Front Matter

H. V. Jagadish, Aoying ZhouPVLDB 2013

Abstract

This article summarizes the editorial shift introduced in Volume 7, Issue 1 of the Proceedings of the VLDB Endowment (PVLDB). Under the leadership of H. V. Jagadish and Aoying Zhou, VLDB 2014 implemented specialized tracks—including Innovative Systems, Experiments and Analysis, and Vision Mini-papers—to address the limitations of traditional peer-review models and capture a broader range of intellectual contributions in the data management field.

Introduction

The 40th International Conference on Very Large Data Bases (VLDB 2014) marked a significant turning point in how the database community evaluates and disseminates scientific contributions. The "Front Matter" of Volume 7, Issue 1 of the Proceedings of the VLDB Endowment (PVLDB) outlines a restructured publication model designed to capture a broader spectrum of intellectual value beyond narrow algorithmic increments.

VLDB Endowment Logo

The Limitations of Traditional Peer Review

Editors H. V. Jagadish and Aoying Zhou identified a systemic issue: the "standard research paper structure" had become too rigid. Traditional tracks often forced a narrow focus on specific components, requiring exhaustive comparisons that sidelined other forms of innovation. Specifically, three areas were identified as underserved:

  1. System-level Innovation: Large, complex systems often lack the space for granular, component-wise comparisons required by traditional tracks.
  2. Experimental Clarity: In crowded sub-fields, prioritizing new inventions over the necessary work of comparing existing ones can lead to a lack of clarity on "clear winners."
  3. Visionary Ideas: High-risk, high-reward concepts often struggle to pass review because they lack the implementation details required for a standard 12-page paper.

A Multi-Track Solution

To bridge these gaps, the VLDB 2014 organizers implemented four distinct new paper tracks:

  • Innovative Systems Track: Reserved for papers describing substantial innovation in system architecture where the value lies in the "whole" rather than a single isolated part.
  • Experiments and Analysis (E&A) Track: Dedicated to papers that advance the field by comparing existing techniques, validating the importance of reproducibility and benchmarking.
  • E&A Mini-papers: A 4-page format for focused experimental results that shed new light on previously published studies.
  • Vision Mini-papers: A 4-page format designed to "paint a compelling picture of the future," prioritizing visionary concepts over immediate implementation details.

Key Insights: Architectural Holism and Reproducibility

The editors emphasized that "no new invention" is required for a paper to be a "great contribution." This validation of reproducibility and benchmarking is a cornerstone of the E&A track. Furthermore, the Innovative Systems track acknowledges that the "sum is greater than the parts," allowing researchers to present complex architectures without being penalized for a lack of narrow focus. This shift encourages the community to value pathways to the future before the entire road has been built.

Initial Results and Community Impact

This volume serves as the first installment of the 2014 proceedings, featuring eight research papers that cover a diverse array of modern database challenges. These include graph processing on billion-node scales, performance isolation in cloud databases, and hardware-aware query optimization, such as the revisited analysis of Sort vs. Hash joins in multi-core, main-memory environments.

Partial list of the VLDB 2014 Program Committee

The success of these initiatives relies on the community's engagement and the reviewers' ability to judge submissions by these new criteria. By diversifying the avenues for contribution, VLDB 2014 aims to foster a more inclusive and robust research ecosystem.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{jagadish2013front,
  author = {H. V. Jagadish and Aoying Zhou},
  title = {{Front Matter}},
  journal = {Proc. VLDB Endow.},
  year = {2013},
}
Figure