Frontal Alpha Complexity of Different Severity Depression Patients

Lulu Zhao, Licai Yang, Baimin Li, Zhonghua Su, Chengyu LiuJournal of Healthcare Engineering 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the complexity of frontal alpha brain waves (EEG) in individuals with varying degrees of depression. They found that brain activity becomes more complex as depression severity increases, suggesting that measures of this complexity could serve as objective biomarkers for diagnosing and evaluating depression.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Depression is a major global health issue, yet its underlying biological mechanisms are not fully understood, and diagnosis often relies on subjective clinical assessments. The paper highlights the need for objective biomarkers to aid in the diagnosis and management of depression, particularly for computer-aided diagnostic systems. While Electroencephalogram (EEG) signals offer a promising avenue due to their direct reflection of brain activity and non-invasive nature, identifying specific EEG features that correlate with depression severity has been challenging. Previous research has yielded conflicting results regarding EEG complexity in depression, and few studies have explored how this complexity changes with the degree of depression.

Methods

The researchers employed two established nonlinear complexity measures: Sample Entropy (SEn) and Lempel-Ziv Complexity (LZC).

  • Sample Entropy (SEn): This method quantifies the regularity of a time series. A higher SEn value indicates less regularity and thus greater complexity. It's an improvement over approximate entropy as it accounts for self-matches.
  • Lempel-Ziv Complexity (LZC): This method measures the complexity of a sequence by counting the rate at which new patterns emerge. A higher LZC value suggests more novel patterns and greater complexity.

These measures were applied to the frontal alpha band (8-13 Hz) EEG signals recorded from three specific electrode locations (Fp1, Fz, Fp2) in participants. Statistical analyses, including Kruskal-Wallis rank tests and group t-tests, were used to compare complexity values across different groups and to explore correlations with depression severity scores.

Datasets

The study utilized data from:

  • 69 depression patients: Divided into three groups based on their Hamilton Depression Rating Scale (HDRS) scores: Non-Depressed (Non-De, 0-7), Mildly Depressed (Mil-De, 8-17), and Confirmed Depressed (Con-De, >17).
  • 14 healthy subjects: Used as a control group.

All participants were recruited from the Second Affiliated Hospital of Jining Medical College, Shandong, China. The data was collected under ethical approval and informed consent.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Increased Complexity with Depression: Both SEn and LZC consistently showed significantly higher complexity in depression patients compared to healthy controls. This suggests a fundamental alteration in frontal brain activity in depression.
  • Severity Matters: The complexity of frontal alpha EEG not only increases with depression but also appears to escalate as the depression deepens. This provides a potential quantitative measure for tracking disease progression.
  • SEn's Superiority in Mild Cases: Sample Entropy demonstrated a particular strength in distinguishing even individuals with a non-clinical depressive state (Non-De group) from healthy controls, suggesting its high sensitivity for early or milder forms of depression.
  • Conflicting Previous Findings Resolved: The study's consistent findings across both SEn and LZC, despite previous literature reporting contradictory results for SEn, lend strong support to their utility in depression research. This consistency is attributed to focusing on specific brain regions (frontal) and EEG bands (alpha).
  • Potential for Objective Diagnosis: The findings strongly suggest that SEn and LZC of frontal alpha EEG could serve as valuable, objective biomarkers for future computer-aided diagnosis and evaluation of depression.

Key Results

  • All six measured indices (SEn and LZC for Fp1, Fz, Fp2) showed significant differences between the healthy group and all three depression groups (p<0.01).
  • Complexity generally increased from healthy to Non-De, then to Mil-De, and further to Con-De groups, though some specific comparisons showed nuances (e.g., a slight decrease in SEn_Fp1 from Non-De to Mil-De).
  • SEn measures were particularly effective in distinguishing the Non-De group from healthy controls, showing significant increases in complexity.
  • LZC measures showed a more steady increase across the groups, and LZC exhibited better correlation with HDRS scores, particularly LZC_Fz.
  • Correlation analysis revealed weak but significant correlations between some complexity measures and HDRS scores, with SEn showing a negative trend and LZC a positive trend.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Medication and Gender: The authors acknowledge that medication status and gender were not controlled for and could influence the results. Future studies should consider these factors.
  • Limited EEG Coverage: The study focused solely on frontal alpha band EEG. Future research could explore other EEG bands and a wider range of brain regions for a more comprehensive understanding of depressive brain activity.
  • Pharmacological Effects: The observed decrease in complexity in the Con-De group compared to the Mil-De group might be influenced by pharmacological treatments, which could lead to a negative correlation between SEn and HDRS scores. This warrants further investigation.
  • Data Availability: The datasets are not publicly available due to patient privacy concerns, but requests can be directed to the corresponding authors.

Summary updated

Abstract

Depression is a leading cause of disability worldwide, and objective biomarkers are required for future computer-aided diagnosis. This study aims to assess the variation of frontal alpha complexity among different severity depression patients and healthy subjects, therefore to explore the depressed neuronal activity and to suggest valid biomarkers. 69 depression patients (divided into three groups according to the disease severity) and 14 healthy subjects were employed to collect 3-channel resting Electroencephalogram signals. Sample entropy and Lempel-Ziv complexity methods were employed to evaluate the Electroencephalogram complexity among different severity depression groups and healthy group. Kruskal-Wallis rank test and group <i>t</i>-test were performed to test the difference significance among four groups and between each two groups separately. All indexes values show that depression patients have significantly increased complexity compared to healthy subjects, and furthermore, the complexity keeps increasing as the depression deepens. Sample entropy measures exhibit superiority in distinguishing mild depression from healthy group with significant difference even between nondepressive state group and healthy group. The results confirm the altered neuronal activity influenced by depression severity and suggest sample entropy and Lempel-Ziv complexity as promising biomarkers in future depression evaluation and diagnosis.
BibTeX
@article{zhao2020frontal,
  author = {Lulu Zhao and Licai Yang and Baimin Li and Zhonghua Su and Chengyu Liu},
  title = {{Frontal Alpha Complexity of Different Severity Depression Patients}},
  journal = {Journal of Healthcare Engineering},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1155/2020/8854725},
}
Figure