Functional Connectivity Uniqueness and Variability? A Signature of Cognitive and Psychiatric Problems in Children

Zening Fu, Jingyu Liu, Mustafa S. Salman, Jing Sui, Vince D. CalhounResearch Square 2022 · DOI

Abstract

Brain functional connectivity (FC) derived from functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) has been serving as a potential “fingerprint” for adults. However, intra-subject variation of FC can be substantial and carry biologically meaningful information, especially during adolescence, a time of intense brain changes. Here, for the first time, we performed a large-scale analysis on cross-scan FC stability and its association with a diverse range of health measures in children from the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development (ABCD) data. Functional network connectivity (FNC), a network analog of FC, was extracted via an automated independent component analysis framework on 9071 subjects (age: 9~11 years) and compared across 4 scans. We found that the FNC profile can identify a given child from a large group with high accuracy (> 80%), though intra-subject variations exist cross-scan. The robustness of this finding is verified by replicating the child identification using the second-year scans and between longitudinal scans with a two-year interval. Moreover, cross-scan FNC stability was predictive of sleep condition, cognitive performance, and psychiatric problems in children, with higher stability correlated with better cognitive performance, longer sleep duration, and less psychotic expression. Meanwhile, parental psychopathology and prenatal exposure were associated with the FNC stability in their children. Overall, our findings show that a child’s connectivity profile is not only intrinsic but also exhibits reliable variability cross-scan, regardless of brain growth and development. The intra-subject connectivity stability may serve as a valuable biomarker to draw inferences on early cognitive and psychiatric behaviors in children.

Introduction

In adults, functional connectivity (FC)—the statistical correlation between activity in different brain regions—is stable enough to serve as a "neural fingerprint." However, applying this concept to children is challenging. The pre-adolescent brain is characterized by intense neuroplasticity and rapid development, leading to significant intra-subject variation. Previous studies have often been limited by small sample sizes and a focus on the mere existence of a fingerprint rather than the biological significance of its variability. This study addresses whether cross-scan variability in a child's brain connectivity is random noise or a meaningful biomarker for cognitive and psychiatric health.

Methodology

The researchers analyzed data from the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development (ABCD) study, involving 9,071 children (ages 9–11) at baseline and 2,918 at a two-year follow-up. Using the Neuromark framework, an automated Independent Component Analysis (ICA) approach, they identified 53 intrinsic connectivity networks (ICNs). Unlike traditional atlas-based methods, Neuromark allows for individual variation while maintaining cross-subject comparability.

The primary metric was Functional Network Connectivity (FNC). Stability was assessed by comparing FNC matrices across four resting-state fMRI scans within a single session and across longitudinal sessions. Linear Mixed-Effect Models (LMM) were employed to correlate FNC stability with neurocognitive and psychiatric assessments, controlling for age, gender, and family structure.

Results

The Robust Neural Fingerprint

Despite the dynamic nature of the developing brain, children could be identified from a group of over 9,000 peers with high accuracy. Within a single session, identification accuracy reached 93.99%. Remarkably, even across a two-year developmental gap, accuracy remained high at 91.43% when averaging scans. This confirms that FNC profiles are highly individualistic and persistent.

Stability as a Biomarker

The study found that the stability of these fingerprints across scans is a potent indicator of health:

  • Cognitive Performance: Higher FNC stability significantly correlated with better performance across all 10 cognitive summary scores (e.g., Total Composite Score: $r = 0.1070, p < 4.82 \times 10^{-24}$).
  • Psychiatric Health: Lower stability (higher "jitter" in brain networks) was associated with increased social problems, psychotic expression, and mania. 12 out of 20 psychiatric problem scores showed a significant negative correlation with stability.
  • Lifestyle Factors: Better sleep quality (longer duration, faster sleep onset) and reduced screen time were linked to higher FNC stability.
Figure 1: Overview of the FNC identification framework and its correlation with behavioral measures.

FNC stability was also associated with external factors. Positive parental behaviors were linked to higher stability in children, whereas prenatal exposure to substances like tobacco or marijuana correlated with lower stability.

Discussion

These findings suggest that a child’s brain connectivity profile is both intrinsic and reliably variable. FNC stability appears to represent a "relaxed" but ready brain state conducive to efficient cognitive reconfiguration. While the study establishes strong correlations, the causal directions—such as whether poor sleep causes instability or vice versa—require further investigation. Future research incorporating genetic data will be crucial to distinguish between inherited traits and environmental influences on neural stability.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Brain functional connectivity (FC) derived from functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) has been serving as a potential “fingerprint” for adults. However, intra-subject variation of FC can be substantial and carry biologically meaningful information, especially during adolescence, a time of intense brain changes. Here, for the first time, we performed a large-scale analysis on cross-scan FC stability and its association with a diverse range of health measures in children from the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development (ABCD) data. Functional network connectivity (FNC), a network analog of FC, was extracted via an automated independent component analysis framework on 9071 subjects (age: 9~11 years) and compared across 4 scans. We found that the FNC profile can identify a given child from a large group with high accuracy (&gt; 80%), though intra-subject variations exist cross-scan. The robustness of this finding is verified by replicating the child identification using the second-year scans and between longitudinal scans with a two-year interval. Moreover, cross-scan FNC stability was predictive of sleep condition, cognitive performance, and psychiatric problems in children, with higher stability correlated with better cognitive performance, longer sleep duration, and less psychotic expression. Meanwhile, parental psychopathology and prenatal exposure were associated with the FNC stability in their children. Overall, our findings show that a child’s connectivity profile is not only intrinsic but also exhibits reliable variability cross-scan, regardless of brain growth and development. The intra-subject connectivity stability may serve as a valuable biomarker to draw inferences on early cognitive and psychiatric behaviors in children.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{fu2022functional,
  author = {Zening Fu and Jingyu Liu and Mustafa S. Salman and Jing Sui and Vince D. Calhoun},
  title = {{Functional Connectivity Uniqueness and Variability? A Signature of Cognitive and Psychiatric Problems in Children}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-1514598/v1},
}
Figure