FOREGROUNDS IN WIDE-FIELD REDSHIFTED 21 cm POWER SPECTRA

Nithyanandan Thyagarajan, Daniel Jacobs, Judd D. Bowman, N. Barry, Adam P. Beardsley, G. Bernardi, F. Briggs, R. J. Cappallo, P. Carroll, B. E. Corey, A. de Oliveira‐Costa, Joshua S. Dillon, D. Emrich, Aaron Ewall‐Wice, L. Feng, R. Goeke, L. J. Greenhill, B. J. Hazelton, Jacqueline N. Hewitt, N. Hurley‐Walker, M. Johnston‐Hollitt, D. L. Kaplan, J. C. Kasper, Han-Seek Kim, Piyanat Kittiwisit, E. Kratzenberg, E. Lenc, J. Line, Abraham Loeb, C. J. Lonsdale, M. J. Lynch, B. McKinley, S. R. McWhirter, D. A. Mitchell, M. F. Morales, E. Morgan, Abraham R. Neben, Divya Oberoi, A. R. Offringa, S. M. Ord, Sourabh Paul, B. Pindor, J. C. Pober, T. Prabu, P. Procopio, J. Riding, A. E. E. Rogers, D. Anish Roshi, N. Udaya Shankar, Shiv K. Sethi, K. S. Srivani, R. Subrahmanyan, Ian Sullivan, Max Tegmark, S. J. Tingay, Cathryn M. Trott, M. Waterson, R. B. Wayth, R. L. Webster, A. R. Whitney, A. Williams, Christopher Williams, Chen Wu2016

TL;DR

Detecting the faint 21cm signal from the early universe is incredibly challenging due to overwhelming foreground emission. This paper uses a novel "delay spectrum" technique to map foreground sources and demonstrates that the shape of radio telescope antennas significantly impacts how much foreground contamination enters the data. They propose a method to selectively down-weight problematic data, potentially reducing foreground contamination by a factor of 100.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The epoch of reionization (EoR) is a crucial period in cosmic history when the first stars and galaxies ionized the neutral hydrogen filling the universe. Detecting the faint 21cm emission from this era is a primary goal for understanding cosmic evolution. However, this signal is orders of magnitude weaker than the foreground radio emission from our own galaxy and extragalactic sources. Traditional methods of analyzing this data often involve discarding large portions of the data to avoid foregrounds, leading to a loss of sensitivity. This paper tackles the problem of understanding and mitigating these foregrounds, particularly in the context of wide-field radio interferometers.

Methods

The authors employ the delay spectrum technique, which transforms radio interferometer data (visibilities) from the frequency domain to a "delay" domain. This technique is particularly useful because it directly maps foreground sources to their signal delays between antenna pairs, effectively locating them in a way that is sensitive to both spatial and spectral properties. They also utilize a high-fidelity instrumental model that accounts for the specific antenna shapes and their power patterns, as well as an all-sky foreground model that includes both diffuse Galactic emission and bright extragalactic point sources. By simulating observations with different antenna geometries (dipole, phased array, and dish) and comparing these simulations to actual data from the Murchison Widefield Array (MWA), they can isolate and understand the impact of various foreground components and instrumental effects.

Datasets

The paper uses observational data from the Murchison Widefield Array (MWA). For their foreground model, they leverage existing radio source catalogs such as the NRAO VLA Sky Survey (NVSS) and the Sydney University Molonglo Sky Survey (SUMSS), along with diffuse foreground models derived from surveys like the Haslam et al. (1982) 408 MHz map.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Wide-field effects are crucial: Even with large antenna spacings, which typically probe small angular scales, foreground contamination is significantly influenced by emission from far off the primary field of view, especially near the horizon. This is a generic effect for all wide-field instruments.
  • Antenna shape matters immensely: The geometry of the antenna's power pattern plays a critical role in determining the level of foreground contamination. Dish antennas, with their more focused primary beams and suppressed side lobes, are significantly better at minimizing foregrounds compared to dipoles or phased arrays.
  • The "Pitchfork" signature: A characteristic "pitchfork" signature emerges in the delay spectrum, formed by the combination of compact emission dominating the primary field of view and diffuse emission near the horizon. This signature is a key indicator of foreground contamination.
  • Horizon emission is a major culprit: The most impactful foreground signatures arise not from sources directly in the telescope's main view, but from bright emission near the horizon, particularly diffuse Galactic emission.
  • Selective data down-weighting is effective: By understanding the location and nature of foreground sources, it's possible to selectively down-weight or discard data from specific antenna spacings and times that are most affected, leading to substantial foreground mitigation with minimal loss of scientific data.

