Furnace Charging Comprehensive Optimization Technology of the Bell-type Annealing Process

Zhenhua Bai, Ya-ya Cui, Jun Zhang, Qilin Li, Boyang Li, Yu XingISIJ 2017 · DOI

Abstract: Sticking defect in the bell-type annealing process is closely related to furnace charging technology. Unsuitable furnace charging technology increases the additional radial pressure of some coils in the furnace and leads to sticking defect. A suitable furnace charging comprehensive optimization technology of the bell-type annealing process is introduced, which aims at sticking prevention. This technology was developed after field experiments and theoretical analyses based on defining the concept of sticking index, considering the influences of coiling technology, coil size, product specifications, and annealing technology on the steel internal stress. The coil work-base quantity was as close as possible to the theoretical minimum value, and the average and peak sticking index value of the same batch of coils as the target were minimized, balanced with production efficiency and defect prevention. This technology was applied to the production practice of a cold-rolled sheet plant, achieving good using effect with furnace charging efficiency. Production increased, and sticking defect decreased. Considerable economic benefit for the enterprise was created with further popularization and application values.

Introduction: The Challenge of Sticking Defects

In the production of cold-rolled steel, bell-type annealing is a critical step where tightly wound coils are stacked and heated to improve their mechanical properties. However, a major challenge for manufacturers is the sticking defect—a phenomenon where layers of the steel strip accidentally weld together during the heating cycle.

Because coils are stacked vertically, those at the bottom of the furnace bear the immense weight of the coils above them. This axial pressure, combined with high temperatures and internal thermal expansion, creates intense radial pressure. If this pressure exceeds a specific threshold, the layers can fuse. When the coil is later unwound, these "sticks" tear the surface, ruining the product. While previous research focused primarily on furnace efficiency, this study addresses how stacking order directly influences these quality failures.

The Poisson effect: axial pressure from the stack weight causes radial deformation, increasing the risk of sticking defects.

Methods: The Sticking Index and Optimization

The authors proposed a comprehensive optimization technology built on three pillars:

  1. Mechanical Stress Analysis: They modeled the total radial stress as a combination of initial coiling stress, thermal stress during heating, and additional pressure caused by the weight of upper coils (the Poisson effect).
  2. The Sticking Index (ξ): This core innovation is a dimensionless value comparing the maximum radial stress in a coil to the "critical stress" at which sticking occurs for a specific steel grade. A value of ξ ≥ 0 indicates a high risk of sticking.
  3. Multi-Objective Optimization: An algorithm was developed to arrange batches of coils to minimize the average and peak Sticking Index across the batch while maintaining high production efficiency by minimizing the number of furnace bases used.

Key Insights: The Bottom-Coil Vulnerability

Field data confirms that the bottom coil is significantly more likely to suffer sticking defects than the top coil, even when subjected to the same annealing temperature. This vulnerability is purely due to the physical weight of the stack. By defining the Sticking Index, the researchers transformed a manual, experience-based process into a precise mathematical optimization problem. The model demonstrates that throughput does not need to be sacrificed for quality; by intelligently pairing "heavy" and "light" coils, manufacturers can keep furnaces full without crushing the bottom layers.

Field data illustrating that sticking defects (categories B and C) are concentrated in the bottom and lower-middle layers where stack weight is highest.

Results and Industrial Impact

The technology was implemented via custom software at a cold-rolled sheet plant, yielding significant improvements over a one-year tracking period:

  • Defect Reduction: The occurrence rate of sticking defects decreased by 12.4%.
  • Productivity Boost: Overall production increased by 5.5% due to better furnace space optimization.
  • Economic Impact: The plant realized an annual economic benefit exceeding ¥5,000,000 (approx. $700,000 USD).

Limitations and Future Work

The "critical stress" value is highly dependent on steel grade and surface roughness, requiring laboratory tests for every new material type. Additionally, the current model assumes a standard bell-type furnace structure; changes in furnace geometry would require recalibrating the stress models. Future work will focus on refining the weighting coefficients in the multi-objective function across diverse industrial environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

Sticking defect in the bell-type annealing process is closely related to furnace charging technology. Unsuitable furnace charging technology increases the additional radial pressure of some coils in the furnace and leads to sticking defect. A suitable furnace charging comprehensive optimization technology of the bell-type annealing process is introduced, which aims at sticking prevention. This technology was developed after field experiments and theoretical analyses based on defining the concept of sticking index, considering the influences of coiling technology, coil size, product specifications, and annealing technology on the steel internal stress. The coil work-base quantity was as close as possible to the theoretical minimum value, and the average and peak sticking index value of the same batch of coils as the target were minimized, balanced with production efficiency and defect prevention. This technology was applied to the production practice of a cold-rolled sheet plant, achieving good using effect with furnace charging efficiency. Production increased, and sticking defect decreased. Considerable economic benefit for the enterprise was created with further popularization and application values.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bai2017furnace,
  author = {Zhenhua Bai and Ya-ya Cui and Jun Zhang and Qilin Li and Boyang Li and Yu Xing},
  title = {{Furnace Charging Comprehensive Optimization Technology of the Bell-type Annealing Process}},
  booktitle = {ISIJ},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.2355/isijinternational.isijint-2016-476},
}
Figure