From informative to co-design: the role of immersive Virtual Reality for user-involvement in healthcare facility design

Shahin Sateei, Mattias Roupé, Mikael JohanssonJournal of Information Technology in Construction 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

Immersive Virtual Reality (VR) is evolving from a simple visualization tool into a powerful engine for collaborative "co-design." By integrating multi-user capabilities and real-time object interaction, researchers found that hospital design revision cycles can be slashed from weeks to mere hours while empowering healthcare staff to act as true partners in the architectural process.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Designing a hospital is a high-stakes puzzle. Architects must balance complex technical requirements with the practical, high-pressure workflows of medical staff. Traditionally, this collaboration relies on 2D drawings or 3D models viewed on flat screens—media that are often too abstract for non-designers to fully grasp. This leads to "user involvement" that is often superficial; medical staff might feel like "alibis" in a process they don't fully understand until the building is already finished and the flaws become permanent.

While we know VR helps with spatial understanding, this paper investigates a deeper question: How do specific interactive features—like the ability to move furniture or see other people in the virtual space—change the nature of collaboration?

Methods

The researchers conducted a qualitative study across six real-life hospital design projects (labeled Cases A through F) in Sweden. These projects ranged from Intensive Care Units (ICUs) to psychiatric wards and radiology rooms.

The team used a mix of off-the-shelf VR software (Enscape, BIMXplorer) and custom-built Unity environments (ViCoDE). They collected data through:

  • Semi-structured interviews with 32 participants (doctors, nurses, architects, and project managers).
  • Video recordings of VR workshops to analyze how people moved, talked, and interacted within the virtual space.
  • Thematic analysis to map these experiences against established frameworks of user involvement.

Datasets

As a qualitative field study, the "dataset" consists of the six real-world architectural projects and the resulting 32 interviews and several hours of transcribed video data. The projects included:

  • Case A: ICU unit (Technical design phase).
  • Case B: Psychiatric ward (Concept & Technical design).
  • Case C: Various facilities (Multiple phases).
  • Case D: ICU and hyperbaric chamber (Late technical design).
  • Case E: Robot-assisted surgical room (Early preparation/briefing).
  • Case F: Radiology room (Technical design).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Interactivity Ladder: The paper proposes that user involvement is a cumulative "ladder" powered by VR features. Exploration (walking around) allows for "Consultative" involvement. Adding Multi-user capabilities allows for "Participatory Design." Finally, adding Object Interaction (moving walls or equipment) enables true "Co-design."
  • Democratizing Design: VR reduces the "interpretative prerogative" of the architect. When a nurse can see a sightline is blocked at 1:1 scale, they don't need to wait for an architect to tell them if a room works; they can prove it themselves.
  • Task-Driven Evaluation: The most successful sessions weren't just "tours." They were "scenarios." Staff would simulate a surgery or a patient transfer, identifying "hidden" issues like poorly placed lift equipment or window heights that were previously overlooked in 2D plans.
  • From Weeks to Hours: In cases with high interactivity (E and F), design changes that normally took 2-3 weeks of "back-and-forth" were resolved in a single afternoon because the architect and the end-user could negotiate and modify the layout in real-time.

Key Results

  • Co-Design Achievement: Only the cases that utilized both multi-user and object interaction (Cases E and F) reached the highest level of involvement, where users acted as "members of the design team."
  • Spatial "Aha" Moments: In Case A, users discovered unrecognized issues with window elevations and lift placement that had passed through multiple 2D reviews unnoticed.
  • Engagement Boost: Participants reported that VR was significantly more engaging and inclusive than traditional methods, leading to higher attendance and more vocal feedback from healthcare staff.
  • New Framework: The authors introduced a Classification Framework (Figure 9) that maps VR features to levels of user involvement, providing a roadmap for practitioners to choose the right VR setup for their specific project goals.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that as a qualitative study of six cases, the results may not be universally generalizable. Furthermore, while the study shows that VR helps identify and resolve design issues, there were no longitudinal follow-ups to confirm if these changes were successfully implemented in the final, physical buildings (except for Case A).

Future Work: The researchers suggest moving toward quantitative metrics—such as tracking the frequency of object interactions or measuring the "cognitive load" of users during VR reviews—to further refine how we use these immersive tools in the built environment.

Summary updated

Abstract

The design of a new hospital is often recognized as a complex process involving diverse stakeholders, where the outcome directly impacts healthcare operations. To improve these outcomes, collaborative practices such as participatory design and co-design are frequently used to gather end-users’ wants, needs, and operational knowledge. Recently, immersive Head-Mounted-Display (HMD) Virtual Reality (VR) has emerged as a tool that can enhance these processes by offering a better understanding of spatial scale and design details compared to traditional visual representations. However, while previous studies have focused on how immersive HMD VR improves spatial comprehension during design reviews, less attention has been paid to how specific interactive features—such as object interaction and multi-user capabilities—can facilitate collaboration and accelerate problem-solving. This paper aimed to gain an understanding of how these interactive features in immersive HMD VR can support various collaborative practices in hospital design projects. We present findings from six real-life hospital projects, spanning multiple design phases and utilizing different immersive HMD VR systems, to explore how interactive features affect user understanding, involvement, and engagement. Our results reveal that in the two cases where both object interaction and multi-user capabilities were available, participants could in real-time iteratively adjust layouts, including structural elements and loose furnishings, to test scenarios simulating real-world workflows. This enabled them to explore multiple spatial configurations and evaluate their impact on functionality. Multi-user collaboration facilitated simultaneous design reviews, promoting task-driven design evaluations and reducing revision lead time from weeks to hours. In cases where only free exploration of the virtual environment was available, participants primarily used immersive HMD VR to identify previously unrecognized design issues, evaluate sightlines, test logistical flow, and gain a clearer understanding of room scale. These insights highlight how varying levels of interactivity in the virtual environment impact user engagement, spatial understanding, and collaborative design processes. Additionally, we propose a classification framework for end-user involvement in VR-supported design reviews.
BibTeX
@article{sateei2025from,
  author = {Shahin Sateei and Mattias Roupé and Mikael Johansson},
  title = {{From informative to co-design: the role of immersive Virtual Reality for user-involvement in healthcare facility design}},
  journal = {Journal of Information Technology in Construction},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.36680/j.itcon.2025.032},
}
Figure