely phase-locked (reflecting sensory input), the late GBO might involve more induced activity (reflecting top-down modulation).

Key Results

  • Pain Ratings:
    • Pain intensity ratings did not differ significantly across negative, neutral, and positive prime conditions.
  • Pain unpleasantness ratings were significantly higher for negative primes compared to neutral and positive primes.
  • A strong positive correlation (rho = 0.851) was found between pain intensity and unpleasantness ratings across all conditions.
  • Gamma Band Oscillations (GBOs):
    • Early GBO: Amplitude was positively correlated with both pain intensity (rho = 0.608) and unpleasantness (rho = 0.558) ratings, but showed no significant main effect of prime valence.
  • Late GBO: Amplitude showed a significant main effect of prime valence, being larger for negative primes compared to neutral and positive primes. The normalized late GBO amplitude (neg-pos) was significantly positively correlated with unpleasantness ratings (rho = 0.511).
  • Inter-trial coherence (ITC) was significantly larger for the early GBO than the late GBO.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Stimulus Intensity: The study used a single intensity of electrical stimulation, meaning the findings might be intensity-dependent. Future work could explore how priming effects vary with different stimulus intensities.
  • Stimulation Modality: The use of electrical stimulation might activate non-nociceptive systems. Future research could employ laser stimulation or intraepidermal electrical stimulation for more selective activation of nociceptors.
  • Visual Artifacts: The GBOs following electrical stimulation could potentially be contaminated by preceding visual-evoked brain activity. Using a control condition with visual pictures but no electrical stimulation could help address this.
  • Interindividual Variability: The study noted variability in outlier detection across analyses, suggesting interindividual differences in pain perception that might be related to genetic or psychosocial factors. Further research could explore these individual differences.

The authors suggest that future studies should aim to further clarify the mechanisms underlying these distinct GBOs and their roles in the emotional modulation of pain, potentially by manipulating various experimental factors and exploring different stimulation modalities. The findings also highlight the importance of considering both sensory and affective dimensions of pain in research and clinical practice.

Summary updated

Abstract

Pain is a multidimensional process, which can be modulated by emotions; however, the mechanisms underlying this modulation are unknown. We used pictures with different emotional valence (negative, positive, and neutral) as primes and applied electrical painful stimuli as targets to healthy participants. We assessed pain intensity and unpleasantness ratings and recorded electroencephalograms (EEGs). We found that pain unpleasantness and not pain intensity ratings were modulated by emotion, with increased ratings for negative and decreased ratings for positive pictures. We also found two consecutive gamma band oscillations (GBOs) related to pain processing from time frequency analyses of the EEG signals. The early GBO had a cortical distribution contralateral to the painful stimulus and its amplitude was positively correlated with intensity and unpleasantness ratings, but not with prime valence. The late GBO had a centroparietal distribution and its amplitude was larger for negative compared to neutral and positive pictures. The emotional modulation effect (negative vs. positive) of the late GBO amplitude was positively correlated with pain unpleasantness. The early GBO might reflect the overall pain perception, possibly involving the thalamocortical circuit, while the late GBO might be related to the affective dimension of pain and top-down-related processes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lyu2022gamma,
  author = {Yuanyuan Lyu and Francesca Zidda and Stefan T. Radev and Hongcai Liu and Xiaoli Guo and Shanbao Tong and Herta Flor and Jamila Andoh},
  title = {{Gamma Band Oscillations Reflect Sensory and Affective Dimensions of Pain}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Neurology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fneur.2021.695187},
}
Figure