Forecasting model for short-term wind speed using robust local mean decomposition, deep neural networks, intelligent algorithm, and error correction

Jiawen Li, Minghao Liu, Lei WenFrontiers in Energy Research 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a sophisticated hybrid model that combines signal decomposition (RLMD), deep learning (BiGRU), and a "crazy" swarm intelligence algorithm to predict short-term wind speeds. By adding a dedicated error-correction module powered by a Deep Extreme Learning Machine, the system significantly outperforms traditional models, offering a more reliable tool for power grid stability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As the world shifts toward renewable energy, wind power has become a cornerstone of the green transition. However, wind is notoriously "fickle." Its inherent intermittency and volatility—what engineers call non-stationarity—make it a nightmare for power grid operators who need to balance supply and demand in real-time.

Existing forecasting models often struggle with the "noise" in raw wind data. Simple statistical models fail to capture complex nonlinear patterns, while standard deep learning models can get bogged down by the chaotic nature of atmospheric signals. The gap this paper fills is the need for a system that can both simplify the raw data and "learn from its own mistakes" through a dedicated error-correction phase.

Methods

The authors propose a four-stage pipeline dubbed RLMD-O-BiGRU-ISSA-DELM:

  1. Data Decomposition (RLMD): The team uses Robust Local Mean Decomposition to break down messy, non-stationary wind signals into a series of simpler components called Product Functions. Unlike older methods (like EMD), RLMD is better at avoiding "mode mixing," where different physical features get blurred together.
  2. The Main Predictor (BiGRU): They employ a Bidirectional Gated Recurrent Unit. While standard GRUs look at past data, the bidirectional version processes the sequence in both directions, capturing deeper temporal dependencies.
  3. Intelligent Optimization (SSA & ISSA): To find the perfect hyperparameters (like learning rate and neuron count), they use the Salp Swarm Algorithm. They further improved this into the ISSA by adding a "crazy operator"—a stochastic perturbation that prevents the algorithm from getting stuck in local optima—and a dynamic learning strategy.
  4. Error Correction (DELM): This is the "secret sauce." The model takes the errors from the BiGRU stage and feeds them into a Deep Extreme Learning Machine (DELM). This second model learns the patterns within the prediction errors to refine the final forecast.

Datasets

The model was validated using real-world data from a wind farm in central China.

  • Timeframes: Two distinct datasets from January and July were used to account for seasonal variations.
  • Granularity: Data was collected at 10-minute intervals (144 points per day).
  • Setup: The first 15 days of each month were used for training, with the final days reserved for testing one-step, two-step, and three-step ahead forecasts.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Decomposition is Essential: The paper confirms that trying to predict raw wind speed is a losing game. Breaking the signal into sub-frequencies (RLMD) allows the neural network to focus on specific trends rather than being overwhelmed by noise.
  • The "Crazy Operator" Works: Swarm intelligence algorithms often suffer from "premature convergence" (finding a "good enough" solution and stopping). By introducing the "crazy operator" in the ISSA, the researchers forced the algorithm to keep exploring the search space, leading to much better neural network tuning.
  • Learning from Mistakes: Most models stop after the first prediction. By treating the error as a signal to be modeled itself, the DELM module effectively "polishes" the results, capturing residual patterns that the BiGRU missed.

Key Results

The hybrid model consistently outperformed benchmarks like standard LSTMs, BPs, and even other decomposition-based models (like EMD-BiGRU).

  • Accuracy: In the January dataset (1-step prediction), the proposed model achieved a Mean Absolute Percentage Error (MAPE) of 2.72%, compared to 6.18% for a standard optimized BiGRU and 6.53% for a traditional BP network.
  • Error Reduction: The error-correction module (ISSA-DELM) alone improved the initial prediction accuracy by an average of 10% to 20% across different metrics.
  • Statistical Significance: The team used the Diebold-Mariano (DM) test, which statistically proved that their model’s superiority wasn't just a fluke of the dataset but a genuine architectural improvement.

Limitations and Future Work

While the results are impressive, the authors acknowledge a few hurdles:

  • Geographic Specificity: The model was tested on data from only one region in China. Wind patterns vary wildly across different terrains (e.g., offshore vs. mountainous).
  • Feature Set: The current model relies almost exclusively on historical wind speed data. The authors suggest that future iterations should incorporate other meteorological variables like temperature, humidity, and air pressure to create a "multi-input" forecasting system.
  • Sampling Sensitivity: Different sampling frequencies can change the chaotic characteristics of the data, which might require re-tuning the RLMD parameters.

Summary updated

Abstract

Wind power generation has aroused widespread concern worldwide. Accurate prediction of wind speed is very important for the safe and economic operation of the power grid. This paper presents a short-term wind speed prediction model which includes data decomposition, deep learning, intelligent algorithm optimization, and error correction modules. First, the robust local mean decomposition (RLMD) is applied to the original wind speed data to reduce the non-stationarity of the data. Then, the salp swarm algorithm (SSA) is used to determine the optimal parameter combination of the bidirectional gated recurrent unit (BiGRU) to ensure prediction quality. In order to eliminate the predictable components of the error further, a correction module based on the improved salp swarm algorithm (ISSA) and deep extreme learning machine (DELM) is constructed. The exploration and exploitation capability of the original SSA is enhanced by introducing a crazy operator and dynamic learning strategy, and the input weights and thresholds in the DELM are optimized by the ISSA to improve the generalization ability of the model. The actual data of wind farms are used to verify the advancement of the proposed model. Compared with other models, the results show that the proposed model has the best prediction performance. As a powerful tool, the developed forecasting system is expected to be further used in the energy system.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2024forecasting,
  author = {Jiawen Li and Minghao Liu and Lei Wen},
  title = {{Forecasting model for short-term wind speed using robust local mean decomposition, deep neural networks, intelligent algorithm, and error correction}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Energy Research},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/fenrg.2023.1336675},
}
Figure