Fully Microstrip Three-Port Circuit Bandpass NGD Design and Test

Blaise Ravelo, Alexandre Douyère, Yang Liu, Wenceslas Rahajandraibe, Fayu Wan, George Chan, Mathieu GuerinIEEE Des. Test 2023 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel design for a three-port microstrip circuit that exhibits a "double bandpass negative group delay" (BP-NGD) effect. This innovative design is crucial for mitigating signal delay issues in high-speed communication systems and has been successfully modeled, simulated, and experimentally validated.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In modern high-speed electronic systems, signal integrity is paramount. As devices become more integrated and operate at higher frequencies, signal delays and distortions become significant challenges. These issues can lead to errors, reduced performance, and even system failures. Traditional methods for managing these delays often involve complex circuit designs or specialized components. Negative Group Delay (NGD) is a phenomenon where a signal appears to emerge from a circuit before it enters, effectively counteracting or reducing existing signal delays. While NGD has been explored, particularly in two-port circuits, extending this capability to multi-port systems, like the three-port circuits common in complex interconnects, presents significant design and theoretical hurdles. This paper tackles the challenge of designing and implementing a three-port circuit that can achieve a bandpass NGD effect, offering a more versatile solution for signal delay management in complex electronic architectures.

Methods

The authors propose a novel three-port microstrip circuit topology based on transmission lines (TLs) with resistive terminations. The core of their approach involves:

  • Transfer Matrix Modeling: They employ a transfer matrix method to analytically model the circuit's behavior. This allows for a systematic derivation of the voltage transfer functions (VTFs) for the different signal paths within the three-port structure.
  • Double Branch NGD Theory: The BP-NGD effect is theorized by analyzing the equivalent models of the voltage transfer functions between the input port and the two output ports. They derive innovative formulas for group delay (GD) based on the TL parameters.
  • Circuit Design and Implementation: A prototype circuit was designed and fabricated using a Rogers Duroid-AD1000 dielectric substrate and standard SMD resistors.
  • Validation: The theoretical models were validated through simulations using MATLAB and commercial tools, and crucially, through experimental measurements using a Vector Network Analyzer (VNA).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical modeling, simulation, and experimental validation of a custom-designed circuit.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Three-Port NGD is Achievable: The paper demonstrates that a bandpass NGD effect can be successfully implemented in a three-port circuit, expanding the applicability of NGD technology beyond two-port configurations.
  • Distributed Design Advantage: The proposed circuit relies on distributed elements (transmission lines) and passive resistors, avoiding the need for complex active or lumped reactive components, which simplifies fabrication and potentially improves performance at higher frequencies.
  • Dual-Path NGD: The circuit exhibits the BP-NGD effect on both output branches simultaneously, offering a versatile solution for managing delays in systems with multiple signal paths.
  • Robustness to Parameter Variations: Sensitivity analyses show that the BP-NGD function is largely conserved even with moderate variations in key circuit parameters like characteristic impedance and propagation delays, suggesting practical implementability.
  • Potential for Skew Reduction: The authors highlight the significant potential of this three-port NGD circuit for applications like skew reduction in communication systems, signal desynchronization, and delay difference suppression.

Key Results

  • Measured NGD Performance: The fabricated prototype achieved a measured NGD value of approximately -3.8 ns and a bandwidth of 75 MHz at a center frequency of about 0.74 GHz for one of the transmission paths.
  • Good Agreement: Calculated, simulated, and measured results for VTF magnitudes and GDs showed very good correlation, validating the theoretical model and design approach.
  • Low Attenuation: The circuit demonstrated low attenuation, particularly on one of the transmission paths, which is desirable for maintaining signal integrity.
  • Comparison to Prior Art: The proposed three-port NGD circuit offers advantages over existing two-port NGD designs, including the ability to generate BP-NGD on multiple paths and the use of fully distributed elements.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Frequency Range: The current prototype operates in the hundreds of MHz range. Future work could focus on extending this to higher frequencies (tens of GHz) for more demanding applications.
  • Parameter Sensitivity: While the circuit shows robustness, further investigation into optimizing parameter tolerances for specific applications might be beneficial.
  • Application Development: The paper outlines potential applications like skew reduction and signal desynchronization. Further research and development are needed to fully realize these applications with the proposed circuit.
  • Optimization: While the design is functional, further optimization of the NGD characteristics (e.g., deeper NGD values, wider bandwidths) could be explored.

Summary updated

Abstract

This article presents design and test of three-port distributed circuit exhibiting double bandpass (BP) negative group delay (NGD) effect.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ravelo2023fully,
  author = {Blaise Ravelo and Alexandre Douyère and Yang Liu and Wenceslas Rahajandraibe and Fayu Wan and George Chan and Mathieu Guerin},
  title = {{Fully Microstrip Three-Port Circuit Bandpass NGD Design and Test}},
  booktitle = {IEEE Des. Test},
  year = {2023},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=Nxc2JhDKOW},
}
Figure