From Dialogue to Monologue: A Dialogic Syntax Approach to the Construal Mechanism of “爱(ai) V不(bu) V” in Chinese

Liying Sun, Mengjie ZhangInternational Journal of Language and Linguistics 2025 · DOI

Abstract

The “爱(ai)V不(bu)V” construction in Chinese is a parallel construction composed of “爱(ai)V” and “不(bu)V”. Based on an investigation of the CCL corpus, the parallelism and resonance between these components are analyzed within the framework of Dialogic Syntax. This paper constructs and verifies a construal mechanism for the “爱(ai)V不(bu)V” construction through case studies. Form resonance between complex sentences triggers semantic resonance, constructing two corresponding events through conceptual expansion: the choosing-to-V event and the choosing-not-to-V event. Strong contrasts between these events activate event resonance, providing options for the choice. Through event integration and cognitive prominence, the speaker expresses an inclination, conveying communicative intentions. This study expands Dialogic Syntax to monologue and offers insights into interpreting parallel structures in linguistic study and natural language processing.

Introduction: The Pragmatic Paradox of “爱 V 不 V”

In Chinese, the construction “爱(ai) V 不(bu) V” (e.g., ai chi bu chi — 'eat if you want, don't if you don't') presents a significant linguistic puzzle. Superficially, the phrase follows a biclausal conditional logic: 'If you want to V, then V; if not, don't.' This structure appears to grant the listener total freedom of choice.

However, in actual usage, the construction is rarely neutral. Phrases like '爱吃不吃' are typically used to express speaker annoyance or discontent, often when the listener is perceived as being difficult or indecisive. This creates a 'pragmatic paradox': a symmetrical, neutral-looking structure that consistently yields an asymmetrical, emotionally charged interpretation. While previous studies have described this phenomenon, they have lacked a formal explanation of the construal mechanism—the cognitive process that transforms neutral optionality into pragmatic coercion.

The Construal Mechanism

This research proposes a new Construal Mechanism (CM) by integrating Dialogic Syntax—a framework traditionally used for multi-party dialogue—with cognitive linguistics. The core innovation is treating a single four-character phrase as an internal 'dialogue' between its parallel components.

The Construal Mechanism of '爱V不V' based on Dialogic Syntax.

The CM operates through a five-step pipeline:

  1. Intentionality: The process begins with the speaker’s underlying goal or 'directedness' of consciousness.
  2. Logical Reasoning: The brain deconstructs the condensed phrase into two antithetical 'If... then...' complex sentences.
  3. Conceptual Expansion: These logical structures expand into mental representations of two competing events: the 'choosing-to-V' event versus the 'choosing-not-to-V' event.
  4. Parallel Resonance: The formal and semantic contrast between these events creates 'resonance,' highlighting the conflict between the two options.
  5. Cognitive Prominence: Finally, the speaker uses 'foregrounding' to highlight one option over the other, signaling their true inclination and emotional state (typically discontent).

Empirical Analysis and Results

To verify this mechanism, the study utilized the CCL Corpus (Center for Chinese Linguistics at Peking University), analyzing 196 valid samples of the construction from modern Chinese records spanning the 1910s to the 2020s.

The corpus analysis provided strong quantitative evidence for the proposed theory, categorizing the usage of 'choice' within the construction based on speaker intent.

Classification of Choice in the '爱V不V' Construction.

The results demonstrate that the 'choice' offered is largely a facade:

  • Inclined Choice (85.2%): In the vast majority of cases, the speaker is not neutral. Within this group, 79.6% specifically expressed 'To V with discontent,' confirming that the construction's primary function in modern Chinese is to convey annoyance.
  • Disinclined Choice (14.8%): Only a small fraction of cases represented a truly neutral stance where the speaker genuinely left the decision to the listener.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The study confirms that the “爱 V 不 V” construction has undergone 'subjectification,' moving from a neutral description of reality to a tool for expressing internal emotional states. By applying Dialogic Syntax to monologue, the authors reveal how internal resonance allows speakers to encode complex subtext within simple parallel structures.

Future work will focus on applying this 'Dialogic Syntax in Monologue' approach to other symmetrical Chinese structures. Additionally, these findings have implications for Natural Language Processing (NLP), as formalizing how 'choice' structures encode 'discontent' can significantly improve sentiment analysis and the detection of pragmatic nuances like sarcasm in AI systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

The “爱(ai)V不(bu)V” construction in Chinese is a parallel construction composed of “爱(ai)V” and “不(bu)V”. Based on the investigation of the corpus CCL, the parallelism and resonance between “爱(ai)V” and “不(bu)V”are analyzed in the framework of Dialogic Syntax in this paper and a construal mechanism for “爱(ai)V不(bu)V” construction is constructed and verified through case studies. The resonating “爱(ai)V” and “不(bu)V” are respectively reduced to two complex sentences with parallel forms and opposite meanings: “如果爱V就V;如果不爱V,就不V ruguo aiV, jiuV; ruguo bu aiV, jiu buV”(if you want to V, then V; if you don’t want to V, don’t V). Form resonance between complex sentences triggers semantic resonance, that is, the opposition between two hypothetical relations. This oppositional relation constructs two corresponding events through conceptual expansion, namely, choosing-to-V event and choosing-not-to-V event. Strong contrasts and conflicts between these events activate event resonance which provides two options for the choice of “爱(ai)V不(bu)V” construction. In the process of event integration, the speaker expresses an inclination for this choice through cognitive prominence, thereby conveying their communicative intentions. This study not only expands of application of Dialogic Syntax to monologue, but also represents a valuable attempt to dynamically analyze static language, offering insights into the interpretation of other parallel structures in linguistic study and natural language processing.
BibTeX
@article{sun2025from,
  author = {Liying Sun and Mengjie Zhang},
  title = {{From Dialogue to Monologue: A Dialogic Syntax Approach to the Construal Mechanism of “爱(ai) V不(bu) V” in Chinese}},
  journal = {International Journal of Language and Linguistics},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.11648/j.ijll.20251302.14},
}
Figure