Galileons coupled to massive gravity: general analysis and cosmological solutions

Garrett Goon, A. Emir Gümrükçüoğ, Kurt Hinterbichler, Shinji Mukohyama, Mark TroddenJournal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores a theoretical framework that combines "galileons" (a type of scalar field with specific non-linear symmetries) with massive gravity, a modification of Einstein's theory of gravity. The authors develop a consistent way to couple these theories, ensuring desirable properties like ghost-freedom, and analyze the resulting cosmological solutions, finding that certain modes in self-accelerating universes have vanishing kinetic terms.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The standard model of cosmology, based on General Relativity (GR) and the cosmological constant, faces challenges in explaining phenomena like dark energy and dark matter. Modified gravity theories, such as massive gravity, aim to address these issues by introducing a massive graviton. However, naively adding a mass term to the graviton often leads to problematic extra degrees of freedom (ghosts) that destabilize the theory.

Simultaneously, galileon fields have emerged as interesting theoretical constructs due to their non-linear symmetries and their potential to exhibit the Vainshtein screening mechanism, which could explain why they don't conflict with fifth-force experimental bounds. The challenge has been to consistently couple these galileon fields to massive gravity without breaking their desirable properties or introducing new instabilities. This paper tackles this challenge by developing a unified framework for galileons and massive gravity, building upon previous work.

Methods

The authors employ a number of sophisticated theoretical techniques:

  • Vielbein Formalism: They rephrase the construction of the theory using vielbeins, which are essentially local frames, instead of directly working with the metric. This approach simplifies calculations and leads to more compact expressions, particularly for the interactions between the galileon and the massive graviton.
  • Probe-Brane Construction: The galileon sector is derived from a probe-brane construction in a higher-dimensional spacetime. This geometric perspective helps understand the origin of galileon symmetries.
  • dRGT Massive Gravity: The massive gravity sector is based on the de Rham-Gabadadze-Tolley (dRGT) theory, which is known to be ghost-free.
  • Action Derivation and Analysis: They derive the general form of the action for the coupled theory and then analyze it in specific, highly symmetric cases (maximally symmetric bulk metrics).
  • Perturbation Theory: To understand the dynamics around specific solutions, they expand the action to quadratic order in fluctuations, allowing them to identify propagating degrees of freedom and their properties (masses, kinetic terms).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. This is a theoretical physics paper focused on developing and analyzing a mathematical framework, not on analyzing observational data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unified Framework: The paper successfully constructs a unified, ghost-free theory of galileons coupled to massive gravity, retaining the desirable symmetries of both sectors.
  • Vielbeins Simplify: The use of vielbeins proves to be a powerful tool for handling the complex interactions between the galileon and massive gravity, simplifying calculations and providing a more elegant formulation.
  • Maximally Symmetric Solutions: The authors demonstrate the existence of maximally symmetric solutions within this coupled theory, which are crucial for studying cosmological scenarios.
  • Scalar and Vector Modes Vanish in Self-Accelerating Universes: A significant finding is that in self-accelerating cosmological solutions, the scalar and vector modes of the perturbations have vanishing kinetic terms. This is a known feature in pure massive gravity and appears to persist in this extended theory.
  • Massive Graviton and Scalar Propagate: In the analyzed maximally symmetric vacuum solutions, a massive graviton and a scalar field propagate, with the scalar's mass depending on the specific background curvature (de Sitter, flat, or anti-de Sitter).

Key Results

  • The paper provides explicit expressions for the action of galileons coupled to dRGT massive gravity in terms of vielbeins.
  • They analyze the spectrum of quadratic fluctuations around maximally symmetric solutions, showing the propagation of a massive graviton and a scalar with masses related to the background curvature.
  • For self-accelerating cosmological solutions, they confirm that the vector and scalar modes have vanishing kinetic terms, a feature that seems to be generic for theories with intact, geometrically interpretable, non-linearly realized symmetries.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Focus on Specific Cases: While the general framework is developed, the detailed analysis of solutions and fluctuations is primarily focused on maximally symmetric cases.
  • Vanishing Kinetic Terms: The vanishing of kinetic terms for scalar and vector modes in self-accelerating solutions, while interesting, might indicate that these modes are not dynamically propagating in a simple way and could be strongly coupled or gauge-dependent. The paper notes that this vanishing might lead to instabilities at non-linear orders, as seen in previous studies.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that further investigation into the implications of these vanishing kinetic terms, particularly regarding potential instabilities at non-linear orders, would be valuable. Exploring more general cosmological solutions beyond the maximally symmetric ones could also be a fruitful direction. The paper also hints at the connection to Stückelberg fields for restoring general coordinate invariance, suggesting further avenues for theoretical development.

Summary updated

Abstract

We further develop the framework for coupling galileons and Dirac-Born-Infeld (DBI) scalar fields to a massive graviton while retaining both the non-linear symmetries of the scalars and ghost-freedom of the theory. The general construction is recast in terms of vielbeins which simplifies calculations and allows for compact expressions. Expressions for the general form of the action are derived, with special emphasis on those models which descend from maximally symmetric spaces. We demonstrate the existence of maximally symmetric solutions to the fully non-linear theory and analyze their spectrum of quadratic fluctuations. Finally, we consider self-accelerating cosmological solutions and study their perturbations, showing that the vector and scalar modes have vanishing kinetic terms.
BibTeX
@article{goon2014galileons,
  author = {Garrett Goon and A. Emir Gümrükçüoğ and Kurt Hinterbichler and Shinji Mukohyama and Mark Trodden},
  title = {{Galileons coupled to massive gravity: general analysis and cosmological solutions}},
  journal = {Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1088/1475-7516/2014/08/008},
}
Figure