Fractions strategy differences in those born extremely preterm

Sarah J. A. Carr, W. Michael Babinchak, Ana E Istrate, Blaine Martyn-Dow, George Wang, Weicong Chen, Jeremy Fondran, Jing Zhang, Michael Wien, Seo Yeon Yoon, Anne Birnbaum, Elizabeth Roth, Carol A. Gross, Nori Minich, Lee A. Thompson, Won Hwa Kim, Yaakov Stern, Chiara Nosarti, H. Gerry Taylor, Curtis TatsuokabioRxiv 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study used fMRI to investigate how extremely preterm (EPT) born adolescents and their full-term (FT) peers solve fraction subtraction problems using different strategies. The findings reveal distinct brain activation patterns between the groups, particularly for more challenging problems, suggesting that tailored math instruction could benefit EPT individuals by leveraging their cognitive strengths and accommodating their weaknesses.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Children born extremely preterm (EPT), defined as before 28 weeks of gestation, often experience cognitive challenges, including difficulties with mathematics. While it's known that EPT individuals may have altered brain structure and function, the specific neural mechanisms underlying their mathematical difficulties, especially when employing different problem-solving strategies, remain underexplored. This paper aims to bridge this gap by examining how EPT and full-term (FT) adolescents' brains respond to solving fraction subtraction problems using distinct strategies (mixed vs. improper fractions) and varying cognitive loads, with the ultimate goal of informing more effective mathematics education for this vulnerable population.

Methods

The researchers employed functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) to capture brain activity while participants mentally solved fraction subtraction problems. Participants were instructed to use either a "mixed fractions" strategy or an "improper fractions" strategy, with the choice of strategy and the type of fraction problem (varying in difficulty) prompted during the scan. Additionally, Diffusion Tensor Imaging (DTI) and T1-weighted structural MRI were used to assess brain structure and white matter connectivity. Statistical analyses included group-level fMRI analysis using a factorial design to compare activation patterns between EPT and FT groups across different strategies and item types, as well as Linear Support Vector Machine (SVM) classification to differentiate between strategies and difficulty levels based on brain activity.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 13 EPT adolescents (born <28 weeks gestation and/or with birth weight <1000g) and 15 full-term (FT) adolescents, all aged 15-17 years. Participants underwent neuropsychological testing and fMRI scanning. The fMRI data was collected during the performance of a specifically designed set of fraction subtraction problems.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Strategy-Dependent Brain Activation: Different strategies for solving fraction problems (mixed vs. improper) elicit distinct patterns of brain activation, highlighting the neural basis of cognitive flexibility in mathematics.
  • Cognitive Load Matters: The differences in brain activation between EPT and FT groups were most pronounced when participants tackled problems requiring higher cognitive load, suggesting that EPT individuals may struggle more with complex mathematical tasks.
  • Structural Differences Underpin Functional Differences: The observed differences in brain activation are likely linked to the previously documented structural differences in EPT individuals, including reduced grey and white matter volume and altered white matter connectivity.
  • Tailored Instruction is Key: The findings strongly support the idea that mathematics instruction for EPT youth should be individualized, considering their specific cognitive profiles and the demands of different problem-solving strategies and problem types.

Key Results

  • Hemodynamic Differences: EPT and FT groups showed significant differences in task-related hemodynamic responses during fraction subtraction. These differences were amplified for item types that resulted in high cognitive load.
  • Structural Deficits: The EPT group exhibited reduced white and grey matter volume and reduced white matter connectivity in widespread brain areas compared to the FT group.
  • Accuracy: While overall accuracy was high, suggesting effective training, EPT subjects showed lower correctness rates than FT subjects when using the mixed strategy to solve Item Type II (harder) problems.
  • SVM Classification: SVM classification was successful in differentiating strategy use and difficulty levels based on brain activity, with higher accuracy for the EPT group in distinguishing difficulty levels for the mixed fractions strategy, suggesting they may be "straining" more with these tasks.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge the small sample size and the potential for limited representativeness, as the EPT group was predominantly female. They suggest that future MRI studies with larger and more diverse samples are needed to confirm these findings and explore the heterogeneity in cognitive outcomes and neural activations within the EPT population. They also propose that further research could investigate how to best adapt problem-solving strategies to be biologically informed, potentially by strengthening underlying cognitive processes like working memory to compensate for identified weaknesses.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Introduction To investigate the effects of different strategies and cognitive load we explored brain hemodynamic responses associated with the use of different strategies to solve subtraction of fractions. We focused on those born extremely preterm (EPT; &lt;28 weeks’ gestation) as they are known to have cognitive challenges and struggle with mathematics. We also included a group of full-term (FT) peers for comparison. Methods Functional MRI was acquired while the participants mentally solved fraction equations using either a strategy based on improper or mixed fractions. Different fraction item types were given, which affected respective required cognitive loads per strategy. Diffusion and T1-weighted structural images were also acquired. Results The EPT and FT groups differed in terms of task-related hemodynamic responses. Functional group differences were greatest when strategies were applied to item types that result in high cognitive load. Other findings showed reduced white and grey matter volume and reduced white matter connectivity in widespread areas in the EPT group compared to the FT group. Conclusion The understanding of function and structure presented here may help inform pedagogical practices by allowing for tailoring of mathematical education through identifying suitable strategy adoption that depends on item type, to circumvent weaknesses in cognitive skills.
BibTeX
@misc{carr2022fractions,
  author = {Sarah J. A. Carr and W. Michael Babinchak and Ana E Istrate and Blaine Martyn-Dow and George Wang and Weicong Chen and Jeremy Fondran and Jing Zhang and Michael Wien and Seo Yeon Yoon and Anne Birnbaum and Elizabeth Roth and Carol A. Gross and Nori Minich and Lee A. Thompson and Won Hwa Kim and Yaakov Stern and Chiara Nosarti and H. Gerry Taylor and Curtis Tatsuoka},
  title = {{Fractions strategy differences in those born extremely preterm}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1101/2022.12.06.519175},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure