Full simulation study of the top Yukawa coupling at the ILC at $$\sqrt{s}=1$$ TeV

T. Price, P. Roloff, J. Strube, T. TanabeThe European Physical Journal C 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a detailed simulation study for measuring the top Yukawa coupling ($y_t$) at the proposed International Linear Collider (ILC) operating at 1 TeV. The study estimates that a precision of 4.5% can be achieved with 1 ab⁻¹ of integrated luminosity, improving to 4% with a specific beam polarization configuration, offering a crucial test of the Standard Model.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Standard Model (SM) of particle physics predicts a specific coupling strength between the Higgs boson and fermions, proportional to their mass. The top quark, being the heaviest known elementary particle, provides a critical test of this prediction through its Yukawa coupling ($y_t$). Deviations in $y_t$ from the SM prediction could signal new physics, such as composite Higgs models. While the LHC can probe $y_t$, its precision is limited. This paper addresses the need for a more precise measurement of $y_t$ by exploring the capabilities of the ILC at a high center-of-mass energy (1 TeV), which is expected to offer a cleaner environment and complementary measurements to the LHC.

Methods

The study employs detailed simulations of two proposed ILC detector concepts: SiD and ILD. The core of the analysis involves simulating the production of Higgs bosons in association with top quark-antiquark pairs ($e^+e^- \rightarrow t\bar{t}H$). The researchers focus on final states with at least six hadronic jets, which are challenging to reconstruct due to the high multiplicity of particles. They utilize sophisticated event generators (PHYSSIM, WHIZARD) and detector simulation tools (GEANT4, MarlinReco, PandoraPFA) to model the physics processes and detector responses. Key techniques include:

  • Particle Flow Algorithms: Used by both SiD and ILD for reconstructing particles from calorimeter and tracking information, crucial for handling complex multi-jet events.
  • Heavy Flavor Tagging: Advanced classifiers are developed to identify jets originating from b-quarks, essential for distinguishing signal from background.
  • Boosted Decision Trees (BDTs): Employed for event selection, combining various discriminating variables to optimize signal significance.
  • Jet Clustering Algorithms: Both Durham and k$_T$ algorithms are used and compared for reconstructing jets.
  • Beam-Induced Background Simulation: The study explicitly accounts for and mitigates the impact of background processes inherent to high-luminosity $e^+e^-$ colliders.

Datasets

The study utilizes simulated datasets generated for various signal and background processes at $\sqrt{s} = 1$ TeV. These include:

  • Signal: $t\bar{t}H$ events, with Higgs decaying into a $b\bar{b}$ pair.
  • Backgrounds: $t\bar{t}Z$ (with Z decaying to $b\bar{b}$), $t\bar{t}g^*$ (where $g^*$ splits into $b\bar{b}$), and $t\bar{t}$ events.

The simulations incorporate realistic beam energy spectra, initial state radiation, and beamstrahlung. The analysis is performed for an integrated luminosity of 1 ab⁻¹, split equally between two beam polarization configurations: $P(e^-, e^+) = (-80\%, +20\%)$ and $P(e^-, e^+) = (+80\%, -20\%)$.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • High-Energy ILC as a Precision Frontier: The 1 TeV ILC offers a unique opportunity for high-precision measurements of fundamental couplings like $y_t$, complementing LHC results.
  • Multi-Jet Reconstruction is Feasible: Despite the complexity of reconstructing events with six or more hadronic jets, the study demonstrates that robust reconstruction and selection are achievable with advanced detector concepts and analysis techniques.
  • Beam-Induced Backgrounds are Manageable: The simulations show that while beam-induced backgrounds are significant, they can be effectively handled through detector design and analysis strategies, particularly with time-stamping capabilities.
  • Polarization is Key: The choice of beam polarization significantly impacts the achievable precision, with a fully polarized negative electron beam ($P(e^-, e^+) = -80\%$) offering the best results.
  • Detector Concepts are Comparable: The study finds that both the SiD and ILD detector concepts yield very similar precisions for the $y_t$ measurement, suggesting that the physics potential is robust across different design choices.

Key Results

The study estimates the following statistical precisions for the top Yukawa coupling ($y_t$) measurement:

  • With 1 ab⁻¹ luminosity, split between two polarization configurations: 4.5%
  • With 1 ab⁻¹ luminosity, using only $P(e^-, e^+) = (-80\%, +20\%)$ polarization: 4%

These precisions are derived from combining results from both the six-jet and eight-jet final state analyses. The study also highlights that systematic uncertainties are expected to be comparable to or smaller than statistical uncertainties at this energy.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Statistical Dominance: The paper emphasizes that statistical uncertainties are expected to dominate over systematic uncertainties at 1 TeV, especially given the relatively clean environment.
  • Exclusion of $\tau$ Leptons: The analysis for the six-jet final state did not include the reconstruction of $\tau$ leptons from W boson decays, which could further improve precision.
  • Theoretical Uncertainties: While the paper focuses on statistical and detector-related systematic uncertainties, it acknowledges that theoretical uncertainties in cross-section calculations for backgrounds like $t\bar{t}Z$ and $t\bar{t}$ will also play a role.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that including $\tau$ lepton reconstruction and employing kinematic fitting could further enhance the precision of the $y_t$ measurement. Further studies on improving the modeling of background processes and their associated uncertainties are also implied.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present a study of the expected precision for the measurement of the top Yukawa coupling, $$y_{\mathrm {t}}$$ , in $$\mathrm{e}^{+}\mathrm{e}^{-} $$ collisions at a center-of-mass energy of 1 TeV. Independent analyses of $$\mathrm{t}\bar{\mathrm{t}}\mathrm{H}$$ final states containing at least six hadronic jets are performed, based on detailed simulations of SiD and ILD, the two candidate detector concepts for the ILC. We estimate that a statistical precision on $$y_{\mathrm {t}}$$ of 4.5 % can be obtained with an integrated luminosity of 1 $$\mathrm {ab}^{-1} $$ that is split equally between two configurations for the beam polarization $$P({{\mathrm{e}}}^{-},{{\mathrm{e}}}^{+})$$ , $$(-80~\%,+20~\%)$$ and $$(+80~\%,-20~\%)$$ . This estimate improves to $$4~\%$$ if the 1 $$\mathrm {ab}^{-1} $$ sample is assumed to be fully in the $$P({{\mathrm{e}}}^{-},{{\mathrm{e}}}^{+}) = (-80~\%,+20~\%)$$ configuration.
BibTeX
@article{price2015full,
  author = {T. Price and P. Roloff and J. Strube and T. Tanabe},
  title = {{Full simulation study of the top Yukawa coupling at the ILC at $$\textbackslash\{\}sqrt\{s\}=1$$ TeV}},
  journal = {The European Physical Journal C},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1140/epjc/s10052-015-3532-4},
}
Figure