Gait, physical activity, and tibiofemoral cartilage damage: A longitudinal machine learning analysis in the Multicenter Osteoarthritis Study

K.e. Costello, David T. Felson, S. Reza Jafarzadeh, Ali Guermazi, Frank W. Roemer, Neil A. Segal, Cora E. Lewis, Michael C. Nevitt, Cara L. Lewis, Vijaya B. Kolachalama, Deepak KumarmedRxiv 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers used an ensemble machine learning approach to predict which individuals are most likely to experience worsening knee cartilage damage over a two-year period. By analyzing complex gait patterns and physical activity data from the Multicenter Osteoarthritis Study (MOST), the study identified "lateral ground reaction force impulse" as a key modifiable risk factor, offering a potential new target for early clinical intervention.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Knee osteoarthritis (OA) affects over 350 million people worldwide, yet we currently have no cure. Most clinical focus remains on late-stage disease where joint replacement is the only option. To shift toward prevention, we need to identify individuals at risk before extensive damage occurs.

While mechanical loading on the joint is a known modifiable risk factor, traditional statistical methods struggle to account for the complex, non-linear interactions between how a person walks (gait), how much they move (physical activity), and their clinical history. This paper seeks to bridge that gap by using machine learning to integrate these diverse data streams and identify which specific factors actually drive disease progression in early-stage OA.

Methods

The authors employed a "Super Learner" ensemble machine learning framework. Rather than picking one "best" algorithm, this approach combines several candidate learners—including Bayesian adaptive regression trees, Random Forests, XGBoost, and regularized regression (LASSO/Ridge)—to create a meta-model that optimizes prediction accuracy.

Key technical highlights include:

  • Feature Engineering: The model utilized 3D Ground Reaction Force (GRF) waveforms from force plates and 7-day tri-axial accelerometer data to characterize movement.
  • Robust Evaluation: To ensure the results weren't a fluke of a specific data split, they used repeated cross-validation (100 different train/test splits).
  • Causal Inference: After identifying the most influential predictors via a Variable Importance Measure (VIM), the researchers used g-computation to estimate the marginal causal risk difference. This allowed them to quantify exactly how much a specific factor (like walking style) increased the risk of cartilage worsening.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the Multicenter Osteoarthritis Study (MOST), a large longitudinal observational cohort.

  • Sample Size: 947 legs from participants with no or early-stage radiographic OA (Kellgren-Lawrence Grade $\le$ 2).
  • Ground Truth: Medial tibiofemoral cartilage worsening was defined using the MRI Osteoarthritis Knee Score (MOAKS) across a 2-year follow-up period.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Lateral Impulse" Discovery: The most striking finding was the importance of the lateral ground reaction force impulse. While many studies focus on vertical loading, this suggests that the "side-to-side" forces during walking are a critical, overlooked driver of medial cartilage decay.
  • Predicting the "Silent" Phase: The model successfully predicted worsening in a population that predominantly had little to no pain. This highlights the potential for ML to catch disease progression that is currently invisible to standard clinical assessments.
  • ML as a Discovery Tool: By using VIM and g-computation, the authors moved beyond "black box" prediction. They used the model to point researchers toward specific biomechanical targets that could be modified through physical therapy or specialized footwear.

Key Results

  • Predictive Performance: The ensemble model achieved a median AUC of 0.73 (ranging from 0.64 to 0.80) across 100 held-out test sets, which is comparable to or better than models using only clinical data for late-stage OA.
  • Prevalence: 14% of the 947 legs experienced significant medial cartilage worsening over the two years.
  • Risk Quantification: Walking with a high lateral GRF impulse was associated with a 5.5% higher risk of cartilage worsening compared to those with lower lateral impulse.
  • Top Predictors: The most consistent predictors across all data splits were baseline cartilage damage, higher KLG grade, and pain during walking.

Limitations and Future Work

The primary limitation is the specialized equipment required; measuring 3D ground reaction forces currently requires expensive force plates embedded in a lab floor, making it difficult to scale to a standard doctor's office. Additionally, the study population was largely White and had relatively low BMI, so the findings may not generalize perfectly to more diverse or higher-risk populations.

Future Work: The authors suggest that advances in wearable technology (like IMUs in shoes or sensors in smartphones) could eventually allow these gait metrics to be captured during everyday life. This would enable the "Super Learner" model to function as a real-world screening tool to identify at-risk patients long before they need a surgeon.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT Objective To 1) develop and evaluate a machine learning model incorporating gait and physical activity to predict medial tibiofemoral cartilage worsening over two years in individuals without or with early knee osteoarthritis and 2) identify influential predictors in the model and quantify their effect on cartilage worsening. Design An ensemble machine learning model was developed to predict worsened cartilage MRI Osteoarthritis Knee Score at follow-up from gait, physical activity, clinical and demographic data from the Multicenter Osteoarthritis Study. Model performance was evaluated in repeated cross-validations. The top 10 predictors of the outcome across 100 held-out test sets were identified by a variable importance measure statistic, and their marginal effect on the outcome was quantified by g-computation. Results Of 947 legs in the analysis, 14% experienced medial cartilage worsening at follow-up. The median (2.5 th -97.5 th percentile) AUC across the 100 held-out test sets was 0.73 (0.65-0.79). Presence of baseline cartilage damage, higher Kellgren-Lawrence grade, greater pain during walking, higher lateral ground reaction force impulse, greater time spent lying, and lower vertical ground reaction force unloading rate were associated with greater risk of cartilage worsening. Conclusions An ensemble machine learning approach incorporating gait, physical activity, and clinical/demographic features showed good performance for predicting cartilage worsening over two years. While identifying potential intervention targets from the model is challenging, these results suggest that lateral ground reaction force impulse, time spent lying, and vertical ground reaction force unloading rate should be investigated further as potential early intervention targets to reduce medial tibiofemoral cartilage worsening. Summary box What are the findings? Machine learning models predicted cartilage worsening in persons without or with early knee osteoarthritis from gait, physical activity, and clinical and demographic characteristics with a median AUC of 0.73 across 100 held-out test sets. High lateral ground reaction force impulse, more time spent lying, and low vertical ground reaction force unloading rate were associated with increased risk of cartilage worsening over two years. How might it impact on clinical practice in the future? Gait and physical activity are some of the only modifiable risk factors for knee osteoarthritis; this study identified three potential intervention targets to slow early knee osteoarthritis progression.
BibTeX
@misc{costello2022gait,
  author = {K.E. Costello and David T. Felson and S. Reza Jafarzadeh and Ali Guermazi and Frank W. Roemer and Neil A. Segal and Cora E. Lewis and Michael C. Nevitt and Cara L. Lewis and Vijaya B. Kolachalama and Deepak Kumar},
  title = {{Gait, physical activity, and tibiofemoral cartilage damage: A longitudinal machine learning analysis in the Multicenter Osteoarthritis Study}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1101/2022.06.30.22277057},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure