Game Analysis of the Open-Source Innovation Benefits of Two Enterprises from the Perspective of Product Homogenization and the Enterprise Strength Gap

Aiping Tao, Qi Qi, Yi Li, Dan Da, Valentina Boamah, Decai TangSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses a game theory model to analyze how product similarity and the difference in company size affect revenue from open-source innovation. It finds that while high product similarity can hurt revenue, a moderate level can be beneficial, and a large gap in company strength between collaborators generally reduces overall profits.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Open-source innovation, where companies collaborate and share development, is increasingly popular. However, a key question remains: does it actually lead to more revenue for the participating firms? While the benefits of open-source are often discussed in terms of cost reduction and faster development, the direct impact on revenue is complex and influenced by various factors. This paper aims to untangle this by focusing on two specific factors: how similar the products are (product homogenization) and how different the strengths of the collaborating companies are (enterprise strength gap). Understanding these dynamics is crucial for companies deciding whether to engage in open-source innovation and how to structure these collaborations for maximum benefit.

Methods

The authors employ a game theory approach, specifically a two-enterprise model. They define an "open-source enterprise" (Enterprise A) and a "learning enterprise" (Enterprise B). They then construct a mathematical model that captures the revenue streams for both enterprises throughout a simplified open-source innovation process, including initial innovation, disclosure, learning, and potential secondary innovation. Key variables are defined and their relationships are modeled:

  • Product Homogeneity (x): A measure of how substitutable the products are, ranging from 0 (completely different) to 1 (identical).
  • Competitive Intensity (α): How much one firm's revenue is affected by the other's actions.
  • Knowledge Absorption Capability (γ): How effectively a firm can learn from shared knowledge.
  • Secondary Innovation Capability (μ): The ability to improve upon existing innovations.
  • Secondary Innovation Cost (C): The expense incurred in secondary innovation.
  • Enterprise Strength Gap (m): The ratio of Enterprise B's strength to Enterprise A's strength.

The paper then derives functional relationships for these variables and uses calculus (partial derivatives) to analyze their impact on the revenues of both enterprises and the total market return. Matlab simulations are used to visualize these complex relationships.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical modeling and simulation rather than empirical data from specific companies or datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Non-Linearity is Key: The relationship between product homogeneity and revenue isn't a simple straight line. Too much similarity can be bad, but a moderate level can actually boost revenue. This challenges the intuition that "more alike is always better" or "more different is always better."
  • Strength Matters, But Balance is Better: A large gap in the strength or size of collaborating companies is detrimental to overall revenue. While a stronger firm might seem to benefit more, the disadvantages faced by weaker firms in sharing and competition lead to a net loss for the partnership.
  • Moderate Homogeneity is the Sweet Spot: The paper suggests that a moderate degree of product similarity strikes a balance. It allows for effective knowledge transfer and learning without leading to intense, revenue-eroding competition.
  • Secondary Innovation is a Double-Edged Sword: While secondary innovation can add value, its cost and the potential for further revenue loss due to competition need careful consideration by the learning enterprise.

Key Results

The study's core findings are derived from the mathematical model and simulations:

  • Product Homogeneity: High homogeneity (close to 1) generally harms open-source innovation revenue. However, revenue can be relatively high at moderate levels of homogeneity. The exact optimal point is complex and depends on other factors.
  • Enterprise Strength Gap: A larger strength gap between collaborating firms negatively impacts revenue. The wider the gap, the greater the revenue loss for weaker firms, leading to lower total revenue. Conversely, similar enterprise strengths tend to maximize total revenue, especially when homogeneity is moderate.
  • Conditions for Secondary Innovation: Enterprise B is more likely to pursue secondary innovation if its benefits outweigh the costs. This is influenced by the strength gap and homogeneity, with stronger incentives for secondary innovation when the strength gap is not too large and homogeneity is moderate.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Simplified Model: The model considers only two enterprises and a simplified innovation process (up to secondary innovation). Real-world scenarios often involve multiple participants and more complex innovation cycles.
  • Assumptions: The model makes assumptions about firms' capabilities, market satisfaction, and the absence of further innovation beyond the second stage.
  • Interdependence of Variables: While the paper attempts to isolate product homogeneity and strength gap, other factors like competitive intensity and knowledge absorption are inherently linked and their interactions are complex.
  • Lack of Empirical Data: The study is theoretical and relies on simulations. Empirical validation with real-world data would strengthen the findings.

Future work could involve extending the model to include more participants, exploring different types of open-source licenses, and investigating the impact of external factors like government policy and market dynamics. The authors also suggest focusing on fields beyond software, such as electronics and new materials, where product differentiation is more pronounced.

Summary updated

Abstract

Revenue is one of the hottest topics in the field of open-source innovation. Can open-source innovation really bring more revenue to firms? What affects the revenue from open-source innovation? Based on the perspective of product homogenization and the enterprise-strength gap, these questions are answered in this study using theoretical analyses and the construction of a game model to explore the influence of product homogeneity and the strength gap between firms regarding the revenue from open-source innovation. The results show that enterprise homogeneity and the revenue from open-source innovation are not linearly related. High homogeneity does harm the revenue from open-source innovation, while the revenue is relatively high when the homogeneity is moderate. Additionally, it was also identified that the strength gap between firms has a negative influence on the revenue from open-source innovation. The wider the strength gap is, the greater the revenue loss of the weaker firms and, thus, the lower the total revenue of the two firms will be. This paper provides a reference for research on enterprise revenue from open-source innovation and the selection of participants in open-source activities.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tao2022game,
  author = {Aiping Tao and Qi Qi and Yi Li and Dan Da and Valentina Boamah and Decai Tang},
  title = {{Game Analysis of the Open-Source Innovation Benefits of Two Enterprises from the Perspective of Product Homogenization and the Enterprise Strength Gap}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su14095572},
}
Figure