From Puzzle to Progress: How engaging with Neurodiversity can improve Cognitive Science

Marie Adrienne Robles Manalili, Amy Pearson, Justin Sulik, Louise Creechan, Mahmoud Medhat Elsherif, Inika Murkumbi, Flávio Azevedo, Kathryn Bonnen, Judy Kim, Konrad P. Körding, Julie Lee, Manifold Obscura, Steven K. Kapp, Jan Philipp Röer, Talia MorsteadPsyArXiv 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper argues that cognitive science is currently hindered by a "deficit model" that pathologizes neurodivergence (such as Autism, ADHD, and Dyslexia) as a dysfunction rather than a natural variation. By adopting the Neurodiversity Paradigm, the authors suggest the field can move toward more robust, representative theories of human cognition that value diverse mental strategies instead of chasing a mythical "average brain."

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cognitive science has a double standard. While it celebrates cultural variation and synesthesia as valuable forms of "cognitive diversity," it traditionally treats neurodivergence as a list of impairments to be "cured" or "fixed."

The authors identify three major issues with this status quo:

  1. Ethical: Framing neurodivergence as "abnormal" has roots in eugenics and leads to "epistemic injustice," where the lived experiences of neurodivergent people are ignored in the very research meant to describe them.
  2. Scientific: Many "deficit-based" findings (like the idea that autistic people simply lack a "Theory of Mind") fail to replicate. These models often ignore the Double Empathy Problem—the idea that communication breakdowns are a two-way street between different neurotypes, rather than a failure of one side.
  3. Theoretical: By assuming there is one "optimal" or "rational" way for a mind to work, researchers miss out on the heterogeneous strategies humans actually use to solve problems.

Methods

As a position paper and theoretical critique, this work does not introduce a new laboratory experiment or algorithm. Instead, it synthesizes perspectives from psychology, philosophy, and the social sciences to propose a shift in research framework.

The authors contrast two approaches to modeling diversity:

  • Separation (The "Weak" Strategy): Treating neurodivergence as a "random effect" or a simple predictor in a regression. This assumes everyone is trying to reach the same "average" outcome, and some just fall short.
  • Variety (The "Radical" Strategy): Modeling cognition as a distribution of different types of mechanisms. This approach views neurotypicality as "common" rather than "normative" and looks for the unique ways different neurotypes might approach the same task (e.g., using linguistic vs. spatial processing to solve a puzzle).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. This is a theoretical perspective piece that cites existing literature rather than introducing a new empirical dataset.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Average Brain" is a Myth: Much of cognitive science relies on "normative" assumptions—that there is one "right" way to learn or make inferences. The authors argue that evolutionary pressure acts on the group, meaning a variety of cognitive strategies (neurodiversity) is actually a feature of a healthy, intelligent collective.
  • Epistemic Injustice: When researchers study a marginalized group without including them in the process, they provide a "false sense of objectivity." Including neurodivergent researchers allows the field to see what those in positions of privilege cannot.
  • From Outcomes to Mechanisms: Instead of just measuring if someone passes a test (outcome), researchers should look at how they solve it (mechanism). For example, different neurotypes might use entirely different neural pathways to achieve the same social or cognitive goal.
  • The Double Empathy Problem: The paper highlights that neurodivergent people often understand each other perfectly well; the "deficit" only appears when they are forced to interact with neurotypicals. This suggests social "impairments" are often context-dependent mismatches rather than inherent flaws.

Key Results

The paper serves as a roadmap for institutional change rather than a report of quantitative data. Its "results" are a set of high-level recommendations for the field:

  • Institutional Change: Explicitly include neurodiversity in diversity statements and reject models that frame neurodivergence as inherently disordered.
  • Research Design: Critically test the assumption that a difference is a "deficit." For instance, researchers should evaluate whether "standard" tasks are actually fair measures for heterogeneous cognitive processes.
  • Community Involvement: Move toward community-driven research that prioritizes the dimensions of life that neurodivergent people actually find important.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that current research is often limited by sampling bias; because many neurodivergent people lack formal diagnoses (especially women and people of color), samples assumed to be "neurotypical" likely contain undiagnosed neurodivergent individuals.

Future Work should focus on:

  • Intersectionality: Moving away from "Whiteness-centered" stereotypes of neurodivergence.
  • New Modeling Approaches: Replacing single-agent reinforcement learning models with population-level models that account for agents pursuing heterogeneous strategies.
  • Open Science: Leveraging open scholarship to improve the inclusion of neurodivergent researchers who may face traditional institutional barriers.

Summary updated

Abstract

In cognitive science, there is a tacit norm that phenomena such as cultural variation or synaesthesia are worthy examples of cognitive diversity that contribute to a better understanding of cognition, but that other forms of cognitive diversity (e.g. autism, ADHD and dyslexia) are primarily interesting only as examples of deficit, dysfunction, or impairment. This status quo is dehumanizing and holds back much-needed research. In contrast, the Neurodiversity Paradigm argues that such experiences are not necessarily deficits, but rather are natural reflections of biodiversity. Here we propose that neurodiversity is an important topic for future research in cognitive science. We discuss why cognitive science has thus far failed to engage with neurodiversity, why this gap presents both ethical and scientific challenges for the field and, crucially, why cognitive science will produce better theories of human cognition if the field engages with neurodiversity in the same way that it values other forms of cognitive diversity. Doing so will not only empower marginalized researchers but will also present an opportunity for cognitive science to benefit from the unique contributions of neurodivergent researchers and communities.
BibTeX
@misc{manalili2022from,
  author = {Marie Adrienne Robles Manalili and Amy Pearson and Justin Sulik and Louise Creechan and Mahmoud Medhat Elsherif and Inika Murkumbi and Flávio Azevedo and Kathryn Bonnen and Judy Kim and Konrad P. Körding and Julie Lee and Manifold Obscura and Steven K. Kapp and Jan Philipp Röer and Talia Morstead},
  title = {{From Puzzle to Progress: How engaging with Neurodiversity can improve Cognitive Science}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.31234/osf.io/gns3b},
  howpublished = {PsyArXiv},
}
Figure