Abstract: This study explores the efficacy of a music-tapping game intervention in reducing the emotional intensity of traumatic memories. Registered at www.chictr.org.cn (identifier: ChiCTR2200055921), the research focuses on the "flow state" as a critical factor in enhancing cognitive interventions during the memory reconsolidation window.
Introduction
Healthcare professionals, particularly those working in Intensive Care Units (ICUs), are frequently exposed to traumatic events such as cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR), placing them at high risk for Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD). Current neurobiological theories suggest that when a traumatic memory is recalled, it enters a "labile" state—a process known as reconsolidation—during which it can be modified or disrupted.
While previous research has utilized visuospatial tasks (e.g., Tetris) to tax working memory during this window, results have been inconsistent. This study investigates whether a multi-modal intervention—combining a visual game with synchronized auditory stimuli—can more effectively reduce the emotional distress of these memories by inducing a state of "flow."
Methods
The researchers conducted a randomized controlled trial involving 76 female ICU nurses who had performed CPR within the preceding 12 hours. The experimental protocol spanned seven days, with the primary intervention occurring on Day 4.
Participants were randomly assigned to one of four groups:
- RGM(+): Memory reminder followed by playing the "Ceaseless Music Note" (CMN) game with matching background music.
- RGM(-): Memory reminder followed by playing the CMN game in silence.
- RM(+): Memory reminder followed by listening to the music only.
- R: Memory reminder only (control).
The CMN game is a smartphone-based rhythmic tapping task. Participants maintained an "intrusion diary" for seven days to record involuntary flashbacks and rated the vividness and emotionality of their memories using Visual Analog Scales (VAS) on Day 4 and Day 7.
Key Results
The study found that the combination of gameplay and synchronized music significantly enhanced the intervention's efficacy.
- Reduction in Emotionality: The RGM(+) group demonstrated a significantly greater decrease in emotionality ratings from Day 4 to Day 7 compared to all other groups ($p < 0.001$). This suggests an "add-on effect" where the auditory component synergizes with the visual task.
- Flow Experience: Participants in the RGM(+) group reported significantly higher levels of concentration (8.40 vs. 7.06) and enjoyment (8.45 vs. 5.42) compared to the silent gameplay group. This supports the hypothesis that a "flow state" maximizes cognitive load and intervention effectiveness.
- Intrusion Frequency: No significant differences were observed between groups regarding the total number of intrusions. Researchers noted a rapid natural decline in intrusions across all groups, which may have created a "ceiling effect" that masked potential treatment differences.
Discussion and Limitations
The findings highlight the importance of multi-modal interference and the "flow experience" in psychological interventions. By engaging both visual and auditory processing streams, the RGM(+) intervention likely provided a more robust disruption of memory reconsolidation than single-modality tasks.
However, several limitations warrant consideration. The study's sample was exclusively female, potentially limiting generalizability. Additionally, the intervention was brief (15 minutes); future research should investigate the impact of multiple sessions. Finally, while self-reported "flow" was high, future studies could benefit from objective physiological markers to further validate these findings.
In conclusion, game-matching background music provides a powerful add-on effect, making cognitive interventions more engaging and effective at dampening the emotional sting of traumatic memories.
Summary updated