FPI: Failure Point Isolation in Large-scale Conversational Assistants

Rinat Khaziev, Usman Shahid, Tobias Röding, Rakesh Chada, Emir Kapanci, Pradeep NatarajanNAACL 2022 · OpenReview

Abstract

Large-scale conversational assistants such as Cortana, Alexa, Google Assistant and Siri process requests through a series of modules for wake word detection, speech recognition, language understanding and response generation. An error in one of these modules can cascade through the system. Given the large traffic volumes in these assistants, it is infeasible to manually analyze the data, identify requests with processing errors and isolate the source of error. We present a machine learning system to address this challenge. First, we embed the incoming request and context, such as system response and subsequent turns, using pre-trained transformer models. Then, we combine these embeddings with encodings of additional metadata features (such as confidence scores from different modules in the online system) using a “mixing-encoder” to output the failure point predictions. Our system obtains 92.2% of human performance on this task while scaling to analyze the entire traffic in 8 different languages of a large-scale conversational assistant. We present detailed ablation studies analyzing the impact of different modeling choices.

Introduction: The Challenge of Cascading Errors

Modern conversational assistants are built as complex pipelines of specialized modules. A typical user request flows through several critical stages: Wake Word Detection, Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR), Natural Language Understanding (NLU), Result Generation, and finally Text-to-Speech (TTS).

The standard modular pipeline of a conversational assistant, where errors in early stages can cascade through the system.

The primary challenge in maintaining these systems is the phenomenon of cascading errors. For instance, if the ASR module mishears a request, the NLU module may correctly process the erroneous text, but the final result will still be incorrect. Identifying the "root cause" or failure point among millions of requests is a massive bottleneck for developers. To address this, researchers at Amazon Alexa AI developed Failure Point Isolation (FPI), a system designed to automatically attribute errors to the specific component responsible.

Methodology: Multi-modal Failure Isolation

The FPI system utilizes a multi-modal transformer-based architecture to automate root cause isolation. Unlike models that rely solely on text, FPI ingests three distinct types of data:

  1. Textual Data: The raw user request and the system's generated response.
  2. Dialog Context: Information from the previous and, crucially, the subsequent turns. A user rephrasing a command in the next turn serves as a strong signal of failure in the current turn.
  3. Metadata Features: Numerical and categorical signals from the live system, such as confidence scores from ASR and NLU engines.
The FPI architecture uses a mixing-encoder to fuse textual embeddings from a language model with numerical and categorical metadata features.

At the core of the architecture is a specialized "mixing-encoder". While standard transformers handle the textual embeddings, the mixing-encoder fuses these with metadata encodings to produce the final failure point prediction. The training process involves a multi-stage approach: fine-tuning the language model on text labels, "warming up" the metadata encoder, and finally jointly fine-tuning the entire stack.

Datasets and Scale

The study utilizes a massive industrial-scale dataset comprising approximately 11.5 million de-identified user requests across 8 different languages. To ensure high-quality evaluation, the researchers established a "Golden" test set of 58,000 sessions. This benchmark was curated using an ensemble of models and multiple highly-trained human experts to establish definitive ground truth for failure attribution.

Key Results and Insights

The best FPI model achieved a macro-average F1 score of 53.3%, reaching 92.2% of human performance on the task. Performance was particularly strong in isolating ASR errors (89.6% of human level) and NLU errors (96.7% of human level).

Key insights from the study include:

  • The Future Explains the Past: Incorporating "next turn" context improved the F1 score by 7.2% absolute. Subsequent user behavior, such as rephrasing a request or saying "Stop," provides implicit negative feedback that helps isolate failures in the preceding turn.
  • Metadata as a Force Multiplier: Text-only models achieved an F1 of only 24.2%. Adding system metadata and context boosted this to over 51%, proving that internal system confidence scores are critical signals for error attribution.
  • Multilingual Robustness: By leveraging multilingual encoders like XLM-R, the system maintains high performance across diverse global deployments.

Limitations and Future Work

While highly effective, the current FPI model assumes a single failure point per session. Future iterations could address scenarios where multiple components fail or aim for higher granularity, such as isolating specific sub-components within the NLU engine. Additionally, integrating FPI with Interaction Quality (IQ) metrics could help prioritize failures based on their perceived severity to the user.

Summary updated

Abstract

Large-scale conversational assistants such as Cortana, Alexa, Google Assistant and Siri process requests through a series of modules for wake word detection, speech recognition, language understanding and response generation. An error in one of these modules can cascade through the system. Given the large traffic volumes in these assistants, it is infeasible to manually analyze the data, identify requests with processing errors and isolate the source of error. We present a machine learning system to address this challenge. First, we embed the incoming request and context, such as system response and subsequent turns, using pre-trained transformer models. Then, we combine these embeddings with encodings of additional metadata features (such as confidence scores from different modules in the online system) using a “mixing-encoder” to output the failure point predictions. Our system obtains 92.2% of human performance on this task while scaling to analyze the entire traffic in 8 different languages of a large-scale conversational assistant. We present detailed ablation studies analyzing the impact of different modeling choices.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{khaziev2022fpi,
  author = {Rinat Khaziev and Usman Shahid and Tobias Röding and Rakesh Chada and Emir Kapanci and Pradeep Natarajan},
  title = {{FPI: Failure Point Isolation in Large-scale Conversational Assistants}},
  booktitle = {Conference of the North American Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2022},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=RVOwJjRDIh},
}
Figure