Foreign Language Teachers’ Self-efficacy Beliefs and Perspectives about Maintaining Their Students’ Interest

Comfort Pratt, Amani Zaier, Yanlin WangJournal of Language Teaching and Research 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Americans do not study foreign languages long enough to achieve communicative competence, posing economic, security, and personal limitations. Despite research on effective teaching methods, students often lose interest. This study investigates the role of teacher self-efficacy (TSE) in maintaining student interest. Through an online survey of foreign language teachers, this mixed-methods study examined beliefs about their impact and general efficacy levels. Findings indicate that while teachers overwhelmingly believe they have a positive impact, their general efficacy is only "mildly high," with no significant correlation between efficacy and the ability to maintain student interest.

Introduction: The Retention Crisis in Language Education

The United States faces a "grim picture" in foreign language education. Despite the clear benefits of multilingualism, most American students discontinue language studies after just two years, far short of communicative competence. While significant research has focused on instructional methods, the "teacher factor" in student retention remains under-explored. This study investigates teacher self-efficacy (TSE)—the belief in one's ability to reach difficult students—to understand how educators perceive their role in breaking the cycle of declining enrollments.

Methods and Data

The researchers surveyed 120 foreign language teachers across the U.S., ranging from middle school to college levels. The sample was 72.5% female, with a mean age of 36.5 years. Languages taught included Spanish (55%), Chinese, French, and German. Over half (52.5%) were native speakers, with experience ranging from one semester to 32 years.

Two primary instruments were used:

  1. Teacher Academic and Demographic Questionnaire (TAD): Captured background data and a binary assessment of whether teachers believed they positively impacted student interest.
  2. Foreign Language Teachers’ Sense of Efficacy Scale (FLTSE): A 31-item scale measuring efficacy across four Bandurian sources: performance accomplishment, vicarious experience, verbal persuasion, and emotional arousal.

Results and Discussion: The Perception Gap

The study revealed a stark disconnect between teacher optimism and professional efficacy. While 91.67% of teachers believed they had a positive impact on student interest, their actual measured efficacy scores told a more nuanced story.

Table 1: Foreign Language Teachers’ Sources of Efficacy Scale results showing mean scores and rank orders for various efficacy items.

As shown in the data, teachers scored highest in the "Emotional Arousal" category. For instance, "I feel happy when I teach well" (Item 29) ranked first with a mean of 89.07. Conversely, they scored lowest in "Performance Accomplishment" items related to specific training and error management. Item 3 ("I have not made mistakes...") and Item 6 ("I have been trained to deal with many of the learning difficulties...") ranked 31st and 30th, respectively. This suggests that while teachers are passionate about their work, they may feel under-equipped to handle the technical challenges of student retention and learning difficulties.

Statistical analysis further highlighted this gap. The overall mean FLTSE score was 69.85 out of 100 ("mildly high"), but the correlation between this score and the belief in positive impact was negligible (r = 0.13). Furthermore, demographic factors like age, gender, and experience did not predict a teacher's perceived impact, suggesting these beliefs may be subjective rather than outcome-based.

Conclusion and Implications

The findings suggest that teacher optimism may mask a critical need for specialized training. To break the cycle of student attrition, teacher preparation programs must move beyond linguistic instruction to include specific strategies for maintaining student interest.

Future research should bridge the "perception gap" by matching teacher self-reports with objective student interest levels and performance data. Qualitative interviews could further clarify why teachers maintain high confidence despite the national trend of declining language study.

Summary updated

Abstract

Americans do not study foreign languages long enough to achieve communicative competence, and that poses economic and security problems for the nation as well as career and personal limitations for individuals. Despite the plethora of research studies on effective approaches and methods for teaching foreign languages, there is evidence in the literature that foreign language students often experience a loss of interest in the languages, and there is a critical need to investigate the causes of the lack of interest and propose solutions. To that end, this study took a look at the possible role played by teachers’ self-efficacy beliefs in their ability or inability to maintain their students’ interest in the target languages. By means of an online survey administered to foreign language teachers, this mixed methods study investigated their beliefs about their ability to impact their students positively and their general level of efficacy for teaching foreign languages. Findings revealed that the teachers overwhelmingly believed that they had a positive impact. However, their general level of efficacy was mildly high and there was no significant correlation between the teachers’ sense of efficacy and their ability to maintain their students’ interest in the languages. Implications for foreign language teacher preparation and professional development point to the need to develop a strong sense of efficacy as well as strategies for positively impacting students to maintain their interest in the language.
BibTeX
@article{pratt2021foreign,
  author = {Comfort Pratt and Amani Zaier and Yanlin Wang},
  title = {{Foreign Language Teachers’ Self-efficacy Beliefs and Perspectives about Maintaining Their Students’ Interest}},
  journal = {Journal of Language Teaching and Research},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.17507/jltr.1201.02},
}
Figure