Forest emissions reduction assessment from airborne LiDAR data using multiple machine learning approaches

Shize Qin, Yiming Chen, Bo Yang, Kaiwei ZhuFrontiers in Energy Research 2023 · DOI

Abstract

This study evaluates the efficacy of airborne Light Detection and Ranging (LiDAR) and machine learning (ML) for estimating carbon emissions reduction in afforestation projects. Using data from a project in Beijing, China, researchers compared species-specific and all-sample modeling schemes across five ML algorithms. Results indicate that species-specific models, particularly Random Forest and Cubist, achieve high accuracy ($R^2 = 0.89$), outperforming traditional pre-estimation methods and aligning closely with ground-based surveys. These findings suggest that LiDAR-based ML workflows can serve as a reliable and cost-effective technique for Certified Emission Reduction (CER) assessment.

Introduction

To mitigate climate change, many nations invest in afforestation and reforestation (A/R) to capture atmospheric $CO_2$. Converting these efforts into tradable "Certified Emission Reduction" (CER) credits—a cornerstone of carbon offset markets—requires rigorous verification of actual carbon storage. Currently, this verification relies on manual field measurements of tree height and diameter in sample plots. This process is slow, expensive, and prone to sampling errors. While airborne LiDAR has emerged as a powerful tool for mapping forest structure at scale, determining the optimal machine learning algorithms to translate raw laser pulses into reliable carbon data for official certification remains a critical challenge.

Methods and Materials

The study utilized a UAV-based LiDAR system (RIEGL VUX-1LR) to scan a 311.35-hectare afforestation project in Beijing, China. The site contains diverse species, including Pinus tabulaeformis and Robinia pseudoacacia. Ground truth was established by surveying 59 plots, where 303 individual trees were manually measured to calculate biomass using established allometric equations.

Figure 1: Map of the study area in Beijing and visualization of the LiDAR point cloud data used for individual tree segmentation.

The researchers employed a sophisticated processing pipeline:

  1. Individual Tree Segmentation: Using a "normalized cut" (Ncut) algorithm, individual trees were isolated from the point cloud with 98.6% accuracy.
  2. Feature Extraction: Structural parameters were extracted for each tree, including height percentiles (H10 to H99) and "Point Quantity" (N), representing the density of laser returns.
  3. Modeling Schemes: Two approaches were tested: Scheme 1 (Species-Specific modeling) and Scheme 2 (All-Sample modeling).
  4. Algorithms: Five modeling techniques were compared: Random Forest (RF), Cubist, Gradient Boosted Regression Trees (GBRT), Support Vector Regression (SVR), and Generalized Additive Models (GAM).

Key Results and Discussion

The study found that species identity is a crucial factor in model performance. Scheme 1 (species-specific) consistently outperformed the general model (Scheme 2), as different tree architectures distribute biomass differently. In the species-specific scheme, Random Forest (RF) and Cubist achieved the highest prediction accuracy, with an $R^2$ of 0.89 and a Root Mean Square Error (RMSE) of 22.87 kg.

Figure 2: Scatter plots comparing ground-based biomass measurements against model predictions for various algorithms under both species-specific (Scheme 1) and all-sample (Scheme 2) modeling approaches.

Interestingly, the "Number of Points" (N) was often the most important predictor, sometimes exceeding tree height in significance. This suggests that the internal density of the canopy, captured by laser pulse returns, is a vital proxy for wood volume. Furthermore, the LiDAR-based estimates were higher than the pre-estimated values in the Project Design Documents (PDD) but closely matched actual ground measurements. This indicates that current official estimates might be underestimating the carbon-sink potential of these forests.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This research demonstrates that LiDAR-based models using tree structural parameters can accurately assess carbon emissions reduction, outperforming traditional methods in both cost and precision. Once trained, these models can be reused for future surveys, drastically reducing the labor required for carbon sink monitoring.

While the results are promising, future work should focus on increasing sample sizes across diverse climates to improve model transferability. Additionally, the poor performance of simpler statistical models like GAM highlights the need for robust machine learning approaches to handle the complex "noise" of forest point clouds. Ultimately, this workflow could become the global standard for verifying forest carbon offsets, providing a transparent and auditable path for climate mitigation efforts.

Summary updated

Abstract

Objective: This study aims to evaluate the accuracy of different modeling methods and tree structural parameters extracted from airborne LiDAR for estimating carbon emissions reduction and assess their reliability as Certified Emission Reduction (CER) assessment techniques. Methods: LiDAR data was collected from an afforestation project in Beijing, China. Various modeling methods, including statistical regression and machine learning algorithms, were used to estimate biomass and carbon emissions reduction. The models were evaluated under two schemes: tree-species-specific modeling scheme (Scheme 1) and all-sample modeling scheme (Scheme 2) using cross-validation and compared with ground-based estimations and pre-estimated emission reductions. Results: Totally, the biomass estimation models in scheme 1 showed better accuracy than scheme 2. In scheme 1, The Random Forest (RF) and Cubist models achieved the highest prediction accuracy (R 2 = 0.89, RMSE = 22.87 kg, CV RMSE = 52.00 kg), followed by GDBT and Cubist, with SVR and GAM performing the weakest. In scheme 2, Cubist model had the highest accuracy (R 2 = 0.75, RMSE = 33.95 kg, CV RMSE = 36.05 kg), followed by RF and GBDT, with SVR and GAM performing the weakest. LiDAR-based estimates of carbon emissions reduction were closer to ground-based estimations and higher than pre-estimated values. Conclusion: This study demonstrates that LiDAR-based models using tree structural parameters can accurately assess carbon emissions reduction. The models outperformed traditional methods in terms of cost and accuracy. Considering tree species in the modeling process improved the accuracy of the models. LiDAR technology has the potential to be a reliable assessment technique for carbon emissions reduction in forestry projects. The pre-trained models can be used for multiple predictions, reducing the cost of carbon sink surveys. Overall, LiDAR-based models provide a promising approach for assessing carbon emissions reduction and can contribute to mitigating climate change.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{qin2023forest,
  author = {Shize Qin and Yiming Chen and Bo Yang and Kaiwei Zhu},
  title = {{Forest emissions reduction assessment from airborne LiDAR data using multiple machine learning approaches}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Energy Research},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fenrg.2023.1252882},
}
Figure