Free-Space Optical Communication Using Non-Mode-Selective Photonic Lantern-Based Coherent Receiver

Bo Zhang, Renzhi Yuan, Jianfeng Sun, Julian Cheng, Mohamed-Slim AlouiniIEEE Trans. Communications 2020 · DOI · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper investigates a novel coherent receiver for free-space optical communication that uses a photonic lantern (PL) to split the incoming signal into multiple single-mode fibers. The authors analyze how the distribution of optical power across these fibers affects system performance, finding that it has minimal impact with maximal-ratio combining but significantly influences performance with selection combining. Their results show that this PL-based receiver offers substantial SNR gains over traditional single-mode and multimode fiber receivers, especially under turbulent atmospheric conditions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Free-space optical (FSO) communication offers high bandwidth but is susceptible to atmospheric turbulence, which degrades signal quality. Coherent receivers are attractive for their high sensitivity, but traditional fiber-based coherent receivers (using either single-mode fibers (SMF) or multimode fibers (MMF)) face trade-offs: SMF offers excellent signal mixing but poor coupling efficiency, while MMF has high coupling efficiency but poor mixing. Photonic lanterns (PLs) offer a potential solution by splitting a larger MMF input into multiple SMF outputs, aiming to combine the benefits of both. However, the distribution of optical power across these SMF outputs from a non-mode-selective PL is not well understood and can vary due to factors like atmospheric turbulence. This variation could impact the performance of different signal combining techniques within the receiver. This paper addresses this gap by modeling and analyzing the impact of this power distribution on the SNR and bit-error rate (BER) of a PL-based coherent receiver using various combining strategies.

Methods

The authors propose a truncated Gaussian distribution over a simplex to model the power distribution at the SMF ends of the non-mode-selective PL. This model is derived from simulations of photon distribution. They then analyze the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and bit-error rate (BER) performance of the PL-based receiver using three common combining techniques:

  • Selection Combining (SC): Selects the branch with the highest instantaneous SNR.
  • Equal-Gain Combining (EGC): Adds the signals from all branches after equalizing their amplitudes.
  • Maximal-Ratio Combining (MRC): Adds the signals from all branches, weighted by their respective SNRs.

The analysis is performed over Gamma-Gamma atmospheric turbulence channels, a standard model for FSO links. They derive integral, series lower bound, and asymptotic solutions for the BER. The performance of the PL-based receiver is then compared against traditional SMF and MMF receivers. They also investigate the impact of imperfect device parameters on SNR gains.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on simulations and theoretical analysis rather than experimental datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Power Distribution Matters (Sometimes): The distribution of optical power across the SMF outputs of the PL significantly impacts the receiver's performance, but this impact is highly dependent on the combining technique used.
  • MRC is Robust: Maximal-Ratio Combining (MRC) is completely insensitive to the power distribution within the PL. This makes it a very robust choice, though it is more complex to implement.
  • EGC is a Good Compromise: Equal-Gain Combining (EGC) shows only a limited influence from the PL power distribution, making it a practical and effective strategy.
  • SC is Sensitive: Selection Combining (SC) is highly susceptible to the power distribution. A non-uniform distribution can drastically degrade performance, while a more uniform distribution can improve it.
  • PL Offers Significant Gains: The PL-based receiver with EGC provides substantial SNR gains over traditional SMF and MMF receivers, particularly under moderate to strong turbulence.

Key Results

  • SNR Gains: Under moderate turbulence at a BER of 10⁻⁶, the PL-based receiver with EGC requires approximately 6 dB less SNR than an SMF receiver and 5.5 dB less SNR than an MMF receiver. These gains are even more pronounced under strong turbulence.
  • Power Distribution Impact:
    • For MRC, the power distribution has no effect on SNR or BER.
  • For EGC, the power distribution has a limited influence on BER. The ratio of BERs between extreme power distributions (uniform vs. degenerate) is around 1.3.
  • For SC, the power distribution can greatly affect BER. The ratio of BERs between extreme distributions can be as high as 4.8.
  • Optimal Combining: EGC is identified as the most suitable combining technique for the PL-based receiver due to its good performance and relative insensitivity to power distribution variations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Complexity: The PL-based receiver, especially with N SMF outputs, requires N balanced photodetectors, increasing cost and complexity compared to SMF receivers.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring hybrid combining techniques (e.g., hybrid-selection/equal-gain combining) to reduce the number of photodetectors and lower receiver complexity while maintaining performance.

Summary updated

Abstract

A free-space optical communication system using non-mode-selective photonic lantern (PL) based coherent receiver is studied. Based on the simulation of photon distribution, the power distribution at the single-mode fiber end of the PL is quantitatively described as a truncated Gaussian distribution over a simplex. The signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs), bit-error rate (BER), and outage probability of PL based receiver using selection combining (SC), equal-gain combining (EGC), and maximal-ratio combining (MRC) over Gamma-Gamma turbulence channels are analyzed and compared with the single-mode fiber (SMF) receiver and multimode fiber (MMF) receiver. We demonstrate that EGC is the most suitable combining for PL based receiver because the PL power distribution has limited influence on the BER and outage probability when EGC is used and can greatly affect the BER and outage probability when SC is used. Numerical results show that PL based receiver with EGC requires 6 dB less SNR than the SMF receiver and 5.5 dB less SNR than the MMF receiver at BER of 10 <sup xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">−6</sup> in moderate turbulence.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2020free,
  author = {Bo Zhang and Renzhi Yuan and Jianfeng Sun and Julian Cheng and Mohamed-Slim Alouini},
  title = {{Free-Space Optical Communication Using Non-Mode-Selective Photonic Lantern-Based Coherent Receiver}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Communications},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.48550/arxiv.2007.01938},
}
Figure