Foundations and profiles: splicing metaphors in genetic databases and biobanks

Matt RattoPublic Understanding of Science 2005 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper argues that the language used in large-scale scientific projects, specifically the metaphors "foundation" and "profile," plays a crucial role in connecting diverse scientific concepts, interests, and stakeholders. By analyzing these metaphors, the authors reveal a shift in genomics from a focus on sequencing to a more complex understanding of gene-environment interactions in "post-genomic" research.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the challenge of understanding how large-scale scientific projects, like the Human Genome Project (HGP) and its successors, are constructed and maintained. It questions why these projects continue to receive funding despite criticisms and aims to explain how diverse scientific disciplines, policymakers, and other stakeholders are brought together to achieve common goals. The authors highlight the "informational turn" in biology, where the focus shifts from pure discovery to the creation and management of complex data infrastructures.

Methods

The primary method employed is a qualitative analysis of language, specifically focusing on the use of metaphors. The authors introduce the concept of "splicing metaphors" to describe terms that connect disparate ideas, interests, and players within scientific projects. They analyze scientific papers, project reports, and interviews to examine how metaphors like "foundation" (used in the HGP) and "profile" (used in the GenomEUtwin consortium) function to legitimize projects, organize work, and bridge different communities. This approach is framed within a tradition of keyword analysis.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on the analysis of scientific literature, project documents, and interviews rather than empirical datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Splicing Metaphors" as Connectors: The core idea is that metaphors are not just linguistic devices but active tools that "splice" together diverse scientific concepts, organizational interests, and social actors.
  • Shift from "Foundation" to "Profile": The paper identifies a significant shift in the dominant metaphor used in genomics. "Foundation" characterized the HGP as a foundational step for future research, while "profile" in post-genomic projects like GenomEUtwin signifies a more complex, data-driven approach to understanding gene-environment interactions and predicting risk.
  • Post-Genomic Research Complexity: The paper highlights key developments in post-genomic research:
  • Explicit acknowledgement of gene-environment complexity.
  • Use of bioinformatics as exploratory tools, not just for "decoding."
    • Development of networked databases linking diverse data sources.
  • Alignment across disciplines (biology, clinical work, public health).
  • Metaphors as "Boundary Objects": Splicing metaphors function similarly to "boundary objects," uniting diverse interests and managing work without necessarily requiring a single, stable meaning.
  • Legitimization and Organization: Metaphors are crucial for legitimizing scientific projects and organizing the complex collaborations required for their success.

Key Results

The paper does not present quantitative results but rather qualitative insights derived from linguistic analysis. The key "results" are the identification and analysis of "splicing metaphors" and their role in:

  • Characterizing the HGP: The metaphor of "foundation" was used to position the HGP as a crucial, albeit past, step in genomic research, providing a temporal order and justifying its funding.
  • Describing GenomEUtwin: The metaphor of "profile" is shown to be central to post-genomic projects, emphasizing the analysis of genetic and environmental data to create predictive risk profiles. This metaphor moves beyond a purely genetic focus to incorporate environmental and lifestyle factors.
  • Connecting Diverse Interests: Both metaphors are shown to connect various stakeholders, including scientists, policymakers, technology providers, and public health experts, by providing a common language and framing for their work.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Neutral Stance: The authors explicitly state they remain "somewhat neutral as to a normative evaluation" of these projects, their promises, and outcomes. This suggests a limitation in offering a critical judgment on the scientific or societal value of the projects themselves, focusing instead on the linguistic mechanisms.
  • Ethical and Social Problematics: While acknowledging the positive aspects and growing sensitivity to social issues among scientists, the authors point out the ethical and social problematic of distributed networks of scientists trading in genetic information globally, advocating for greater attention to these networks and their research objects.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that terms like "foundation" and "profile" are productive tools for critical analysis, and shifts in metaphoric expression reveal changes in the direction of genetic research. Further analysis of such "splicing metaphors" is encouraged to understand how scientific insights are connected to public and private interests.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper we explore new developments in genomics, in particular the move from data sequencing efforts like the Human Genome Project (HGP), to newer forms of data-driven genomic work that focus explicitly on the complicated relationship between genes and environment. We compare the use of a key term within the HGP, the metaphor of “foundation,” to the use of a different term, the metaphor of “profile,” within the GenomEUtwin consortium, an exemplar of “post-genomic” projects. By doing so, we attempt to re-think the role of language and metaphor in scientific projects and explore new developments in post-genomic research. These developments include: first, the movement towards an explicit and programmatic acknowledgement of the complexity of gene and trait relationships, second, the use of bio-informatics techniques as exploratory tools of discovery rather than as part of a more straightforward “decoding” effort, third, the development of network infrastructures that link up and provide access to a vast array of different databases, and fourth, the alignment between various disciplines and interests within biology, clinical work, and public health initiatives. We use the metaphor of “splicing” to emphasize the heterogeneous work of scientists engaged in “weaving together” the diverse set of ideas, interests, and players necessary for the success of large-scale scientific projects.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ratto2005foundations,
  author = {Matt Ratto},
  title = {{Foundations and profiles: splicing metaphors in genetic databases and biobanks}},
  booktitle = {Public Understanding of Science},
  year = {2005},
  doi = {10.1177/0963662506056786},
}
Figure