Functioning styles of personality disorders and five-factor normal personality traits: a correlation study in Chinese students

Wei Wang, Lan Hu, Ling Mu, Dahong Chen, Song Qi, Mengping Zhou, Weijuan Zhang, Jun Hou, Zhigang Li, Jun Wang, Jianhui Liu, Chengsen HeBMC 2003 · DOI

Abstract

The PERM constructs were loaded in a predictable way on the disordered super-traits, suggesting the PERM might offer assistance measuring personality function in clinical practice.

Introduction

Psychiatry has long debated whether personality disorders (PDs) are distinct clinical categories or simply extreme points on a spectrum of normal personality variation. While the Five-Factor Model (FFM) is the gold standard for describing normal personality, clinicians require tools that specifically capture the dysfunctional "styles" associated with PDs.

The Parker Personality Measure (PERM) was developed to provide an efficient, first-level clinical assessment of these styles. This study examines how PERM constructs align with established personality models in a large sample of Chinese students, bridging the gap between Western-developed tools and non-Western populations.

Methods and Data

The researchers recruited 913 healthy students from poly-technical schools and colleges in China. Participants were categorized into "Adult" (18–25 years) and "Child" (13–17 years) groups to assess factor congruence across different developmental stages.

Demographic characteristics of the study sample

Participants completed three distinct questionnaires:

  1. PERM: Measures 11 personality disorder styles (e.g., Paranoid, Schizoid, Borderline).
  2. FFNPQ (Five-Factor Nonverbal Personality Questionnaire): A 60-item tool using pictorial depictions of behaviors to measure the Big Five traits, bypassing potential translation issues.
  3. ZKPQ (Zuckerman-Kuhlman Personality Questionnaire): An alternative model measuring traits like Impulsive Sensation Seeking and Neuroticism-Anxiety.

Results

The study utilized Principal Component Analysis (PCA) to determine how the 21 constructs from the three inventories clustered together. The analysis confirmed that disordered personality traits reliably load onto four higher-order "super-traits": Dissocial, Emotional Dysregulation, Inhibition, and Compulsivity.

Correlation matrix of personality constructs

Key findings include:

  • Factor Loadings: PERM constructs loaded predictably. For instance, PERM Antisocial loaded heavily (.81) on the "Dissocial" factor, while PERM Avoidant (.81) and Dependent (.77) loaded on "Emotional Dysregulation."
  • Experience Hunting: A fifth factor emerged, primarily driven by the nonverbal FFNPQ (Openness, Conscientiousness, and Extraversion). This factor was not captured by the PD-specific PERM or the ZKPQ, suggesting that normal personality inventories capture positive growth-oriented traits that clinical tools may overlook.
  • Demographics: Younger women scored significantly higher on traits related to Emotional Dysregulation compared to men.

Discussion and Conclusion

The underlying structure of these personality constructs remained remarkably stable in a Chinese sample, demonstrating cross-cultural robustness. However, some PERM scales, such as Schizoid and Obsessive-Compulsive, showed lower internal consistency, suggesting a need for cultural adaptation in how these traits are expressed or interpreted in China.

While the study is limited by its use of a non-clinical, self-reporting sample, the results suggest that the PERM is a promising tool for measuring personality function. Future research should apply the PERM in actual clinical practice to validate its predictive power for formal DSM-IV diagnoses.

Summary updated

Abstract

The PERM constructs were loaded in a predictable way on the disordered super-traits, suggesting the PERM might offer assistance measuring personality function in clinical practice.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2003functioning,
  author = {Wei Wang and Lan Hu and Ling Mu and Dahong Chen and Song Qi and Mengping Zhou and Weijuan Zhang and Jun Hou and Zhigang Li and Jun Wang and Jianhui Liu and Chengsen He},
  title = {{Functioning styles of personality disorders and five-factor normal personality traits: a correlation study in Chinese students}},
  booktitle = {BMC},
  year = {2003},
  doi = {10.1186/1471-244x-3-11},
}
Figure