Abstract
This study investigates the social stratification of physical activity (PA) participation among Chinese residents using data from the 2023 China General Social Survey (CGSS). By applying the lenses of spatial and temporal justice, the research reveals that exercise frequency is not merely a personal choice but a product of structural forces. Key findings include a significant "urban gradient" in fitness, the universal barrier of "time poverty" caused by overwork, and a counterintuitive "gym paradox" where commercial fitness usage correlates with lower overall activity levels. The study suggests that cultural capital (education) is a more potent predictor of health behavior than economic income.
Introduction
In the wake of the "Healthy China 2030" initiative, physical activity has become a primary metric for public health. However, participation remains highly unequal across different social strata. This paper addresses the "social stratification" of fitness by examining three critical dimensions:
- Spatial Justice: The impact of living in "health ecosystems" versus "sports deserts."
- Temporal Justice: How the "996" work culture (9 am to 9 pm, 6 days a week) acts as a universal "time tax" on health.
- Capital Theory: Whether economic capital (wealth) or cultural capital (education and internalized habits) more effectively facilitates a healthy lifestyle.
Methodology and Data
The researchers analyzed a nationally representative sample of 2,129 adults (aged 18–70) from the 2023 China General Social Survey (CGSS2023). The study employed an ordered logistic regression model, utilizing eight nested models to isolate the effects of geography, labor time, and various forms of capital.
A key methodological innovation was the "component-background" decomposition, which distinguished between the "compositional effect" (the characteristics of people who move to cities) and the "contextual effect" (the independent influence of the urban environment itself, such as parks and public services).
Key Results
1. The Urban Gradient and Spatial Justice
There is a clear spatial hierarchy in fitness. Residents in city centers are significantly more likely to engage in high-frequency exercise than rural residents. As shown in the regression analysis, the coefficients for "Town," "Urban fringe," and "Downtown" are all positive and highly significant compared to the rural reference group. Over half of this gap is attributed to the "contextual effect"—the actual presence of infrastructure and a local fitness culture.
2. Temporal Justice and the Overwork Penalty
Unlike spatial advantages, "time poverty" is a universal constraint. The data shows that every additional hour of work reduces the odds of exercise across all regions. A "996" worker (60 hours/week) faces an 11.3% lower probability of high-frequency exercise compared to a standard 40-hour worker. This creates a "willingness but inability" scenario where exhaustion necessitates passive rest over active movement.
3. Capital Theory and the "Gym Paradox"
One of the study's most striking findings is the negative correlation between gym usage and overall exercise frequency. Labeled the "Gym Paradox," the data (Model 6) shows a coefficient of -0.504 for gym availability/usage. This suggests that commercial fitness may act as a substitute for more frequent, lifestyle-integrated activities, or that unmotivated individuals may use gym memberships as a psychological crutch without increasing actual activity.
Furthermore, the study highlights that cultural capital (education) is a stronger predictor of health than income. When education is added to the model, the effect of income largely vanishes, suggesting that the internalized "habitus" of a health-oriented lifestyle is more important than the financial ability to buy equipment.
Discussion and Conclusion
The findings challenge the simplistic assumption that commercialized fitness is the primary driver of public health. Instead, the "Gym Paradox" suggests a need to reconsider localized, lifestyle-oriented forms of exercise. To achieve the goals of "Healthy China," policymakers must move beyond individual advocacy and address the structural "spatial deserts" and "time poverty" that make exercise a luxury for the few. Future research should utilize longitudinal data and objective measurements (like wearable devices) to further explore the causal mechanisms behind these inequalities.
Summary updated