Forest demography and biomass accumulation rates are associated with transient mean tree size vs. density scaling relations

Kailiang Yu, Han Y. H. Chen, Arthur Geßler, Thomas A. M. Pugh, Eric B. Searle, Robert B. Allen, Hans Pretzsch, Philippe Ciais, Oliver L. Phillips, Roel Brienen, Chengjin Chu, Shubin Xie, Ashley P. BallantynePNAS 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals a crucial link between how forest structure changes over time (mean tree size vs. density scaling) and how much biomass forests accumulate. By developing a new theoretical framework and analyzing a large dataset, the researchers demonstrate that steeper scaling trajectories are associated with higher biomass accumulation rates, offering a new way to predict forest carbon dynamics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Forests play a critical role in global carbon cycles, but accurately predicting their carbon sequestration capacity is challenging. A key concept in forest ecology is the "scaling law" that describes the relationship between mean tree size and tree density within a forest stand as it develops. While this relationship is thought to integrate forest structure and function, its variability across different forest types and its direct connection to demographic processes and carbon dynamics have remained unclear. Previous studies often used a "space-for-time" approach, inferring temporal changes from spatial variations across different stands, which can mask important local dynamics. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a theoretical framework and using a novel temporal approach to quantify this scaling relationship within individual forest stands and link it directly to demographic processes and biomass accumulation.

Methods

The researchers developed a conceptual model based on forest demographic processes (growth and mortality) to explain the transient mean tree size vs. density scaling trajectory. They then compiled a large dataset of long-term forest stand observations. For each stand, they quantified the "temporal scaling slope" (a) by fitting a reduced major axis (RMA) regression to the log-transformed mean tree biomass and tree density over time. This temporal approach, focusing on changes within individual stands, is a key novelty. They then analyzed the association of these temporal scaling slopes with demographic rates (growth and biomass loss from mortality) and biomass accumulation rates across different forest biomes. To investigate environmental influences, they used random forest models and spatial error models (SEMs) to assess the importance of factors like forest age, rainfall seasonality, and soil properties.

Datasets

The study utilized a broad-scale dataset of 1,433 long-term sample forest stands from largely undisturbed forests. These stands were located in:

  • Temperate forests: n = 800 (92 ha)
  • Boreal forests: n = 602 (64 ha)
  • Tropical forests: n = 31 (66 ha)

These forests were located across North and South America, Europe, and Oceania. The data included at least four censuses per stand, with forest stand age information available for many. The authors emphasize that these are largely undisturbed forests, minimizing the confounding effects of recent fires or harvesting.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Temporal vs. Spatial Scaling: The study highlights the crucial difference between inferring scaling relationships from spatial snapshots versus tracking them dynamically over time within a stand. The temporal approach provides a more direct link to demographic processes.
  • Steeper Slopes, More Carbon: A key finding is that steeper (more negative) mean tree size vs. density scaling slopes are strongly associated with higher rates of biomass accumulation. This implies that forests undergoing rapid structural change (growing larger trees while density decreases) are also efficient carbon sinks.
  • Demography is Key: The research firmly links forest structure dynamics to fundamental demographic processes – growth and mortality. The balance between these two dictates the scaling trajectory and, consequently, carbon sequestration.
  • Environmental Influence: Factors like forest age and rainfall seasonality can significantly influence these scaling trajectories, suggesting that climate change and forest maturation will alter carbon dynamics.

Key Results

  • Wide Variation in Scaling Slopes: The temporal scaling slopes (a) varied significantly across forest stands, ranging from -4 to -0.2.
  • Biome Differences: Mean scaling slopes differed across biomes, with boreal forests showing less negative slopes compared to tropical and temperate forests.
  • Biomass Accumulation Link: Steeper scaling slopes were associated with higher biomass accumulation rates. Specifically, forests with higher growth rates and/or lower biomass loss from mortality exhibited more negative scaling slopes.
  • North American Drivers: In North American forests, scaling slopes were positively correlated with forest stand age and rainfall seasonality, suggesting younger forests with lower rainfall seasonality had steeper slopes and thus higher biomass accumulation.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their findings might be less robust in structurally complex forests, particularly in the tropics, where data are currently sparse and size variation among individuals is substantial. They suggest that future research should focus on these complex systems, potentially by aggregating data across spatial and temporal scales to account for disturbances and size structure. Further investigation into the role of decomposition in the carbon cycle and its linkage with forest structure is also recommended. The study also points to the potential of leveraging high-resolution remote-sensing data and size-structured demographic models to improve predictions of forest demography and carbon dynamics at broad scales, building upon the insights gained from this research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Linking individual and stand-level dynamics during forest development reveals a scaling relationship between mean tree size and tree density in forest stands, which integrates forest structure and function. However, the nature of this so-called scaling law and its variation across broad spatial scales remain unquantified, and its linkage with forest demographic processes and carbon dynamics remains elusive. In this study, we develop a theoretical framework and compile a broad-scale dataset of long-term sample forest stands (<i>n</i> = 1,433) from largely undisturbed forests to examine the association of temporal mean tree size vs. density scaling trajectories (slopes) with biomass accumulation rates and the sensitivity of scaling slopes to environmental and demographic drivers. The results empirically demonstrate a large variation of scaling slopes, ranging from -4 to -0.2, across forest stands in tropical, temperate, and boreal forest biomes. Steeper scaling slopes are associated with higher rates of biomass accumulation, resulting from a lower offset of forest growth by biomass loss from mortality. In North America, scaling slopes are positively correlated with forest stand age and rainfall seasonality, thus suggesting a higher rate of biomass accumulation in younger forests with lower rainfall seasonality. These results demonstrate the strong association of the transient mean tree size vs. density scaling trajectories with forest demography and biomass accumulation rates, thus highlighting the potential of leveraging forest structure properties to predict forest demography, carbon fluxes, and dynamics at broad spatial scales.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yu2024forest,
  author = {Kailiang Yu and Han Y. H. Chen and Arthur Geßler and Thomas A. M. Pugh and Eric B. Searle and Robert B. Allen and Hans Pretzsch and Philippe Ciais and Oliver L. Phillips and Roel Brienen and Chengjin Chu and Shubin Xie and Ashley P. Ballantyne},
  title = {{Forest demography and biomass accumulation rates are associated with transient mean tree size vs. density scaling relations}},
  booktitle = {PNAS},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1093/pnasnexus/pgae008},
}
Figure