Further Evidence of Modified Spin-down in Sun-like Stars: Pileups in the Temperature-Period Distribution

Trevor J. David, Ruth Angus, Jason L. Curtis, Jennifer L. van Saders, Isabel L. Colman, Gabriella Contardo, Yuxi Lu, Joel ZinnarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We combine stellar surface rotation periods determined from NASA's Kepler mission with spectroscopic temperatures to demonstrate the existence of pileups at the long-period and short-period edges of the temperature-period distribution for main-sequence stars with temperatures exceeding $\sim 5500$K. The long-period pileup is well-described by a curve of constant Rossby number, with a critical value of $\mathrm{Ro_{crit}} \lesssim 2$. The long-period pileup was predicted by van Saders et al. (2019) as a consequence of weakened magnetic braking, in which wind-driven angular momentum losses cease once stars reach a critical Rossby number. Stars in the long-period pileup are found to have a wide range of ages ($\sim 2-6$Gyr), meaning that, along the pileup, rotation period is strongly predictive of a star's surface temperature but weakly predictive of its age. The short-period pileup, which is also well-described by a curve of constant Rossby number, is not a prediction of the weakened magnetic braking hypothesis but may instead be related to a phase of slowed surface spin-down due to core-envelope coupling. The same mechanism was proposed by Curtis et al. (2020) to explain the overlapping rotation sequences of low-mass members of differently aged open clusters. The relative dearth of stars with intermediate rotation periods between the short- and long-period pileups is also well-described by a curve of constant Rossby number, which aligns with the period gap initially discovered by McQuillan et al. (2013a) in M-type stars. These observations provide further support for the hypothesis that the period gap is due to stellar astrophysics, rather than a non-uniform star-formation history in the Kepler field.

Introduction: The Gyrochronology Problem

For decades, astronomers have relied on "gyrochronology"—the relationship between a star's rotation period and its age—to date Sun-like stars. The underlying principle is that stars lose angular momentum over time through magnetized winds, causing older stars to rotate more slowly. However, data from the Kepler mission revealed a significant discrepancy: older stars appear to rotate faster than standard models predict. This observation led to the "Weakened Magnetic Braking" (WMB) hypothesis, which suggests that magnetic braking efficiency drops significantly once a star reaches a critical Rossby number ($Ro$), the ratio of rotation period to convective turnover time.

A key challenge has been determining whether the observed "gap" in rotation periods is a physical phenomenon or an artifact of detection biases or non-uniform star formation in the Kepler field. This study seeks to confirm these features as astrophysical "pileups" rather than observational artifacts.

Datasets and Methodology

The authors combined stellar surface rotation periods from Kepler with high-precision spectroscopic temperatures from several large-scale surveys:

  • California-Kepler Survey (CKS): High-resolution spectra for approximately 1,300 planet hosts.
  • LAMOST DR5: Low-resolution spectra for roughly 40% of the Kepler field (~19,000 stars).
  • Kepler Rotation Catalogs: Primarily the McQuillan et al. (2014) and Santos et al. (2021) catalogs.
  • Asteroseismic Sample: A "gold standard" set of 91 stars from Hall et al. (2021) with rotation periods determined via asteroseismology, which is immune to spot-tracking biases.

By using precise spectroscopic temperatures instead of photometric ones, the researchers were able to resolve fine structures in the temperature-period distribution that were previously smeared out.

Evidence for Astrophysical Pileups

The analysis reveals distinct overdensities, or "pileups," in the temperature-rotation period plane. These features are well-described by curves of constant Rossby number across multiple independent datasets.

Density contours of the temperature-period distribution across different datasets, showing the alignment of pileups with constant Rossby number curves.

The Long-Period "Rossby Ridge"

The long-period edge of the distribution exhibits a sharp pileup, often referred to as the "Rossby Ridge." This feature confirms that stars do not slow down indefinitely; instead, they reach a rotation "floor" for their given temperature and remain there for billions of years. This pileup is well-described by a critical Rossby number $Ro_{crit} \lesssim 2$. Notably, the Sun sits very close to this long-period pileup, suggesting it may be entering or currently in the WMB phase.

The Short-Period Pileup and the Period Gap

In addition to the long-period ridge, a newly identified short-period pileup exists at $Ro \approx 0.4$ for stars between 4500 K and 5800 K. This feature likely stems from "core-envelope coupling," where the star's interior and exterior exchange angular momentum, temporarily halting surface spin-down. The "period gap"—a relative dearth of stars between these two pileups—is also well-described by a constant Rossby number curve, supporting a stellar physics origin rather than a star-formation history effect.

Quantitative Analysis of Distribution Edges

To quantify these features, the authors performed non-linear least-squares and Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) fits to the 10th and 90th percentiles of the rotation period distribution.

Quantitative fits to the 10th and 90th percentiles of the rotation period distribution using constant Rossby number models.

The fits demonstrate that the edges of the distribution are remarkably consistent with constant Rossby number curves across a wide temperature range. The WMB model was found to be statistically preferred over standard spin-down models, with a significant improvement in fit quality ($\Delta\chi^2 = 154$) for the upper edge.

Implications for Gyrochronology

The existence of these pileups has profound implications for stellar dating. Stars on the long-period pileup are found to have a wide range of ages (~2–6 Gyr). This means that for these stars, the rotation period is strongly predictive of surface temperature but weakly predictive of age. Essentially, gyrochronology "stalls" at these evolutionary stages, as rotation becomes decoupled from age for significant portions of a star's lifetime.

Conclusion

This work provides strong observational evidence for modified spin-down in Sun-like stars. While temperature systematics between surveys introduce some uncertainty in the exact critical Rossby numbers, the presence of the pileups themselves is robust. Future data from APOGEE DR17 and Gaia will be essential for further refining these distributions and testing the universality of these astrophysical features across different galactic environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

We combine stellar surface rotation periods determined from NASA's Kepler mission with spectroscopic temperatures to demonstrate the existence of pileups at the long-period and short-period edges of the temperature-period distribution for main-sequence stars with temperatures exceeding $\sim 5500$K. The long-period pileup is well-described by a curve of constant Rossby number, with a critical value of $\mathrm{Ro_{crit}} \lesssim 2$. The long-period pileup was predicted by van Saders et al. (2019) as a consequence of weakened magnetic braking, in which wind-driven angular momentum losses cease once stars reach a critical Rossby number. Stars in the long-period pileup are found to have a wide range of ages ($\sim 2-6$Gyr), meaning that, along the pileup, rotation period is strongly predictive of a star's surface temperature but weakly predictive of its age. The short-period pileup, which is also well-described by a curve of constant Rossby number, is not a prediction of the weakened magnetic braking hypothesis but may instead be related to a phase of slowed surface spin-down due to core-envelope coupling. The same mechanism was proposed by Curtis et al. (2020) to explain the overlapping rotation sequences of low-mass members of differently aged open clusters. The relative dearth of stars with intermediate rotation periods between the short- and long-period pileups is also well-described by a curve of constant Rossby number, which aligns with the period gap initially discovered by McQuillan et al. (2013a) in M-type stars. These observations provide further support for the hypothesis that the period gap is due to stellar astrophysics, rather than a non-uniform star-formation history in the Kepler field.
BibTeX
@misc{david2022further,
  author = {Trevor J. David and Ruth Angus and Jason L. Curtis and Jennifer L. van Saders and Isabel L. Colman and Gabriella Contardo and Yuxi Lu and Joel Zinn},
  title = {{Further Evidence of Modified Spin-down in Sun-like Stars: Pileups in the Temperature-Period Distribution}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2203.08920},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2203.08920},
}
Figure