Fun with F_24

Sarah Harrison, Natalie Paquette, Daniel Persson, Roberto VolpatoOpenReview 2023 · arXiv · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper explores the rich mathematical structures hidden within a seemingly simple 2D quantum field theory: 24 free chiral fermions, known as F24. The authors construct a new family of infinite-dimensional Lie superalgebras, called Borcherds-Kac-Moody (BKM) superalgebras, derived from F24. These findings offer new examples of these complex algebraic structures and shed light on their potential role in string theory and related areas.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper delves into the intricate connections between quantum field theories (specifically, 2D conformal field theories or CFTs) and advanced mathematical structures like Lie superalgebras. While simple 2D fermionic systems are known to exhibit interesting physics, this work focuses on uncovering the hidden algebraic machinery. The authors investigate F24, a specific CFT with 24 chiral free fermions and a central charge of 12, which is one of only three "self-dual" CFTs with this central charge. The core problem is to understand the structure of physical states in chiral superstring theories compactified on F24 and to demonstrate that these states form specific types of Lie superalgebras, namely Borcherds-Kac-Moody (BKM) superalgebras. This addresses a gap in the explicit construction of such algebras and their relation to fundamental string theory models.

Methods

The authors employ a multi-pronged approach rooted in superconformal field theory and algebraic structures:

  • Super Vertex Operator Algebras (SVOAs): They start by defining F24 as a holomorphic SVOA with central charge 12, generated by 24 chiral free fermions. They then explore the concept of N=1 supercurrents, which are crucial for defining the N=1 superconformal structure of F24. The choice of these supercurrents is shown to be classified by 24-dimensional semisimple Lie algebras.
  • Orbifolding: A key technique used is orbifolding, where a symmetry is applied to a larger theory to obtain a smaller one. They demonstrate that F24, with any of its N=1 supercurrent choices, can be obtained by orbifolding a related theory based on the E8 lattice (VfE8). This provides a way to connect different CFTs and understand their relationships.
  • BRST Cohomology: To construct the physical states of a chiral superstring, the authors utilize BRST quantization and analyze the resulting cohomology. This process involves identifying states that are invariant under certain symmetry operations and are "closed" under the BRST charge.
  • Borcherds-Kac-Moody (BKM) Superalgebras: The core of the paper is the construction of BKM superalgebras from the cohomology of physical states. They prove that these constructed algebras satisfy the defining properties of BKM superalgebras, which are infinite-dimensional Lie superalgebras with a specific structure that allows for roots of non-positive norm.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hidden Algebraic Structure: The paper reveals that a seemingly simple system of 24 free fermions (F24) harbors a complex and rich algebraic structure, specifically in the form of Borcherds-Kac-Moody (BKM) superalgebras. This highlights how fundamental physics can be deeply intertwined with advanced mathematics.
  • Classification of N=1 Structures: The choice of an N=1 supercurrent on F24 is not arbitrary but is directly linked to the structure of 24-dimensional semisimple Lie algebras. This provides a clear classification scheme for the different N=1 superconformal structures F24 can possess.
  • Interconnectedness of CFTs: The demonstration that F24 can be obtained via orbifolding from the E8 lattice-based SCFT (VfE8) establishes a concrete link between these distinct but related theories. This is crucial for understanding dualities in string theory.
  • New Examples of BKM Superalgebras: The paper provides a family of new explicit constructions of BKM superalgebras. These are rare and important mathematical objects, and their connection to F24 offers new avenues for their study.
  • Potential for BPS State Connections: The authors suggest that these BKM superalgebras might be related to the algebraic structure of BPS states in string theory, a long-standing area of research. This opens up exciting possibilities for future investigations.

Key Results

  • The paper constructs eight distinct Lie superalgebras of "physical" states for a chiral superstring compactified on F24.
  • It is proven that all these constructed superalgebras are Borcherds-Kac-Moody (BKM) superalgebras.
  • A method is presented to obtain F24, with any of its N=1 supercurrent choices, via orbifolding from the E8 lattice-based SCFT (VfE8).
  • The paper provides explicit formulas for the denominator and superdenominator of these newly constructed BKM superalgebras.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Explicit Root Descriptions: While the paper establishes the existence of BKM superalgebras for various semisimple Lie algebras, it only provides a detailed analysis of the roots for the A1 case. Determining the simple roots and additive sides of the denominator identities for the remaining cases is left as future work.
  • Connection to Non-Chiral Models: The authors suggest exploring the role of F24 and its associated BKM algebras in the context of non-chiral string constructions and their relation to curve counts.
  • Cohomology and Anomalies: Further investigation into the semirelative cohomology of these models is proposed, as it may contain information about anomalies and D-brane states.
  • Discrete Symmetry Groups: The paper suggests studying the discrete symmetry groups of the BKM algebras, which could lead to generalizations of existing constructions.
  • BPS States and Moonshine: The authors express interest in understanding the role of these BKM algebras in the context of BPS states and their potential connection to moonshine phenomena, particularly in contrast to related theories like Vfh.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study some special features of F24, the holomorphic c=12 superconformal field theory (SCFT) given by 24 chiral free fermions. We construct eight different Lie superalgebras of "physical" states of a chiral superstring compactified on F24, and we prove that they all have the structure of Borcherds-Kac-Moody superalgebras. This produces a family of new examples of such superalgebras. The models depend on the choice of an N=1 supercurrent on F24, with the admissible choices labeled by the semisimple Lie algebras of dimension 24. We also discuss how F24, with any such choice of supercurrent, can be obtained via orbifolding from another distinguished c=12 holomorphic SCFT, the N=1 supersymmetric version of the chiral CFT based on the E8 lattice.
BibTeX
@misc{harrison2023fun,
  author = {Sarah Harrison and Natalie Paquette and Daniel Persson and Roberto Volpato},
  title = {{Fun with F\_24}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2009.14710},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2009.14710},
  howpublished = {OpenReview},
}

Loading related content...

Figure