Abstract
Atomic clocks occupy a unique position in measurement science, exhibiting higher accuracy than any other measurement standard and underpinning six out of seven base units in the SI system. By exploiting higher resonance frequencies, optical atomic clocks now achieve greater stability and lower frequency uncertainty than existing primary standards. Here, we report frequency ratios of the $^{27}$Al$^+$, $^{171}$Yb and $^{87}$Sr optical clocks in Boulder, Colorado, measured across an optical network spanned by both fiber and free-space links. These ratios have been evaluated with measurement uncertainties between $6\times10^{-18}$ and $8\times10^{-18}$, making them the most accurate reported measurements of frequency ratios to date. This represents a critical step towards redefinition of the SI second and future applications such as relativistic geodesy and tests of fundamental physics.
Introduction
For decades, the international definition of the "second" has relied on the microwave resonance of Cesium-133. However, metrology has reached the "Cesium floor," where microwave standards are limited to approximately 16 digits of accuracy ($10^{-16}$). Optical atomic clocks, which operate at frequencies 100,000 times higher than microwave standards, offer the potential to improve this precision by two orders of magnitude.
To realize a new definition of the SI second, researchers must demonstrate the ability to compare different clock species across distances without losing precision. Because the absolute frequency of an optical clock cannot be measured in Hertz more accurately than the current Cesium standard allows, the frontier of metrology lies in measuring the ratio between two optical clocks—a unitless constant of nature. This paper details the achievements of the Boulder Atomic Clock Optical Network (BACON) in reaching 18-digit precision across a regional network.
The BACON Network Architecture
The BACON collaboration integrated three distinct optical clock architectures located in Boulder, Colorado:
- $^{27}$Al$^+$ (Aluminum Ion): A single-ion clock noted for its extremely low sensitivity to environmental temperature shifts.
- $^{171}$Yb (Ytterbium Lattice): A lattice clock utilizing thousands of atoms trapped in an optical lattice to achieve high stability.
- $^{87}$Sr (Strontium Lattice): A second lattice clock located at JILA, approximately 1.5 km away from the NIST laboratory housing the other two clocks.
To connect these systems, the team developed a hybrid network. This included a 3.6 km underground fiber link and a 1.5 km free-space link. The free-space link utilized Optical Two-Way Time-Frequency Transfer (O-TWTFT), a sophisticated technique that cancels out atmospheric turbulence by transmitting pulses in both directions simultaneously. Five optical frequency combs served as the "gears" of the system, coherently linking the various optical frequencies across the network.
Overcoming Geodetic and Statistical Barriers
At the $10^{-18}$ level of precision, General Relativity introduces significant practical challenges. A height difference of just one centimeter results in a gravitational redshift (a change in the clock's ticking rate) of $1 \times 10^{-18}$. Given the 18.6-meter elevation difference between the NIST and JILA labs, the researchers performed an extensive geodetic survey to map the local geopotential. This allowed them to correct for gravitational effects with the necessary precision.
Furthermore, the team addressed the "Link Limit" using a rigorous Bayesian statistical framework. Traditional tools like Allan deviation often fail to capture "between-day" variability—unexplained systematic shifts that may appear constant during a single session but fluctuate over time. The Bayesian model provided a more conservative and accurate uncertainty estimate by accounting for this excess scatter, ensuring the 18-digit precision was statistically sound.
Key Results
The BACON collaboration successfully measured three fundamental frequency ratios with unprecedented accuracy:
- $f_{Al^+} / f_{Yb}$ = 2.162 887 127 516 663 703 (13)
- $f_{Al^+} / f_{Sr}$ = 2.611 701 431 781 463 025 (21)
- $f_{Yb} / f_{Sr}$ = 1.207 507 039 343 337 848 2 (82)
The total fractional uncertainties for these measurements ranged from $5.9 \times 10^{-18}$ to $8.0 \times 10^{-18}$. To illustrate this level of precision: if these clocks had been synchronized at the time of the Big Bang (13.8 billion years ago), they would differ by only one second today.
Discussion and Future Outlook
This work proves that regional optical networks can maintain 18-digit precision across both fiber and free-space links. The success of the O-TWTFT free-space link is particularly significant, as it suggests that future clock networks could be linked via satellites, bypassing the need for physical fiber infrastructure between continents.
However, challenges remain. While the Bayesian model accounted for daily variations, the physical source of the "between-day" noise in the Ytterbium/Strontium ratio remains an area for further investigation. Additionally, as clock precision continues to improve, the uncertainty in Earth's gravity field will eventually become the primary bottleneck. This transition will mark the beginning of "relativistic geodesy," where optical clocks are used as sensors to map the Earth's interior and gravitational structure with higher resolution than ever before possible.
Summary updated