Galactic cosmic ray propagation: sub-PeV diffuse gamma-ray and neutrino emission

Bing-Qiang Qiao, Wei Liu, Mengjie Zhao, Xiao-Jun Bi, Yi-Qing GuoarXiv 2021 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The Tibet AS$\gamma$ experiment recently reported the measurement of sub-PeV diffuse gamma-ray emission from the Galactic disk, reaching energies up to 957 TeV. These gamma-rays likely originate from hadronic interactions between cosmic rays and interstellar gas. This measurement provides direct evidence that Galactic cosmic rays can be accelerated beyond PeV energies. In this work, we model the sub-PeV diffuse gamma-ray spectrum within a cosmic ray diffusive propagation framework. We identify a significant tension between the sub-PeV diffuse gamma-rays and the local cosmic ray spectrum; describing the observed gamma-ray flux generally requires a larger local cosmic-ray flux than measured in the "knee" region. Furthermore, we calculate the PeV neutrino flux from this propagation model, finding that Galactic neutrinos account for less than ~15% of the observed IceCube flux, suggesting a predominantly extragalactic origin for the remainder.

Introduction

For decades, the "knee" in the cosmic ray (CR) spectrum—a steepening around 4 PeV ($10^{15}$ eV)—has suggested the existence of "PeVatrons" within our Galaxy. However, direct evidence for these ultra-high-energy accelerators has been elusive. The Tibet AS$\gamma$ experiment's detection of diffuse gamma rays up to nearly 1 PeV provides a new window into these processes. This study investigates whether standard and advanced propagation models can reconcile these new gamma-ray observations with the CR spectra measured directly at Earth.

Methodology and Propagation Models

To simulate the Galactic high-energy environment, researchers utilized the DRAGON code for solving diffusion equations and GALPROP for calculating resulting diffuse emissions. Three primary propagation scenarios were tested:

  1. Homogeneous Diffusion (HD): A standard model assuming a uniform diffusion coefficient throughout the Galactic halo.
  2. Spatially Dependent Propagation (SDP-A & SDP-B): Advanced models where diffusion is slower near the Galactic disk and faster in the outer halo. SDP-A assumes spectral hardening is due to a local source, while SDP-B attributes it to the spatial variation of the diffusion process itself.

The Tension in Local Cosmic Ray Flux

A core finding of this research is the "tension" between global Galactic observations and local measurements. To produce the gamma-ray flux observed by Tibet AS$\gamma$, models—particularly the spatially dependent ones—require a significantly higher density of cosmic rays in the Galactic disk than what is measured by experiments like AMS-02, CREAM, and DAMPE near the "knee" region.

Figure 4: Proton and Helium spectra compared with various propagation models. The SDP-B model (blue line) shows a significant departure from local measurements at high energies to match gamma-ray data.

This discrepancy suggests that our local solar neighborhood might reside in a "quiet" pocket of the Galaxy, where the CR flux is lower than the Galactic average. As shown in the spectra, the standard HD model fails to account for the high-energy flux needed to explain the gamma-ray glow.

Diffuse Gamma-Ray Observations

The Tibet AS$\gamma$ data serves as a critical benchmark for these models. While the HD model significantly under-predicts the sub-PeV emission, the SDP-B model provides a much better fit across different Galactic longitude regions.

Figure 5: Diffuse gamma-ray flux in different Galactic longitude regions (a and b). The SDP-B model (blue solid line) aligns most closely with the Tibet AS$\gamma$ and ARGO-YBJ data points.

Despite the success of SDP-B in fitting the gamma-ray data, it does so at the cost of over-predicting the all-particle CR flux between 100 TeV and 100 PeV, reinforcing the conclusion that local measurements may not be representative of the broader Galactic disk.

Implications for Neutrino Astronomy

By linking gamma-ray production to neutrino production via pion decay, the study also constrains the Galactic contribution to the neutrino flux observed by IceCube. The results indicate that diffuse Galactic propagation only accounts for approximately 15% of the total observed neutrino flux. The calculated neutrino spectrum is also steeper than IceCube observations above hundreds of TeV, confirming that the highest-energy neutrinos likely originate from extragalactic sources.

Conclusion

The sub-PeV gamma-ray emission detected by Tibet AS$\gamma$ confirms the existence of Galactic PeVatrons but highlights a fundamental gap in our understanding of CR propagation. Reconciling the "tension" between local and global fluxes will require higher precision measurements of CR composition in the PeV range and more sensitive gamma-ray observations to distinguish truly diffuse emission from unresolved point sources.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Tibet ASgamma experiment just reported their measurement of sub-PeV diffuse gamma ray emission from the Galactic disk, with the highest energy up to 957 TeV. These gamma-rays are most likely the hadronic origin by cosmic ray interaction with interstellar gas in the Galaxy. This measurement provides direct evidence to the hypothesis that the Galactic cosmic rays can be accelerated beyond PeV energies. In this work, we try to explain the sub-PeV diffuse gamma-ray spectrum within cosmic rays diffusive propagation model. We find there is a tension between the sub-PeV diffuse gamma rays and the local cosmic ray spectrum. To describe the sub-PeV diffuse gamma-ray flux, it generally requires larger local cosmic-ray flux than measurement in the knee region. We further calculate the PeV neutrino flux from the cosmic ray propagation model. Even all of these sub-PeV diffuse gamma rays originate from the propagation, the Galactic neutrinos only account for less than ~15% of observed flux, most of which are still from extragalactic sources.
BibTeX
@misc{qiao2021galactic,
  author = {Bing-Qiang Qiao and Wei Liu and Mengjie Zhao and Xiao-Jun Bi and Yi-Qing Guo},
  title = {{Galactic cosmic ray propagation: sub-PeV diffuse gamma-ray and neutrino emission}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2104.03729},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2104.03729},
}

Loading related content...

Figure