Functional and Structural Moment Arm Validation for Musculoskeletal Models: A Study of the Human Forearm and Hand
Matthew T. Boots, Russell L. Hardesty, Anton R. Sobinov, Valeriya Gritsenko, Jennifer L. Collinger, Lee E. Fisher, Robert A. Gaunt, Sergiy YakovenkobioRxiv2020 · DOI
Developing realistic musculoskeletal models is crucial for understanding sensorimotor control and improving artificial limb design. However, accurate models require extensive validation against sparse experimental data. This study introduces a multi-stage validation framework for a human forearm and hand model, addressing "assembly errors" in muscle paths. By rigorously matching simulated moment arms to experimental profiles and identifying structural failures in unobserved postures, the researchers significantly improved model accuracy. A key finding reveals that assuming constant moment arms leads to a 35% error in predicted wrist torque, highlighting the necessity of posture-dependent modeling.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Musculoskeletal (MS) models serve as "digital twins" in biomechanics, yet modeling the human hand is exceptionally difficult due to its complex anatomy and the sparsity of experimental data on "moment arms"—the mechanical leverage muscles exert on joints.
The 18-DOF musculoskeletal model of the human forearm and hand featuring 32 musculotendon actuators.
Existing models often suffer from "structural failures," such as tendons unphysically slipping off bones during movement. This can cause "zero-crossing errors," where a muscle's function (e.g., flexion vs. extension) flips incorrectly. Without systematic validation, researchers often simplify models by assuming constant moment arms, which severely limits their predictive accuracy.
Methods
The researchers employed a three-step validation process within the OpenSim environment:
Structural Validation (Observed): Simulated moment arms were compared against a meta-dataset of experimental values from cadaveric and MRI studies. Adjustments were made to "wrapping objects" and "via-points" to minimize error and maximize correlation.
Structural Validation (Unobserved): To address postures lacking experimental data, the team developed automated checks for functional flipping and force imbalances at postural extremes.
Multi-dimensional validation approach for handling sparse experimental data across 1D, 2D, and 3D posture spaces.
Functional Validation: Maximum isometric forces were scaled using published torque data, following a "distal-to-proximal" strategy—validating finger muscles before the more complex wrist muscles.
Key Results and Insights
Significant Accuracy Gains: The validation process improved the model's structural score by 1.51x, increasing the proportion of "high-quality" muscle profiles from 8.6% to 73.5%.
The 35% Torque Error: The study demonstrated that assuming constant moment arms results in a 34.9% mean decrease in predicted wrist torque amplitude. This confirms that the body's geometry is "tuned" to maintain torque capacity across different muscle lengths.
The "Zero-Crossing" Indicator: Unexpected sign reversals in moment arms were identified as a critical "red flag" for modeling errors, signaling broken wrapping geometry.
Conclusion
This study underscores that rigorous structural and functional validation is essential for realistic hand dynamics. While the current manual iteration is time-consuming, it paves the way for future automated optimization of high-fidelity, subject-specific models for clinical and prosthetic applications.
Summary updated
Abstract
Abstract The development of realistic musculoskeletal models is a fundamental goal for the theoretical progress in sensorimotor control and its engineering applications, e.g., in the biomimetic control of artificial limbs. Yet, accurate models require extensive experimental measures to validate structural and functional parameters describing muscle state over the full physiological range of motion. However, available experimental measurements of, for example, muscle moment arms are sparse and often disparate. Validation of these models is not trivial because of the highly complex anatomy and behavior of human limbs. In this study, we developed a method to validate and scale kinematic muscle parameters using posture-dependent moment arm profiles, isometric force measurements, and a computational detection of assembly errors. We used a previously published model with 18 degrees of freedom (DOFs) and 32 musculotendon actuators with force generated from a Hill-type muscle model. The muscle path from origin to insertion with wrapping geometry was used to model the muscle lengths and moment arms. We simulated moment arm profiles across the full physiological range of motion and compared them to an assembled dataset of published and merged experimental profiles. The muscle paths were adjusted using custom metrics based on root-mean-square and correlation coefficient of the difference between simulated and experimental values. Since the available measurements were sparse and the examination of high-dimensional muscles is challenging, we developed analyses to identify common failures, i.e., moment arm functional flipping due to the sign reversal in simulated moments and the imbalance of force generation between antagonistic groups in postural extremes. The validated model was used to evaluate the expected errors in torque generation with the assumption of constant instead of the posture-dependent moment arms at the wrist flexion-extension DOF, which is the critical joint in our model with the largest number of crossing muscles. We found that there was a reduction of joint torques by about 35% in the extreme quartiles of the wrist DOF. The use of realistic musculoskeletal models is essential for the reconstruction of hand dynamics. These models may improve the understanding of muscle actions and help in the design and control of artificial limbs in future applications. New & Noteworthy Realistic models of human limbs are a development goal required for the understanding of motor control and its applications in biomedical fields. However, developing accurate models is restrained by the lack of accurate and reliable musculoskeletal measurements in humans. Here, we have overcome this challenge by using multi-stage validation of simulated structures using both experimental data and the identification of structural failures in the high-dimensional muscle paths. We demonstrate that the rigorous structural and functional validation method is essential for the understanding of force generation at the wrist.
BibTeX
@misc{boots2020functional,
author = {Matthew T. Boots and Russell L. Hardesty and Anton R. Sobinov and Valeriya Gritsenko and Jennifer L. Collinger and Lee E. Fisher and Robert A. Gaunt and Sergiy Yakovenko},
title = {{Functional and Structural Moment Arm Validation for Musculoskeletal Models: A Study of the Human Forearm and Hand}},
year = {2020},
doi = {10.1101/2020.05.29.124644},
howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}