Key Results

  • Simulations demonstrate that dish antennas can reduce foreground contamination in the "EoR window" by orders of magnitude compared to dipoles or phased arrays.
  • The "pitchfork" signature, a combination of compact and diffuse foreground emission, is predicted to be imprinted on the "foreground wedge" of delay spectra.
  • By analyzing MWA data and simulations, the authors show that removing short, eastward-oriented antenna spacings can reduce foreground contamination by a factor of ~100, with a negligible loss of data (around 5% for baselines < 30m).
  • The paper provides a quantitative comparison between simulated and observed MWA delay spectra, showing good agreement within expected uncertainties.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Thermal noise limitations: The "pitchfork" signature is only marginally visible in the current short MWA observations due to thermal noise. Deeper observations are needed to reveal this feature more clearly.
  • Model uncertainties: While the simulations show good agreement with data, there are still uncertainties in the foreground models and instrumental parameters. Further refinement of these models and more comprehensive calibration techniques are necessary.
  • Generalizability of the technique: The proposed baseline-based mitigation technique is demonstrated using the MWA as an example. Future work will involve generalizing this approach to other instruments and optimizing the selection criteria for discarding or down-weighting data based on specific instrument configurations and sky conditions.
  • More sophisticated estimators: While the delay spectrum is a useful tool, more advanced power spectrum estimation techniques could potentially extract even more information from the data and further improve foreground mitigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Detection of 21 cm emission of H i from the epoch of reionization, at redshifts z > 6, is limited primarily by foreground emission. We investigate the signatures of wide-field measurements and an all-sky foreground model using the delay spectrum technique that maps the measurements to foreground object locations through signal delays between antenna pairs. We demonstrate interferometric measurements are inherently sensitive to all scales, including the largest angular scales, owing to the nature of wide-field measurements. These wide-field effects are generic to all observations but antenna shapes impact their amplitudes substantially. A dish-shaped antenna yields the most desirable features from a foreground contamination viewpoint, relative to a dipole or a phased array. Comparing data from recent Murchison Widefield Array observations, we demonstrate that the foreground signatures that have the largest impact on the H i signal arise from power received far away from the primary field of view. We identify diffuse emission near the horizon as a significant contributing factor, even on wide antenna spacings that usually represent structures on small scales. For signals entering through the primary field of view, compact emission dominates the foreground contamination. These two mechanisms imprint a characteristic pitchfork signature on the "foreground wedge" in Fourier delay space. Based on these results, we propose that selective down-weighting of data based on antenna spacing and time can mitigate foreground contamination substantially by a factor of ~100 with negligible loss of sensitivity.
BibTeX
@misc{thyagarajan2016foregrounds,
  author = {Nithyanandan Thyagarajan and Daniel Jacobs and Judd D. Bowman and N. Barry and Adam P. Beardsley and G. Bernardi and F. Briggs and R. J. Cappallo and P. Carroll and B. E. Corey and A. de Oliveira‐Costa and Joshua S. Dillon and D. Emrich and Aaron Ewall‐Wice and L. Feng and R. Goeke and L. J. Greenhill and B. J. Hazelton and Jacqueline N. Hewitt and N. Hurley‐Walker and M. Johnston‐Hollitt and D. L. Kaplan and J. C. Kasper and Han-Seek Kim and Piyanat Kittiwisit and E. Kratzenberg and E. Lenc and J. Line and Abraham Loeb and C. J. Lonsdale and M. J. Lynch and B. McKinley and S. R. McWhirter and D. A. Mitchell and M. F. Morales and E. Morgan and Abraham R. Neben and Divya Oberoi and A. R. Offringa and S. M. Ord and Sourabh Paul and B. Pindor and J. C. Pober and T. Prabu and P. Procopio and J. Riding and A. E. E. Rogers and D. Anish Roshi and N. Udaya Shankar and Shiv K. Sethi and K. S. Srivani and R. Subrahmanyan and Ian Sullivan and Max Tegmark and S. J. Tingay and Cathryn M. Trott and M. Waterson and R. B. Wayth and R. L. Webster and A. R. Whitney and A. Williams and Christopher Williams and Chen Wu},
  title = {{FOREGROUNDS IN WIDE-FIELD REDSHIFTED 21 cm POWER SPECTRA}},
  year = {2016},
}
Figure