Foreign Direct Investment, Financial Development and Political Risks

Nabamita Dutta, Sanjukta Roy2010 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how financial development impacts foreign direct investment (FDI), revealing a non-linear relationship where too much financial development can actually deter FDI. Crucially, political stability acts as a moderator, shifting the point at which financial development becomes detrimental to FDI, suggesting that a stable political environment is essential for maximizing the benefits of financial development for attracting foreign capital.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the complex relationship between a nation's financial development (FD) and its ability to attract foreign direct investment (FDI). While it's generally accepted that a well-developed financial sector is beneficial for economic growth and can facilitate investment, the exact nature of this relationship with FDI is not fully understood. Specifically, the authors question whether a continuously increasing level of financial development always leads to more FDI, or if there's a point of diminishing returns or even a negative impact. Furthermore, they explore how political factors, often overlooked in this context, might influence this FD-FDI dynamic. The gap identified is the lack of research that specifically examines the interplay between political risks, financial development, and FDI inflows.

Methods

The authors employ panel data regression analysis using a dataset of 97 countries over a 20-year period (1984-2003). Their primary regression specification includes FDI inflow as the dependent variable and financial development (FD) and its squared term (FD²) as key independent variables. The inclusion of FD² is a standard econometric technique to capture non-linear relationships, allowing them to test for a concave or convex relationship. They also incorporate a range of control variables, including economic growth, inflation, exchange rate, trade openness, population, regional dummies, and time dummies.

A significant part of their methodology involves introducing political risk indicators from the International Country Risk Guide (ICRG) database. They test the impact of these political risk factors individually and, importantly, their interaction with financial development. This interaction term is crucial for understanding how political stability moderates the FD-FDI relationship. They use both OLS and Feasible Generalized Least Square (FGLS) estimation methods to account for potential issues like autocorrelation.

Datasets

The study utilizes data from several reputable sources:

  • Foreign Direct Investment (FDI): United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) database.
  • Financial Development (FD): Beck, Demirguc-Kunt and Levine (2000) database and World Development Indicators (WDI) 2005.
  • Control Variables:
    • Growth, Population, Inflation, Exchange Rate: World Bank World Development Indicators (WDI) 2005, Penn World Table.
  • Trade Openness: Penn World Table.
  • Natural Resources: Sachs and Warner database.
  • Schooling: Barro and Lee (2000) dataset.
  • Political Risk Indicators: International Country Risk Guide (ICRG) database.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Too Much Finance" Paradox for FDI: The most striking insight is that financial development doesn't always lead to more FDI. Beyond a certain threshold, further financial development can actually reduce FDI inflows. This suggests that while a functional financial system is attractive, an overly complex or potentially unstable one might deter foreign investors.
  • Political Stability as a Crucial Enabler: Political stability is not just a background factor; it actively shapes the FD-FDI relationship. Higher political stability shifts the "sweet spot" for financial development to attract FDI to higher levels, meaning a country can have more developed financial markets without negatively impacting FDI if it's politically stable.
  • Non-Linearity is Key: The relationship is not a simple linear one. The quadratic term for financial development is essential for capturing the nuanced, concave relationship observed.
  • Specific Political Risks Matter: Not all political risks are equal. The study identifies specific factors like Government Stability, Law and Order, Investment Profile, Bureaucratic Quality, and Socio-economic Condition as having a significant positive impact on the FD-FDI nexus.

Key Results

  • Concave Relationship: The primary regression results show a statistically significant positive coefficient for Financial Development and a negative coefficient for its squared term, confirming a concave (inverted U-shaped) relationship between FD and FDI inflows.
  • Threshold Effect: A critical threshold for financial development is identified at approximately 1.3. Before this level, FD positively impacts FDI. Beyond this point, further increases in FD lead to diminishing FDI inflows.
  • Moderating Role of Political Risk: The interaction term between financial development and political risk is positive and significant, indicating that higher political stability enhances the positive impact of financial development on FDI. For instance, with higher government stability, the threshold level of financial development beyond which FDI is negatively affected shifts to higher values.
  • Significant Political Risk Factors: Among the political risk factors, Government Stability, Law and Order, Investment Profile, Bureaucratic Quality, and Socio-economic Condition were found to have significant positive coefficients, suggesting their importance in facilitating FDI.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Limitations: The study uses data up to 2003. More recent data could reveal evolving trends. The paper also notes that alternative data sources for FDI were considered later, implying potential data nuances.
  • Causality: While the study explores the relationship, establishing definitive causality can be challenging in macro-economic studies. The authors use panel data and specific econometric techniques to address this, but it remains a general limitation.
  • Specific Mechanisms: While the study identifies that political risk matters, the precise mechanisms through which it alters the FD-FDI threshold could be further explored. For example, how does government stability specifically influence investor confidence in a financially developed market?
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further analysis by breaking down the sample by financial development levels to understand the relationship across different stages of development. They also implicitly suggest that exploring other political risk indicators or different measures of financial development could yield further insights.

Summary updated

Abstract

Financial development is definitely a determinant of the extent of foreign direct investment (FDI) inflow into an economy. Yet, the contribution of financial development (FD) can be dependent on the political situation of the recipient nation. Higher political stability aids financial institutions to reap the benefits of FDI efficiently. Our paper empirically investigates the role of political risk in the association of FDI and FD. Using a panel of 97 countries, we show the relationship to be strictly non-linear. The impact of FD on FDI becomes negative beyond a threshold level of FD. However, we do find political risk factors to be affecting the relationship by altering the threshold level of financial development.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dutta2010foreign,
  author = {Nabamita Dutta and Sanjukta Roy},
  title = {{Foreign Direct Investment, Financial Development and Political Risks}},
  booktitle = {˜The},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.1353/jda.0.0106},
}
Figure