Framework for WASH Sector Data Improvements in Data-Poor Environments, Applied to Accra, Ghana

Rembrandt Koppelaar, May N. Sule, Zoltán Kis, Foster Mensah, Xiaonan Wang, Charalampos Triantafyllidis, Koen H. van Dam, Nilay ShahWater 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel data integration framework and a bottom-up material flow model to address the critical lack of data in Water, Sanitation, and Hygiene (WASH) sectors in data-poor environments. Applied to Accra, Ghana, this approach provides a comprehensive quantitative mapping of the entire WASH flow-cycle, enabling better policy and infrastructure planning.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Improving WASH services in developing countries is severely hampered by a lack of reliable, granular data. Existing data is often aggregated, outdated, or spatially fragmented, making it difficult to understand the true state of water and sanitation systems. This "data poverty" prevents fact-based decision-making, hinders the development of tailored solutions, and makes it challenging to track progress towards targets. Specifically, the paper highlights the challenge of integrating diverse data sources to create a comprehensive baseline assessment of urban water flows, from raw water intake to wastewater discharge, and the need for a robust methodology to identify areas for improvement and test future scenarios.

Methods

The core of this research is a data integration framework combined with a bottom-up material flow analysis. This approach meticulously defines individual system components and their interactions, using first-principle engineering and mass-balance principles to build a holistic understanding. The framework breaks down the WASH system into nine distinct conversion steps and 34 material flow equations, covering the entire lifecycle from raw water abstraction to wastewater treatment and discharge. This detailed, step-by-step methodology allows for the quantification of inputs and outputs at various stages, enabling a granular view of the system. The authors also developed a set of standardized metrics to facilitate future research and scenario testing.

Datasets

The study utilized a comprehensive range of data sources, including:

  • Literature studies, reports, and news articles: A broad screening of several hundred sources was conducted to extract key datasets.
  • Local authorities and water company officers: Direct contact with officials from the Ghana Water Company Limited (GWCL) was made to update information on water treatment, pipeline systems, and rationing.
  • Ghana Statistical Service: Household infrastructure use data from the 2010 census was a primary source for district-level analysis.
  • Water Resources Commission: Data on licensed users for local water sourcing was obtained.
  • Liquid waste disposal census data: Used to establish proportions of wastewater discharged via different routes.
  • Previous studies and reports: Data on toilet types, sub-soil leakage rates, and sewage treatment plant operational status were incorporated.

The paper notes that the primary limitation was the availability of more recent household data than 2010.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The power of a bottom-up approach: By meticulously mapping each step of the WASH flow-cycle, the study reveals critical bottlenecks and inefficiencies that might be missed by top-down analyses.
  • The critical role of sachet and bottled water: Including these informal sources dramatically increases access to "improved safe water," highlighting the need to consider all water sources in policy.
  • Wastewater is largely unsafely managed: A significant portion of generated wastewater is not treated, with a large percentage ending up in open drains, posing substantial environmental and health risks.
  • Underutilized treatment capacity: Despite existing infrastructure, a very small fraction of wastewater treatment capacity is operational, indicating severe management and maintenance issues.
  • Data integration is key to informed planning: The framework demonstrates how disparate data sources can be harmonized to create a robust baseline for urban planning and scenario analysis.

Key Results

  • Improved water access: In 2010, 96% of the population in Greater Accra Metropolitan Area (GAMA) had access to improved safe water when sachet and bottled water were included; this figure dropped to 67% when excluded.
  • Wastewater disposal: 66% of the 338,000 m³ of wastewater generated daily was unsafely disposed of locally, with 23% entering open drains and 11% entering sewage pipes.
  • Wastewater treatment: In 2014, less than 0.5% of wastewater was treated, and only 18% of the available 43,000 m³ per day treatment capacity was operational.
  • Sanitation coverage: Poor sanitation coverage is indicated by the high percentage of wastewater unsafely disposed of.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Data availability: The study relied heavily on 2010 data, with a lack of more recent household-level data on non-drinking water sources, toilet types, and liquid waste discharge. This makes it difficult to precisely track progress at the household level.
  • Parameter accuracy: The accuracy of the results is dependent on the accuracy of input parameters, particularly those related to leakage in the pipe system, which were based on limited estimates.
  • Interpretation of indicators: Definitions of "improved sources" can vary, impacting the interpretation of access statistics.

Future work suggested includes:

  • More frequent sub-surveys: Conducting surveys aligned with medium-term development plans to address the planning deficit.
  • Further analysis of pipe leakage: Investigating physical losses and potential improvements to reduce non-revenue water.
  • Generating data for non-domestic sectors: Conducting company water use surveys and expanding water metering.
  • Analyzing public vs. private water rates: Investigating the significant differences in water charges.
  • Applying the framework to other cities: The methodology is designed to be transferable to other data-poor urban environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

Improvements in water, sanitation and hygiene (WASH) service provision are hampered by limited open data availability. This paper presents a data integration framework, collects the data and develops a material flow model, which aids data-based policy and infrastructure development for the WASH sector. This model provides a robust quantitative mapping of the complete anthropogenic WASH flow-cycle: from raw water intake to water use, wastewater and excreta generation, discharge and treatment. This approach integrates various available sources using a process-chain bottom-up engineering approach to improve the quality of WASH planning. The data integration framework and the modelling methodology are applied to the Greater Accra Metropolitan Area (GAMA), Ghana. The highest level of understanding of the GAMA WASH sector is achieved, promoting scenario testing for future WASH developments. The results show 96% of the population had access to improved safe water in 2010 if sachet and bottled water was included, but only 67% if excluded. Additionally, 66% of 338,000 m3 per day of generated wastewater is unsafely disposed locally, with 23% entering open drains, and 11% sewage pipes, indicating poor sanitation coverage. Total treated wastewater is <0.5% in 2014, with only 18% of 43,000 m3 per day treatment capacity operational. The combined data sets are made available to support research and sustainable development activities.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{koppelaar2018framework,
  author = {Rembrandt Koppelaar and May N. Sule and Zoltán Kis and Foster Mensah and Xiaonan Wang and Charalampos Triantafyllidis and Koen H. van Dam and Nilay Shah},
  title = {{Framework for WASH Sector Data Improvements in Data-Poor Environments, Applied to Accra, Ghana}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/w10091278},
}
Figure