Forecast of lacustrine shale lithofacies types in continental rift basins based on machine learning: A case study from Dongying Sag, Jiyang Depression, Bohai Bay Basin, China

Zhengwei Fang, Liqiang Zhang, Shicui YanFrontiers in Earth Science 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a machine learning-based approach to accurately predict complex shale rock types (lithofacies) in continental rift basins. By fusing traditional well-logging data with paleoenvironmental chemical markers and using a "curve shape-to-point" data extraction method, the team achieved a 98% accuracy rate in identifying the most favorable zones for shale oil extraction.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Identifying the right "lithofacies"—the specific type of rock characterized by its mineral composition and microstructure—is the "holy grail" for shale oil exploration. In marine shales, this is relatively straightforward because the environment is stable. However, lacustrine shales (formed in ancient lakes) are incredibly messy. They change rapidly across short distances and depths due to fluctuating lake levels, climate shifts, and sediment sources.

Standard geophysical tools, like well logging, measure physical properties (density, radioactivity, etc.) but often fail to distinguish between subtle rock textures that determine whether a well will be productive. This "blind spot" in conventional methods restricts the efficiency of shale oil development in complex regions like China's Bohai Bay Basin.

Methods

The authors compared two heavy hitters in supervised learning: Support Vector Machines (SVM) and Extreme Gradient Boosting (XGBoost). To move beyond standard industry practices, they introduced three key tactical shifts:

  1. Granular Classification: Instead of broad categories, they used core samples and 753 thin sections to reclassify the shale into 22 distinct lithofacies types based on mineralogy and microstructure.
  2. Data Fusion: They didn't just use well logs. They integrated paleoenvironmental parameters derived from X-ray fluorescence (XRF) scanning, such as Rb/Sr ratios (climate), Sr % (salinity), and Ti % (sediment source).
  3. Curve Shape-to-Point Extraction: Standard ML models often look at a single data point at a specific depth. The authors used a "curve shape" approach, which pulls data from the surrounding depth interval to capture the morphology of the log curve, providing the model with much-needed context about vertical trends.

Datasets

The study focused on Well FY1 in the Dongying Sag of the Bohai Bay Basin, China.

  • Core Data: 195 meters of continuous core from the upper $Es_4$ member.
  • Logging Data: 1,561 sampling points covering five parameters (Gamma Ray, Resistivity, Acoustic Slowness, Density, and Neutron logging).
  • Elemental Data: 2,334 data points obtained via handheld XRF, measuring over 20 elements to calculate paleoenvironmental indicators.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of "Context": The "curve shape-to-point" method outperformed "point-to-point" extraction by 7–8%. This suggests that the trend of the data (e.g., a sharpening or fining upwards sequence) is more diagnostic of rock type than the absolute value at a single depth.
  • Chemical Memory: Adding paleoenvironmental data improved accuracy by up to 28%. This is because the chemical "memory" of the lake's salinity and climate at the time of deposition is a stronger proxy for mineralogy than physical density alone.
  • The "45-Group" Rule: The researchers found a clear threshold for training: once the number of learning samples for a specific lithofacies exceeded 45, forecast accuracy jumped to over 90%. Below this, the models struggled to generalize.
  • The Overlap Challenge: Some lithofacies remain difficult to distinguish because their physical and chemical signatures overlap significantly (e.g., different types of laminated mudstones). This highlights that even with ML, geological "noise" is a persistent hurdle.

Key Results

  • Top Performer: The SVM model using combined logging and paleo-data with curve-shape extraction was the winner.
  • Overall Accuracy: Reached 68% across all 22 complex lithofacies types—a significant feat given the high degree of heterogeneity.
  • Target Accuracy: For "favorable" lithofacies (the ones actually targeted for oil), the model hit an impressive 98% accuracy.
  • Synergy: Using both logging and paleo-data was 7%–28% more accurate than using either dataset in isolation.

Limitations and Future Work

While the results are promising, the authors note that the high degree of heterogeneity within a single lithofacies (such as thin laminae of different minerals) still causes data overlap that confuses the models.

Future work will likely focus on:

  • Microstructure Integration: Incorporating more quantitative data on rock micro-textures.
  • Algorithm Optimization: Refining the SVM and XGBoost hyperparameters further or exploring deep learning architectures that naturally handle sequence/curve data (like CNNs or LSTMs).
  • Global Scaling: Testing this multi-proxy ML approach in other continental rift basins globally to see if the "45-group" rule and paleo-data fusion hold up in different geological settings.

Summary updated

Abstract

Lacustrine shale in continental rift basins is complex and features a variety of mineralogical compositions and microstructures. The lithofacies type of shale, mainly determined by mineralogical composition and microstructure, is the most critical factor controlling the quality of shale oil reservoirs. Conventional geophysical methods cannot accurately forecast lacustrine shale lithofacies types, thus restricting the progress of shale oil exploration and development. Considering the lacustrine shale in the upper Es 4 member of the Dongying Sag in the Jiyang Depression, Bohai Bay Basin, China, as the research object, the lithofacies type was forecast based on two machine learning methods: support vector machine (SVM) and extreme gradient boosting (XGBoost). To improve the forecast accuracy, we applied the following approaches: first, using core and thin section analyses of consecutively cored wells, the lithofacies were finely reclassified into 22 types according to mineralogical composition and microstructure, and the vertical change of lithofacies types was obtained. Second, in addition to commonly used well logging data, paleoenvironment parameter data (Rb/Sr ratio, paleoclimate parameter; Sr %, paleosalinity parameter; Ti %, paleoprovenance parameter; Fe/Mn ratio, paleo-water depth parameter; P/Ti ratio, paleoproductivity parameter) were applied to the forecast. Third, two sample extraction modes, namely, curve shape-to-points and point-to-point, were used in the machine learning process. Finally, the lithofacies type forecast was carried out under six different conditions. In the condition of selecting the curved shape-to-point sample extraction mode and inputting both well logging and paleoenvironment parameter data, the SVM method achieved the highest average forecast accuracy for all lithofacies types, reaching 68%, as well as the highest average forecast accuracy for favorable lithofacies types at 98%. The forecast accuracy for all lithofacies types improved by 7%–28% by using both well logging and paleoenvironment parameter data rather than using one or the other, and was 7%–8% higher by using the curve shape-to-point sample extraction mode compared to the point-to-point sample extraction mode. In addition, the learning sample quantity and data value overlap of different lithofacies types affected the forecast accuracy. The results of our study confirm that machine learning is an effective solution to forecast lacustrine shale lithofacies. When adopting machine learning methods, increasing the learning sample quantity (>45 groups), selecting the curve shape-to-point sample extraction mode, and using both well logging and paleoenvironment parameter data are effective ways to improve the forecast accuracy of lacustrine shale lithofacies types. The method and results of this study provide guidance to accurately forecast the lacustrine shale lithofacies types in new shale oil wells and will promote the harvest of lacustrine shale oil globally.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{fang2023forecast,
  author = {Zhengwei Fang and Liqiang Zhang and Shicui Yan},
  title = {{Forecast of lacustrine shale lithofacies types in continental rift basins based on machine learning: A case study from Dongying Sag, Jiyang Depression, Bohai Bay Basin, China}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Earth Science},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/feart.2023.1047981},
}
Figure