This 1992 paper by Mao Rui provides a robust framework for calculating and forecasting water evaporation from Taihu Lake, one of China's largest freshwater bodies. By comparing three classical models and developing a simplified forecasting tool, the author demonstrates how evaporation data can be used to predict critical water level changes during extreme droughts and floods.
TL;DR
The research establishes a specialized forecasting model for Taihu Lake that translates standard weather forecasts (temperature and rain days) into accurate evaporation estimates. This model allows water managers to predict water level declines with less than 15% error, providing a vital tool for drought relief and flood control.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Taihu Lake is a massive but shallow "typical shallow lake" (average depth only 1.89m). Because of its high surface-area-to-volume ratio, evaporation is not just a minor variable—it is a dominant force in the lake's hydrology. In dry years, evaporation can account for 50% of the lake's total water output.
During the "mid-summer droughts" (伏旱) common to the region, the lake essentially becomes a giant "evaporation pan." For example, in August 1978, the lake lost 1/10th of its total storage to the atmosphere in a single month. Conversely, during summer waterlogging (夏涝), the lake often becomes a "closed" system where outlets are blocked; in these cases, evaporation is the primary mechanism for lowering dangerous water levels. The challenge addressed here is that direct measurement of lake evaporation is technically difficult, necessitating reliable mathematical models that can work with standard meteorological data.
Methods
The author evaluates three primary calculation methods using data from the Yixing Lake Station:
- Climate Index Model (Dalton-type): Relates evaporation to wind speed and the vapor pressure gradient between the water surface and the air.
- Difference Method: An energy balance approach that calculates the difference in energy flux between the lake and nearby evaporation pans.
- Modified Penman Equation: A combination of energy balance and aerodynamic theory, adjusted for the specific conditions of Taihu.
The paper’s core contribution is the Summer Evaporation Forecasting Model. Recognizing that variables like "water surface temperature" are rarely available in a standard 3-day or 10-day weather forecast, the author uses the Magnus formula and empirical correlations to transform the complex Dalton-type model into a function of forecastable variables: air temperature, relative humidity, and the number of rainy days.
Datasets
The study relies on long-term observational data from the Yixing Lake Station on the western shore of Taihu:
- Primary Data: Evaporation records from 100m² and 20m² large-scale evaporation pools.
- Timeframes: Two main periods: 1964–1969 and 1988–1990.
- Validation Data: Meteorological data (wind speed, vapor pressure, temperature) from six surrounding stations (Wuxi, Suzhou, Dongshan, Wujiang, Huzhou, and Yixing).
Key Insights and Ideas
- The "Heat Storage" Pitfall: The author notes that while the Penman method is theoretically sound, it fails to account for the lake's heat storage. Consequently, it overestimates evaporation in the spring (when the lake is absorbing heat to warm up) and underestimates it in the autumn (when the lake is releasing stored heat).
- Rainy Days as a Proxy: A key "aha" moment in the forecasting model is the discovery that relative humidity in the Taihu region during summer is highly correlated with the number of days with precipitation $\ge$ 10mm. This allows the model to use simple "rainy day" counts from a weather forecast to estimate atmospheric moisture.
- The "Closed Lake" Phenomenon: In 1991, before major drainage projects were completed, Taihu acted as a "closed lake" during floods—water could come in, but couldn't easily get out. In such scenarios, the author proves that evaporation becomes the deciding factor in how fast the floodwaters recede.
Key Results
- Model Accuracy: The proposed forecasting model (Equation 12 in the paper) was tested against historical data from 1964 and 1965. The predicted values closely matched the "Difference Method" results, with relative errors generally staying below 10%.
- Water Level Prediction: By combining the evaporation forecast with a simple water balance equation, the author could predict the daily decline in lake levels ($\Delta h$). For the drought years of 1966, 1971, and 1978, the model's predicted water level drops matched actual observations with a relative error of less than 15%.
- Evaporation Intensity: The data quantified the extreme nature of the "evaporation pan" effect, showing daily evaporation rates exceeding 0.7cm for 11–14 days during peak drought months.
Limitations and Future Work
The paper acknowledges that the model relies on historical averages for wind speed ($W_{10}$), as wind is notoriously difficult to forecast accurately over 10-day periods. Additionally, the model assumes a relatively uniform response across the lake based on the Yixing station data.
Future work (as of 1992) suggested integrating these evaporation models into larger, automated hydrological dispatching systems to better manage the "骨干性排水工程" (backbone drainage projects) then under construction. Modern researchers might look to update these empirical coefficients using satellite-derived surface temperatures and more granular spatial data.
Summary updated