Abstract
Brain functional connectivity (FC) derived from functional magnetic resonance imaging has been serving as a potential ‘fingerprint’ for adults. However, cross-scan variation of FC can be substantial and carries biological information, especially during childhood. Here we performed a large-scale cross-sectional analysis on cross-scan FC stability and its associations with a diverse range of health measures in children. Functional network connectivity (FNC) was extracted via a hybrid independent component analysis framework on 9,071 participants and compared across four scans. We found that FNC can identify a given child from a large group with high accuracy (maximum >94%) and replicated the results across multiple scans. We then performed a linear mixed-effects model to investigate how cross-scan FNC stability was predictive of children’s behaviour. Although we could not find strong relationships between FNC stability and children’s behaviour, we observed significant but small associations between them (maximum r = 0.1070), with higher stability correlated with better cognitive performance, longer sleep duration and less psychotic expression. Via a multivariate analysis method, we captured larger effects between FNC stability and children’s cognitive performance (maximum r = 0.2932), which further proved the relevance of FNC stability to neurocognitive development. Overall, our findings show that a child’s connectivity profile is not only intrinsic but also exhibits reliable variability across scans, regardless of brain growth and development. Cross-scan connectivity stability may serve as a valuable neuroimaging feature to draw inferences on early cognitive and psychiatric behaviours in children.
Introduction
In adults, functional connectivity (FC)—the synchronized activity between different brain regions—is stable enough to identify individuals across different days or tasks, acting as a "brain fingerprint." However, children’s brains undergo rapid developmental changes. This study addresses two critical questions: first, is a child’s FC profile unique enough to be a reliable fingerprint despite these changes? Second, is the observed variation between scans merely noise, or does it carry meaningful biological information? Leveraging the massive Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development (ABCD) study, researchers established robust links between brain connectivity stability and behavioral phenotypes.
Methodology
The researchers employed the Neuromark Framework, a hybrid Independent Component Analysis (ICA) approach. Unlike rigid anatomical atlases, this framework uses templates from independent datasets (HCP and GSP) to extract 53 "Intrinsic Connectivity Networks" (ICNs) that are spatially comparable across participants while remaining flexible enough to capture individual-specific time-courses.
From these time-courses, Functional Network Connectivity (FNC) matrices were calculated for each scan. To assess the uniqueness and stability of these profiles, the team compared FNC matrices within and across participants to determine identification accuracy.
Statistical analysis involved Linear Mixed-Effects Models (LMM) to relate FNC stability to behavior while accounting for confounding variables like age, sex, and family environment. Additionally, Partial Least Squares Regression (PLSR) was used to predict cognitive scores from connectivity stability.
Key Results and Insights
The study revealed that FNC could identify a specific child from a group of thousands with over 94% accuracy within the same session and approximately 91% accuracy across a two-year interval. This confirms that the "brain fingerprint" is present and identifiable even during childhood.
Crucially, the "wobble" or variability across scans proved to be biologically significant. Higher connectivity stability was associated with:
- Cognitive Performance: Better scores in vocabulary, memory, and processing speed. While univariate correlations were modest ($r \approx 0.11$), the multivariate PLSR model showed a much stronger relationship ($r = 0.2932$).
- Mental Health & Sleep: Lower stability (higher variability) correlated with increased social problems, psychotic-like experiences, and shorter sleep duration.
- Developmental Maturation: Female participants exhibited higher identification accuracy and greater FC stability than males, aligning with theories that female brain networks reach stable, adult-like states earlier.
Furthermore, a child’s FC stability was found to correlate with parental mental health and prenatal history, suggesting that brain stability is a neurobiological endophenotype influenced by both genetic and early environmental factors.
Conclusion and Future Directions
While the associations are statistically significant, the effect sizes in univariate analyses remain small, highlighting a common challenge in large-scale neuroimaging. As a cross-sectional study, it cannot definitively establish causality—whether low stability causes psychiatric issues or vice versa. Future research integrating genetic data and high-frequency "moment-by-moment" monitoring will be essential to further unravel the drivers of connectivity variability and its role in neurodevelopment.
Summary updated