Frictional drag between superconducting LaAlO 3 /SrTiO 3 nanowires

Yuhe Tang, Jungwoo Lee, Anthony Tylan‐Tyler, Hyung-Woo Lee, Michelle Tomczyk, Mengchen Huang, Chang‐Beom Eom, Patrick Irvin, Jeremy LevySemiconductor 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have measured "frictional drag" between two superconducting LaAlO₃/SrTiO₃ nanowires, observing a unique signal that reveals insights into the 1D nature of superconductivity in these materials. This work demonstrates how interactions between superconducting nanowires can be used to probe fundamental electronic properties, particularly electron-hole asymmetry.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the exotic electronic properties of oxide heterostructures like LaAlO₃/SrTiO₃ (LAO/STO) is a major challenge. While superconductivity is known to exist at the interface, its behavior in confined geometries, such as nanowires, is less understood. Specifically, the authors aim to investigate the nature of electron interactions and correlations within these superconducting nanowires. They use the technique of "frictional drag," where current in one conductor induces a voltage in a nearby, electrically isolated conductor, to probe these interactions. Previous studies have explored frictional drag in various systems, but its application to two superconducting nanowires, especially in the context of LAO/STO, is novel. The key question is how the superconducting state and the unique 1D nature of superconductivity in LAO/STO nanowires influence this drag phenomenon.

Methods

The core experimental technique is frictional drag. Two LAO/STO nanowires, fabricated using conductive-AFM lithography, are placed in close proximity (separated by tens to hundreds of nanometers). A current is driven through one nanowire (the "drive" nanowire), and the induced voltage in the other (the "drag" nanowire) is measured. This induced voltage, normalized by the drive current, gives the drag resistance.

The researchers analyzed the drag resistance by decomposing it into symmetric and anti-symmetric components. This decomposition helps disentangle different physical mechanisms contributing to the drag signal. They also performed measurements under varying temperatures and magnetic fields to probe the superconducting transitions and the influence of magnetic fields. Crucially, they compared measurements where both nanowires were superconducting with scenarios where one nanowire was in a normal (non-superconducting) state.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments utilize custom-fabricated LAO/STO nanowire devices.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dual Nature of Drag: The frictional drag signal in superconducting LAO/STO nanowires is not a single phenomenon but a combination of symmetric and anti-symmetric components, each arising from distinct physical processes.
  • Symmetric Drag from Thermal Noise: The symmetric component of the drag resistance is strongly linked to the superconducting-normal transition in the drive nanowire. It's attributed to the rectification of thermal noise generated during this transition.
  • Anti-symmetric Drag from Shot Noise: The anti-symmetric component is present even in normal-state nanowires and is explained by the rectification of quantum shot noise in the drive nanowire, amplified by broken symmetry in the drag nanowire.
  • 1D Superconductivity and Electron-Hole Asymmetry: The most striking finding is the suppression of the symmetric drag component when the drag nanowire is in a normal state. This suggests a significant electron-hole asymmetry within the superconducting LAO/STO nanowire itself, which is proposed to stem from the 1D nature of superconductivity at the LAO/STO interface.
  • Probing Electron-Hole Asymmetry: Frictional drag proves to be a sensitive probe of electron-hole asymmetry, a fundamental property that is difficult to measure directly in such nanoscale systems.

Key Results

  • Frictional drag measurements between two superconducting LAO/STO nanowires reveal both symmetric and anti-symmetric drag resistance components.
  • The symmetric drag resistance component is observed to be large and closely correlated with the superconducting-normal transition in the drive nanowire.
  • When one nanowire is in the normal state, the symmetric drag component is significantly suppressed. This suppression is particularly pronounced when the drag nanowire is normal, indicating a strong electron-hole asymmetry in the superconducting nanowire.
  • The observed drag resistance shows little dependence on the separation between nanowires, suggesting non-Coulombic interactions are dominant.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the exact nature of the coupling mechanism responsible for both the symmetric and anti-symmetric drag components, especially at larger separations, remains unknown. They also note that while they can select devices where one nanowire is superconducting and the other is normal, they cannot independently control the carrier density of individual nanowires.

Future work could focus on:

  • Investigating the precise microscopic origin of the coupling mechanisms.
  • Exploring the influence of device geometry (width, length, separation) on the drag signal in more detail.
  • Attempting to tune the superconducting state of individual nanowires to further elucidate the role of electron-hole asymmetry.
  • Extending these measurements to other superconducting materials or heterostructures to see if similar phenomena are observed.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract We report frictional drag measurements between two superconducting LaAlO 3 /SrTiO 3 nanowires. In these experiments, current passing through one nanowire induces a voltage across a nearby electrically isolated nanowire. The frictional drag signal contains both symmetric and anti-symmetric components. The anti-symmetric component arises from the rectification of quantum shot noise in the drive nanowire by the broken symmetry in the drag nanowire. The symmetric component in the drag resistance is ascribed to rectification of thermal noise in the drive nanowire during superconducting-normal transition. The suppression of the symmetric component is observed when a normal nanowire is used as either a drag or drive nanowire with the other nanowire superconducting. The absence of symmetric drag resistance between a normal drag nanowire and a superconducting drive nanowire suggests a higher electron-hole asymmetry in the superconducting LaAlO 3 /SrTiO 3 nanowire arising from the 1D nature of superconductivity at LaAlO 3 /SrTiO 3 interface.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tang2020frictional,
  author = {Yuhe Tang and Jungwoo Lee and Anthony Tylan‐Tyler and Hyung-Woo Lee and Michelle Tomczyk and Mengchen Huang and Chang‐Beom Eom and Patrick Irvin and Jeremy Levy},
  title = {{Frictional drag between superconducting LaAlO <sub>3</sub> /SrTiO <sub>3</sub> nanowires}},
  booktitle = {Semiconductor},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1088/1361-6641/ab9ec9},
}
Figure